Informal enumerative geometry seminar
Informal Enumerative Geometry Seminar
Spring 2022
Notes by Patrick Lei
Lectures by Various
Columbia University
Disclaimer
These notes were taken during the seminar using the vimtex package of the editor neovim. Any errors are mine and not the speakers’. In addition, my notes are picture-free (but will include commutative diagrams) and are a mix of my mathematical style and that of the lecturers. If you find any errors, please contact me at plei@math.columbia.edu.
Seminar Website: https://www.math.columbia.edu/~ccliu/Seminars/IEG_S22.html
1 Melissa (Feb 03): Virtual fundamental classes in algebraic geometry
1.1 Overview
Virtual fundamental classes are well-motivated for us, so we will not motivate them. Let be a Deligne-Mumford stack, which is virtually smooth (which means it has a perfect obstruction theory). A perfect obstruction theory is a class in which is locally isomorphic to a morphism of vector bundles.
In Li-Tian, the authors consider a perfect tangent-obstruction complex
where is the tangent sheaf and is the obstruction sheaf. If we consider
we note that the virtual tangent bundle has K-theory class
Thus has virtual dimension , and from the data , we will produce a virtual fundamental class . If is a scheme (for example in Donaldson-Thomas theory), then . If is smooth, then and . Of course, we should recover the usual fundamental class in this case.
1.2 Cones
Recall the Proj construction from Hartshorne, II.7. Let be a scheme and be a sheaf of graded -algebras generated over by a coherent . Then define , which is an affine scheme over . Because , then is a closed embedding.
Example 1.2.1.
Consider and . Of corse is a conic in , and is , which is a cone. Note that , so .
Of course, by Hartshorne, Ex. II.5.18, if is locally free, then is a vector bundle. The analogous notion for a coherent sheaf is an abelian cone. Note that the Stacks Project calls abelian cones vector bundles for some reason.
1.3 Local theory on a scheme
Recall that if is a smooth manifold, then it has an atlas of open sets in . Let be a scheme. Then has a cover by affines , and we have open embeddings . Finally, consider a Deligne-Mumford stack . Then we have an étale atlas . If is an Artin stack, then replace étale with smooth.
Now let denote the derived category of quasicoherent sheaves of -modules. Then let denote the full subcategory on complexes with vanishing cohomology outside of with and coherent.
Definition 1.3.1.
A perfect obstruction theory on is a complex with , where is the cotangent complex such that induces an isomorphism on and a surjection on .
To understand this, assume that is an affine scheme with an étale morphism to . Then pulls back to . If we consider a closed immersion of into a smooth scheme, we can now do intersection theory a la Fulton. The normal cone is defined to be
This is a closed subcone of . In this case, we only need to consider the truncated cotangent complex
In fact, if is a local complete intersection, then is locally free and . Thus . If this is surjective, then is smooth, so we have an exact sequence
and therefore . Locally, we have a morphism of locally free sheaves, and a morphism .
Proposition 1.3.2.
Up to quasi-isomorphism, we may assume that and with . Given these assumptions, is surjective.
Proof.
Locally, suppose that . Then let be finitely-generated -modules such that are free. Then consider . Next, choose a surjection with a finitely-generated free module. Then define
which is clearly quasi-isomorphic to . Then define by and . Now is surjective.
Next, we may asume that such that is surjective. We will now replace by the top row of the cartesian diagram
Because this is a fiber product, we have a map that is the identity in the -th position. □
Now we return to an étale chart , where is a Deligne-Mumford stack. Applying to , we obtain a morphism
Then we define
which is an Artin stack. We also apply this to the intrinsic normal sheaf
Finally, the intrinsic normal cone is defined to be
which is a cone stack over . We have a closed embedding
of into an abelian cone stack. Finally, these embed into . Because has pure dimension , we see that has dimension .
1.4 Virtual fundamental classes
We have intrinsic normal cones locally, and fortunately, they glue! Therefore, we have an intrinsic normal cone which is a cone stack over of pure dimension , an intrinsic normal sheaf which is an abelian cone stack over , and , which is a vector bundle stack over smooth of relative dimension .
Recall from Fulton that if is a vector bundle over a scheme of rank , there is a Gysin map . We want to do something similar in the case of a vector bundle stack. In Cycles groups for Artin stacks, Kresch gives the following: Let be a vector bundle stack of rank over a Deligne-Mumford stack. Then there is a Gysin map . Applying this to our situation, the virtual fundamental class is given by
1.5 Relative version
Let be a Deligne-Mumford stack and consider , where is a smooth Artin stack of pure dimension . If is virtually smooth, then there exists a relative perfect obstruction theory
where is the relative cotangent complex. We again require that induces an isomorphism on and a surjection on .
