FGA explained
FGA Explained Learning Seminar
Fall 2020
Notes by Patrick Lei
Lectures by Various
Columbia University
Disclaimer
These notes were taken during the seminar using the vimtex package of the editor neovim. Any errors are mine and not the speakers’. In addition, my notes are picture-free (but will include commutative diagrams) and are a mix of my mathematical style and that of the lecturers. If you find any errors, please contact me at plei@math.columbia.edu.
Seminar Website: https://www.math.columbia.edu/~calebji/fga.html
1 Caleb (Oct 16): Representable Functors and Grothendieck Topologies
1.1 Representable Functors
We will always denote categories by .
Definition 1.1.1.
Given an object , define the functor by .
Any morphism induces a natural transformation . By the Yoneda lemma, this correspondence is bijective.
Lemma 1.1.2 (Yoneda Lemma).
Let and be a functor. Then .
Proof.
Let . This gives a map , and we can consider . Now given , we need . Given , then we have a map and then . We can check that these are inverses. □
Definition 1.1.3.
A functor is representable if it is naturally isomorphic to for some .
Definition 1.1.4.
If is a presheaf, a universal object for is a pair such that and for any where , there exists a unique such that .
Note that representability is equivalent to having a universal object.
Example 1.1.5.
- 1.
For the first example, consider for some ring . Then if , then clearly this is isomorphic to and the universal object is .
- 2.
Let where is a line bundle and generate , then is a universal object.
1.2 Grothendieck Topologies
According to Wikipedia, this is supposed to be a pun on “Riemann surface.” We want to generalize the idea of a topology because the Zariski topology is awful. Instead of open sets, we will consider suitable maps (coverings).
Definition 1.2.1.
A Grothendieck topology on a category is a specification of coverings of for each . Here are the axioms for coverings:
- 1.
If is an isomorphism, then is a covering.
- 2.
If is a covering, for all , the fiber products and form a covering of .
- 3.
If is a covering and are coverings, then is a covering of .
A category with a Grothendieck topology is called a site.
Example 1.2.2.
Here are some topological examples. Let be a topological space.
- 1.
The site of is the poset category of open subsets of . The fiber product is just the intersection, and a covering is a normal open covering.
- 2.
(Global classical topology) Let . Here, the coverings are sets of open embeddings such that the union of the images covers the whole space.
- 3.
(Global étale topology) Here, and the coverings are now local homeomorphisms.
Returning to schemes, we have several examples of Grothendieck topologies.
- 1.
(Global Zariski Topology). Let . The coverings are jointly surjective open embeddings.
- 2.
(Big étale site over ) The objects are schemes over and the morphisms are -morphisms that are étale and locally of finite presentation.
- 3.
(Small étale site) This the same as the big étale site, but with the added requirement that is also étale.
- 4.
(fppf topology) This stands for the French fidèlement plat et présentation finie. The morphisms are flat and locally of finite presentation. A covering is a set of jointly surjective morphisms such that the map is faithfully flat and of finite presentation. Note that flat and locally of finite presentation implies open.
- 5.
(fpqc topology) This stands for the French Fidèlement plat et quasi-compacte. An fpqc morphism is a morphism that is faithfully flat and one of the following equivalent conditions:
- (a)
Every quasicompact open subset of is the image of a quasicompact open subset of .
- (b)
There exists an affine open cover of such that is the image of a quasicompact open subset of .
- (c)
Given , there exists a neighborhood such that is open in and is quasicompact.
- (d)
Given , there exists a quasicompact open neighborhood such that is open and affine in .
The fpqc topology is given by maps such that is an fpqc morphism.
- (a