If is an affine scheme with étale, then is smooth. Also let be a closed embedding of into a smooth scheme and suppose is smooth of relative domension . Then we have the relative intrinsic normal cone
of pure dimension , the relative intrinsic normal sheaf
and the vector bundle stack . These also glue nicely, and we obtain
where is a vector bundle stack of rank . Then , and then the relative virtual fundamental class is
2 Melissa (Feb 10): Virtual fundamental classes in enumerative geometry
Recall our abstract setup of a Deligne-Mumford stack and a perfect obstruction theory . In this setting, Behrend-Fantechi construct a virtual fundamental class , where is the virtual dimension of . There is an equivariant version of this for the action of a reductive group on a Deligne-Mumford stack . Then we will have , so we can consider equivariant perfect obstruction theories . Here, we will have .
For us, we will normally consider . Here, there is a fixed substack . If we consider
we know that . Restricting to the fixed locus, we can decompose the tangent sheaf
into fixed and moving parts, and similarly for the obstruction sheaf . Then we have
and the moving part is
Graber-Pandharipande proved torus localization for virtual fundamental classes, and in particular, we obtain
Because , we are considering . Note that if acts trivially on , then .
2.1 Gromov-Witten theory
Let be a smooth projective variety and be an effective curve class. Let be the moduli space of genus , -pointed stable maps to of degree . The -points of this functor are , where is a genus , -pointed prestable curve and has .
Taking the locus with finite automorphism groups, we obtain a Deligne-Mumford stack , which is an Artin stack. is a proper Deligne-Mumford stack with projective coarse moduli space. Recall that there is a map , which is a smooth Artin stack of dimension , forgetting the map . We would like to construct a relative perfect obstruction theory.
Consider the diagram
with . Then we have and . Globally, we obtain
Then we obtain
and therefore we obtain
Our stability condition guarantees that any component contracted by is already stable as a curve. Now let be a scheme of finite type with a smooth map to . Then we have the following diagram:
with . We know that is flat and projective over , so define the line bundle
By the stability condition, is -ample because has degree on any irreducible component . Also, is a locally free sheaf on , so there exists such that is globally generated and . In addition, .
Now consider the exact sequence
and use the long exact sequence in cohomology, and thus .
Example 2.1.1.
Note that . Here, given , we must have , for some . Then , and so we obtain
Note that . Thus and , where . Finally, we see that
2.2 Remarks on equivariant localization
Let act on a stack . Then to do localization, we need to check that
- 1.
There exists a -equivariant embedding of into a smooth Deligne-Mumford stack.
- 2.
There exists a global locally free resolution .
Thus doing equivariant enumerative geometry required constructing a -equivariant embedding of into a smooth stack. Then a result of Chang-Kiem-Li in 2017 allows us to remove the first condition and weaken the second (we only nneed a global resolution on the fixed locus).
3 Song (Feb 17): Crepant transformation conjecture for toric Deligne-Mumford stacks, part 1
The crepant transformation conjecture roughly says:
Conjecture 3.0.1 (Ruan, etc).
For a pair of -equivalent manifolds/orbifolds/Deligne-Mumford stacks , their quantum cohomology/Gromov-Witten theory should be related.
Here, by K-equivalent we mean (following C-L Wang) that there exists a diagram
where is birational, are projective and birational, and . Coates-Iritani-Jiang formulated and proved the crepant transformation conjecture for toric Deligne-Mumford stacks and complete intersections.
3.1 Toric geometry
Note that toric crepant transformations correspond to wall-crossings of GIT stability conditions. There are three types of this.
Example 3.1.1 (Crepant (partial) resolution).
Here, we have a morphism that partially resolves singularities of . In our example, we will consider . Then the toric fan of is generated by . The toric fan of is generated by , and there is a singularity at , so to get we subdivide the triangle.
The GIT data for is given by . Dualizing, we have a surjection . In , we see that there is a positive chamber and a negative chamber, and in the positive chamber we obtain and in the negative chamber we obtain .
Example 3.1.2 (Flop).
Consider . These are related by an Atiyah flop. The flop corresponds to exchanging the two diagonals of a square. In this case, we still have a -dimensional secondary fan with two chambers.
Example 3.1.3 (Gerbe flop).
Consider and . Note that both rigidified stacks are isomorphic to . The GIT data is given by , where . If we choose we obtain and if we choose we obtain . The secondary fan has , where the bottom chamber corresponds to and the top chamber corresponds to .
Returning to the crepant resolution, we can tensor the lattice data to obtain
We will let be the dense open torus in . Thus also acts on . We will work -equivariantly.
Now note that . The two copies of are called the twisted sectors and will be labeled by . The untwisted sector will be labeled by . Then we take Chen1-Ruan cohomology and obtain
where the twisted sectors live in degrees respectively. On the other hand, is a scheme, so and
Note that . We will call its rank . We can also define -equivaraint versions of everything and there exists a -equivariant orbifold Poincaré pairing
Here, takes an automorphism to its inverse.
3.2 Quantum cohomology/Gromov-Witten theory
First, we will define (-equivariant) Gromov-Witten invariants. Choose , , , and defining the descendent insertions. Then we define
Note that the moduli spaces are not compact, so we need to use -equivariant localization.
With the Gromov-Witten invariants, we can now define the quantum product. Let , be a basis for , and be the completion to a homogeneous basis for . Let be the corresponding coordinates. For , define
This is a commutative and associative product which has a nonequivariant limit. The reason for this is because the evaluation maps are proper (a consequence of being semiprojective).
The next thing to define are the -functions. Again write . Then define the -function
By a result of Givental and Coates-Corti-Iritani-Tseng, there is a mirror theorem stating that
under the mirror map . The -function is an explicit hypergeometric function (here, we need weak Fano).
We will now discuss -functions and the extended complex moduli for the example of the crepant resolution. Let be the -equivariant parameters. Then set
Continuing, let be the -equivariant Poincaré duals of the “divisors” corresponding to the . Also define
Now we may define the -functions of by
where denotes the fractional part of . The -functions have some nice properties. For example, are locally analytic near the “large radius limit point” of in the extended complex moduli space, which in our case is just the secondary variety corresponding to the secondary fan, which is simply . The point is a smooth point and is an orbifold point. Thus we can relate . Based on this oversimplified picture, we can state the following result:
Theorem 3.2.1 (Crepant transformation conjecture, oversimplified).
There exists a degree-preserving -linear isomorphism such that after analytic continuation.
4 Song (Feb 24): Crepant transformation conjecture for toric Deligne-Mumford stacks, part 2
Recall the oversimplified statement of the crepant transformation conjecture discussed previously:
Theorem.
There exists a degree-preserving -linear isomorphism such that after analytic continuation.
4.1 Technical discussion of the simplified result
Begin by recalling the -functions corresponding to and . We should note here that in this case, and . We will reproduce the -functions below:
The main tool here that we will use is the Mellin-Barnes analytic continuation. This is a classical tool for analytic continuation of hypergeometric functions. Replacing , consider the functions
This allows us to define the -equivariant gamma classes of by
We can relate and by . Now we will work with the -functions, and we will consider analytic continuation of under the fixed-point basis. At the point , we have , so we have
because has simple poles at and . Call the complicated function in the final expression . This has poles at all integers and at . But now if is a contour, we obtain the integral
Therefore is a sum of residues at poles to the right of , which is the integral for small. Taking the analytic continuation from right to left, we obtain the same integral for large, which is the same as small . But now is a sum of residues at poles to the left of . Omitting the explicit computations, we obtain
After more explicit computations, we obtain the desired result.
For general , suppose we have a -dimensional cone with chambers with a wall. Set to be approximately the toric variety defined by the two chambers. Then is the total space of a vector bundle on the curve corresponding to the wall. On , there are points coresponding to the respective large radius limits. We have analytic problems, so we will consider the formal neighborhhood of in . Once we do this, we can apply the Mellin-Barnes method.
4.2 Fourier-Mukai transform
Recall that we have the diagram
Because this diagram is a -equivalence, we have a Fourier-Mukai transform
Theorem 4.2.1.
There exists a commutative diagram
The are related to the “-integral structure” where roughly we have
This result is proved by explicit computation. But now because the Fourier-Mukai transform has a non-equivariant limit, so does .
4.3 Related work
First, there is some related work in physics by Hori-Romo. In this, the Mellin-Barnes analytic continuation of the hemisphere partition function (the contour integral) corresponds to transportation of branes (the Fourier-Mukai transform).
Second, there is the work of Borisov-Horja. They replace our diagram by the diagram
where the bottom row consists of solutions spaces to hypergeometric systems. The bottom arrow is also a Mellin-Barnes integral, and the vertical arrows are so-called “mirror symmetry” maps. CIJ is a generalization of this.
Third, there is the work of Gonzalez-Woodward. They have a wall-crossing formula for genus-0 Gromov-Witten theory for general variation of GIT stability condition, which is a generalization of CIJ.
Finally, we can upgrade the simplified version by replacing orbifold cohomology by Givental’s loop spaces. There are other statements of the crepant transformation conjecture in quantum cohomology, but some of them have well-definedness issues. Unfortunately, we do not have the time to discuss these.
5 Che (Mar 03): Quantum groups and quantum cohomology, part 1
5.1 Nakajima quiver varieties
Let be a quiver with set of vertices . Then let be the framed double of . Choose dimension vectors . Then let . Then define to be the sum of
and its dual. This has an action of which preserves the symplectic form, so we have a moment map . Then we define
Example 5.1.1.
Let be the trivial quiver with one vertex. Then .
Example 5.1.2.
If is the quiver with one vertex and one loop, then .
Nakajima quiver varieties have various group actions. First, define
Then we may define
Here, the scales the symplectic form with weight . Now let be the maximal torus.
Example 5.1.3.
Consider . Then , and we have
Now define . Clearly we have . Noting that and , we in fact have
In general, define . Then we have
Now consider , where . Then in fact .
We also note that is a vector bundle on . The Chern classes of these are called tautological classes.
5.2 Quantum cohomology
Let be a smooth variety with the action of a reductive group with compact. Define the quantum product by
Here, and . Our goal is to describe this quantum cohomology in terms of the action of a quantum group. This connection seems surprising, but there is some previous literature on this.
- •
In 1994, Nakajima constructed an action of on , where is the quiver with adjacency matrix given by the Cartan matrix of .
- •
Nekrasov-Shatashvili proved a correspondence between 2D supersymmetric gauge theories and so-called Heisenberg spin chains. Usually, there is a quantum group action on the Heisenberg spin chains producing operators commuting with the Hamiltonian.
- •
Maulik-Okounkov identified with a subalgebra of a quantum group called the Yangian.
5.3 Stable envelopes
First, we will construct the stable envelope. This will give us an -matrix, which will in turn give us the Yangian.
Consider the action of on . Fix a pair of tori where preserves the symplectic form. Consider all of the -weights of . These partition the Lie algebra (the Lie algebra of the maximal compact) into chambers.
Example 5.3.1.
Consider . Then the weights are , which are exactly the roots of .
Definition 5.3.2.
Let be a chamber of and let . Then the attracting set of with chamber is defined to be
Here, for all . Now we may define
where if .
Example 5.3.3.
In the example of , let . Then at , we have weight in the fiber direction and in the base direction and at we have weight in the base direction and in the fiber direction. Then choose . Note . We then have and . We also have and .
Definition 5.3.4.
A polarization is a choice of such that .
Example 5.3.5.
For , let .
Next, we will define a degree in . Consider
where and . Note that . Thus for all , we can define to be its degree in .
Theorem 5.3.6.
Fix a chamber and a polarization . There exists a unique -module map
such that for all and for all and ,
- 1.
;
- 2.
, where is the repelling direction of the normal bundle of ;
- 3.
for all .
Example 5.3.7.
Consider again. Consider . Then we have and . In particular, . Finally, we see
when restricted to the fixed points.
Remark 5.3.8.
For the example of , the conditions in the theorem say that
- 1.
is lower triangular;
- 2.
The diagonal elements are ;
- 3.
The off-diagonal elements have -degree less than .
6 Che (Mar 10): Quantum groups and quantum cohomology, part 2
We will consider . Then recall that we have , where the scaled the contangent direction. Also recall that we constructed stable envelopes. Recall that we constructed stable envelopes for a chamber in the real cocharacters of .
6.1 -matrices
Let be chambers in . Then define . In the example of , we have
where
is the swapping operator. Our goal is to eventually construct the Yangian acting on .
Remark 6.1.1.
We can replace with a subtorus . For example, we want , where .
Now let be a chamber and be a face of . Then write for the span of and for the subtorus of associated to .
Lemma 6.1.2 (Triangle lemma).
The stable envelope factors as
Example 6.1.3.
Consider with the action of , , and to be the face where . Then define . Now we have . The lemma tells us we have a diagram
Corollary 6.1.4.
If and are two adjacent chambers separated by a wall , then denote by the chambers . Then .
Proof.
Applying the triangle lemma, we can see that the second factors are the same, so we obtain
Theorem 6.1.5 (Yang-Baxter equation for ).
Let be the -matrix we constructed. Then
where acts on the -th factor.
Here, in our example, we should have . But then we have relations like , and this gives us the desired result.
6.2 Construction of the Yangian
This construction is due to Fadeev, Reshetikhin, Takhtajan. Let . Then define , where this notation persists for historical reasons. Now let
where the tensor products are taken over . If we set , define by
This corresponds to the below picture where the horizontal line is auxillary space and the vertical lines are physical space.
Now we have , but we wanted elements of . First, we need to take expansions in , and then we view as a matrix with values in . Finally, we take to be generated by all limits (as ) of all coefficients of all matrix elements of for all possible after dividing by .
Note that acts on . On the other hand, we had
because , and therefore acts on for all because is an isomorphism after localization. This choice should be independent of the choice of by the Yang-Baxter equation.
Now let be the span of the terms in and be the span of , where for , .
Proposition 6.2.1.
- 1.
is a Lie algebra;
- 2.
is a subalgebra;
- 3.
is a maximal commutative subalgebra in .
Example 6.2.2.
Consider . We have
Define to be the classical -matrix. This implies
After computation, we will see that is spanned by
We then see that , and that are raising and lowering operators, respectively.
Proposition 6.2.3.
The associated graded algebra of is , where the grading is with respect to degree in shifted by .
Then consider .
Theorem 6.2.4.
Let and . Then
where the quantum product is modified by .
Now let . This has an action of , so consider and . Then we have
But then
7 Kevin (Mar 24): Donaldson-Thomas type invariants via microlocal geometry, part 1
For any finite type Deligne-Mumford stack , Behrend constructs a natural constructible function . More precisely, we can use to compute enumerative invariants.
Theorem 7.0.1.
Let be a projective Deligne-Mumford stack (maybe proper with projective coarse moduli space?) with a symmetric obstruction theory. If is either smooth, a global finite group quotient, or a gerbe over a scheme, then
Example 7.0.2.
Let be a DT-type moduli space for a Calabi-Yau threefold. Then has a symmetric obstruction theory, and so we can compute Donaldson-Thomas and Pandharipande-Thomas invariants for Calabi-Yau threefolds using the Behrend function.
We will attempt to explain the following diagram where is an embedding of into a smooth stack :
| (7.1) |
The left triangle was studied by MacPherson, and is relatively well-known. The right triangle is microlocal because of the presence of the cotagent bundle.
7.1 Obstruction theories
7.1.1 Perfect obstruction theories
Recall that a perfect obstruction theory for a Deligne-Mumford stack is that is a surjection on and an isomorphism on . We also require that is a perfect complex with amplitude contained in . Note that is locally of the form
where is a smooth stack containing .
From the perfect obstruction theory, we can construct the intrinsic normal cone, which is the cone stack such that if is étale and is an embedding into a smooth scheme, then . Then a perfect obstruction theory gives us a closed immersion , and the virtual fundamental class is
This is really bad because of the vector bundle stacks, so Behrend gives a different construction that will give us honest vector bundles.
Definition 7.1.1.
A local resolution of over is a presentation of as over . The obstruction cone is the cone that is the pullback
We have a surjection .
Proposition 7.1.2.
Let be a vector bundle on with a surjection . Then there exists a unique closed subcone such that for all local resolutions on with obstruction cone and lifts
. This is called the obstructon cone of .
Some nice facts in the case that is projective are
- •
Perfect obstruction theories admit global resolutions;
- •
There exists an embedding into a smooth stack.
Proposition 7.1.3.
Let be projective with perfect obstruction theory . Let be a vector bundle with surjection and let be the obstruction cone. Then has pure dimension and
7.2 Symmetric obstruction theories
Definition 7.2.1.
A symmetric obstruction theory is a perfect obstruction theory endowed with a nondegenerate symmetric bilinear form of degree , which means an isomorphism
such that .
Note that if has a symmetric obstruction theory, which means that . Thus we can define the virtual count if is proper.
Example 7.2.2.
Let be a projective Calabi-Yau threefold and be a Hilbert scheme of subschemes of of dimension . Also let be the universal ideal sheaf on . Then let fit into a distinguished triangle
Now is a symmetric obstruction theory. First, it is clear that is self-dual, and second, by relative Serre duality, we have
Shifting and composing, we obtain .
Example 7.2.3.
Let be a smooth variety and let be an almost closed -form (which means that . Then has a symmetric obstruction theory
This is clearly self-dual, and the map to the cotangent complex is given by . Then we obtain a closed embedding , and the image of this is the obstruction cone of .
Proposition 7.2.4.
Let be a symmetric obstruction theory on . Then étale locally, there exists and an almost closed -form such that and is the symmetric obstruction theory associated to .
7.3 The Behrend function
We want to think of as an invariant of singularities of . This means that:
- •
If is a smooth point, then ;
- •
If is smooth, then ;
- •
For any , we have ;
- •
If , then
Here, is the vanishing cycles and is the Milnor fiber.
Now we want to define . The first tool is MacPherson’s local Euler obstruction
which is in the diagram 7.1 and is given by
Here, if we choose , embed into a smooth , and consider the Grassmann bundle of rank quotients of . Above the smooth locus , there exists a section sending to . Finally, we let be the closure of this section in and be the natural projection, called the Nash blowup. Also, is the universal quotient bundle on .
Now we can define the Chern-Mather class by
We now need to construct a cycle . Embed into a smooth stack and consider the normal cone . Also let be the projection, and define the cycle
where ranges over the irreducible components of . When is smooth, then .
We may finally define the Behrend function by . There is also the Aluffi class
When is smooth, then .
Proposition 7.3.1.
In the cases of the main theorem, we have
8 Kevin (Mar 31): Donaldson-Thomas type invariants via microlocal geometry, part 2
Recall the diagram (7.1) from last time. Our first goal is to show that .
8.1 Microlocal geometry
Let be a smooth variety of dimension .
Definition 8.1.1.
An irreducible closed subset is conic if it is invariant under the action. is Lagrangian if the symplectic form vanishes generically on .
Definition 8.1.2.
A closed subscheme of is conic Lagrangian if all of its irreducible components of conic Lagrangian.
Because these conditions are actually étale local, we can extend the definitions to the case where is a smooth Deligne-Mumford stack.
Example 8.1.3.
Let be irreducible. Then the closure of the conormal bundle to is a conic Lagrangian cycle.
Definition 8.1.4.
We will define to be the group of conic Lagrangian cycles and to be the group of conic Lagrangian cycles supported over .
Proposition 8.1.5.
There is an isomorphism given by the maps
and
The point of this microlocal geometry is the following result:
Proposition 8.1.6.
The diagram
commutes.
Lemma 8.1.7 (Fundamental lemma for almost closed -forms).
The obstruction cone (where ) is conic Lagrangian.
To prove the lemma, we can simply check locally. Now, if we note that
by definition of , then we obtain
as desired.
8.2 Hilbert schemes of points on threefolds
Let and . We can choose coordinates on and extend to coordinates on . Then write
Now let and define to be the image of . We also define to be the image of the section
Proposition 8.2.1.
For small and small relative to , we can express the Behrend function as a linking number via the formula
where is a radius copy of around .
We will not consider torus actions. Let be a -scheme with an isolated fixed point and an equivariant symmetric obstruction theory.
Proposition 8.2.2.
There exists an invariant affine neighborhood where equivariantly such that is an invariant almost closed -form and .
Proposition 8.2.3.
Let act on with finite stabilizers. Let be -invariant submanifolds. Suppose we have an -equivariant homotopy from to where is an open interval containing and . Then
The proof of this requires us to talk about orbifolds, so we will not discuss it.
Proposition 8.2.4.
Let be a smooth -dimensional scheme with an isolated fixed point . Let , where is an invariant almost closed -form and . Then
Proof.
Choose equivariant coordinates on around . Then let
be the image of , which is oriented times the orientation . Now let . There is an -equivariant homotopy from to given by the formula
Because is an isolated fixed points, the action of on has finite stabilizers, so by the previous proposition,
But the left hand side is and the right side is , as desired. □
Finally, we give the following result:
Theorem 8.2.5.
For , we have the formula
Theorem 8.2.6.
Recall that the fixed points of the torus action on the Hilbert scheme are actually the monomial ideals . But then
by MNOP, and therefore
where is the -th coefficient of the McMahon function.
9 Konstantin (Apr 07): Inductive construction of stable envelopes, part 1
9.1 Elliptic cohomology
There is a general way to construct generalized cohomology theories from formal groups using complex cobordism, but this is totally not useful in computations. There is another more explicit construction using derived moduli stacks of elliptic curves, but we don’t understand infinity-categories, so it is useless to us. Instead, in 1995, Ginzburg, Kapranov, and Vasserot constructed equivariant elliptic cohomology with complex coefficients. This generalizes a construction of Grojnovski, which reduces to ordinary cohomology in the non-equivariant case. Even here, the notation used by Okounkov (which we will use) is very different from that of Ginzburg, Kapranov, and Vasserot.
We will consider the elliptic curve
living over . This is identified with by the exponential map and . We will also consider
where gives the Kähler variables. For an elliptic curve , we have an exact sequence
Note that any bundle in has a meromorphic section , where , and
This satisfies the equation , so we have an entire function on . Also, we note that , so is a section of the line bundle corresponding to .
Let be an algebraic group, which for us will be a torus. Then we will define
For example, if , then . In general, we will have a morphism of schemes
This gives us a sheaf . Note that elliptic cohomology is periodic, and in fact we have
where is a line bundle.
Remark 9.1.1.
If , then . If , then is the group of -torsion points on .
Remark 9.1.2.
Note that is a ring over . Therefore, we can take as a scheme. We can do a similar construction for . Then there is a map , and then of course .
Now we can construct a sheaf
Example 9.1.3.
We will now compute the elliptic cohomology of , equivariant with respect to . First, note that
Note that this is a union of two hyperplanes and projects to . Next, in -theory, we have
By our choices, we still have a union of hyperplanes, and the projection is onto . We now need to take a quotient with respect to multiplication by , and this tells us that
where the diagonal is the locus . In particular, we have
Unfortunately, there is no easy geometric interpretations of elliptic cohomology classes comparable to cohomology classes being cycles and -theory classes being sheaves. However, we can consider them as sections of bundles on . Let be a vector bundle on . Then the Thom space of is defined to be . Its elliptic cohomology is defined to be
which is a module over and thus a pushforward of a sheaf on . We will call this sheaf .
Now denote and note that is a finite cover of . In cohomology, we have something like
This has a map to , and this tells us that
Recall from cohomology the Thom isomorphism given by . In elliptic cohomology, if we replace by , we take
The bundle satisfies the following properties:
- •
;
- •
.
This defines a map . In fact, this generates all bundles used in Okounkov’s constructions.
Now let . This defines a map . We also have a map
where
9.2 Outline of Okounkov’s construction
Let
For each component
10 Konstantin (Apr 14): Inductive construction of stable envelopes, part 2
10.1 More on elliptic cohomology
Let
Recall we have a diagram
We will define the Elliptic cohomology functor
This is
Finally, recall that if
To construct this, consider the topological picture
This defines a map between the elliptic cohomology of
and then this becomes
and noting that
We now discuss correspondences. Consider the diagram
Then we want morphisms
To make this work, we require
We can also consider more general line bundles
where
10.2 Okounkov’s construction
Let
as a disjoint union of connected components. From the bundle
For each fixed component, we can define the attracting set
Then note that
For example, if
In the example of
Now define
Proposition 10.2.1.
We have
for any
Proof.
We have the identity
Then the right hand side becomes
Now consider the diagram
This defines us a morphism
Lemma 10.2.2.
The map
This result gives us an interpolation from
We want to make the support
To make the support closed, we do the following. Let
Lemma 10.2.3.
If
This automatically gives us
and then
11 Patrick (Apr 21): DT/PT correspondence using motivic Hall algebras
11.1 Introduction
Let
Now let
Then denote
Finally, we call a class
Now let
is a derived equivalence, called the McKay correspondence. Then there is a map
Then define following DT and PT generating series:
Theorem 11.1.1 (DT/PT correspondence).
Let
11.2 Categorical preliminaries
Definition 11.2.1.
Let
with
This can be naturally generalized to the notion of a torsion
Example 11.2.2.
Let
For a torsion pair
This is called tilting at the torsion pair
Example 11.2.3.
Define the category
Unfortunately, this category is too large for our purposes, so we will define a new category. First, if
This is a Noetherian abelian category with the inclusions
Definition 11.2.4.
Let
Example 11.2.5.
For example, if
For a pair of full subcategories as above, we may also define
If
11.3 Moduli stack
There is a stack
into open and closed substacks by the numerical
Definition 11.3.1.
A torsion pair
Lemma 11.3.2.
The following conditions define open substacks of
- 1.
andH 0 ( E ) ∈ 𝚃 ;E ∈ D [ − 1 , 0 ] ( 𝒳 ) - 2.
andH − 1 ( E ) ∈ 𝙵 .E ∈ D [ − 1 , 0 ] ( 𝒳 )
In particular, if
Proposition 11.3.3.
Let
In particular,
are inclusions of open substacks, and in particular, the first two stacks are Artin stacks locally of finite type.
11.4 Motivic Hall algebras
Recall the Grothendieck ring of varieties
Definition 11.4.1.
Let
Definition 11.4.2.
A morphism
Lemma 11.4.3.
- 1.
If
is a geometric bijection, thenf : X → Y ;[ X ] = [ Y ] - 2.
.[ X 1 ] + [ X 2 ] = [ X 1 ⊔ X 2 ]
Now we say that a morphism
Definition 11.4.4.
The Grothendieck ring of stacks
- 1.
;[ X ⊔ Y ] = [ X ] + [ Y ] - 2.
If
is a geometric bijection, thenf : X → Y ;[ X ] = [ Y ] - 3.
If
are Zariski fibrations with the same fibers, thenX 1 , X 2 → Y .[ X ] = [ Y ]
For any Artin stack
Proposition 11.4.5.
There exists an Artin stack
for
Now, for
This defines an associative product on
There is an inclusion
Proposition 11.4.6.
Let
where
We will not be considering the motivic Hall algebra but rather a completed version
11.5 Wall-crossing and the DT/PT correspondence
Definition 11.5.1.
A torsion pair
All of the torsion pairs we will consider are numerical.
Proposition 11.5.2.
Let
Lemma 11.5.3.
Assume that
- 1.
The stack
is of finite type.𝙿𝚊𝚒𝚛 ¯ ( 𝚃 + , 𝙵 − ) α - 2.
The stack
is of finite type.( 𝙿𝚊𝚒𝚛 ¯ ( 𝚃 + , 𝙵 + ) ∗ 𝚆 ¯ ) α - 3.
The stack
is of finite type.( 𝚆 ¯ ∗ 𝙿𝚊𝚒𝚛 ¯ ( 𝚃 − , 𝙵 − ) ) α
Definition 11.5.4.
A full subcategory
- 1.
is closed under direct sums and summands;𝚆 - 2.
defines an element of𝚆 ;H gr ( 𝙲 ) - 3.
If
, there are only finitely many ways to writeα ∈ N ( 𝒳 ) , where eachα = α 1 + ⋯ + α n represents a nonzero element inα i .𝚆
Theorem 11.5.5 (No-poles).
If
We are finally ready to do wall-crossing, but we need one more definition.
Definition 11.5.6.
Let
Theorem 11.5.7.
Suppose
Proof of DT/PT correspondence.
Let
Now let
Next, write
Combining this with the first DT-PT identity, we have
Finally, noting that
12 Patrick (Apr 28): The DT crepant resolution conjecture
12.1 Brief review
Recall that
Let
Finally, recall the integration map
of regular elements.
12.2 Stability conditions
Fix an ample class
Definition 12.2.1.
A stability condition on
then either
We will now define a number of stability conditions. First, we fix a “generating” vector bundle
Definition 12.2.2.
Define the Nironi slope of
if
Definition 12.2.3.
Define the stability condition
for
For a stability condition
Also, call the category of
In order to control DT-like invariants coming from stability conditions, we need our categories of semistable objects and of pairs to satisfy openness and boundedness properties.
Proposition 12.2.4.
- 1.
For any
, the torsion pairδ ∈ ℝ is open.( 𝚃 ν , δ , 𝙵 ν , δ ) - 2.
For any
, the torsion pair( γ , η ) ∈ ℝ > 0 × ℝ is open. In addition, the moduli stack( 𝚃 ζ , ( γ , η ) , 𝙵 ζ , ( γ , η ) ) is open for anyℳ ¯ ζ ss ( a , b ) ⊂ 𝙲𝚘𝚑 ¯ ≤ 1 ( 𝒳 ) .( a , b ) ∈ ℝ 2
We will now discuss boundedness. For any real number
This will control the series expansion of the rational function
Definition 12.2.5.
Let
is finite for every
is finite for every
The main results about semistable sheaves and pairs are the following. Recall that a category
Proposition 12.2.6.
Let
is
Proposition 12.2.7.
For any
is
Corollary 12.2.8.
The category
Finally, we will locate regions in which the notion of a
Lemma 12.2.9.
Let
For
12.3 DT-like invariants
We define DT-like invariants counting objects in the categories that we have defined. Once we do this, we will cross our infinitely many walls.
Recall that
Therefore, we can define DT-type (Joyce-Song) invariants by
Now let
Finally, we can form generating series
Lemma 12.3.1.
Let
The following is a technical lemma whose proof requires the Hard Lefschetz condition.
Lemma 12.3.2.
For every
Now we will discuss wall-crossing. Once we cross all of the walls in
is finite for any
Lemma 12.3.3.
Let
If
This tells us that on each wall
Proposition 12.3.4.
Let
Now define the series
Lemma 12.3.5.
Let
is a rational function of degree less than
Taking
Corollary 12.3.6.
Let
Theorem 12.3.7.
Let
12.4 Bryan-Steinberg invariants
In order to have a crepant resolution conjecture, we need some kind of enumerative invariants on
Then define
Definition 12.4.1.
A Bryan-Steinberg pair
For a class
Before we continue, we will say a little but more about the McKay correspondence. Define the category
Proposition 12.4.2.
The equivalence
We now need to relate Bryan-Steinberg pairs to objects living on
Definition 12.4.3.
Let
Let
The following result justifies the inclusion of
Lemma 12.4.4.
Let
We should think of
Lemma 12.4.5.
We have the following:
These give us the following:
Lemma 12.4.6.
If
This implies that
Theorem 12.4.7 (Crepant resolution conjecture).
There exists a unique rational function
- 1.
The Laurent expansion of
with respect tof β is the seriesdeg ;PT ( 𝒳 ) β - 2.
The Laurent expansion of
with respect tof β forL γ is the series0 < γ < min γ ′ ∈ V β γ ′ .BS ( Y / X ) β
Using results of Bryan-Steinberg and of the previous lecture, we have
Corollary 12.4.8 (Crepant resolution conjecture, original formulation).
There is an equality of rational functions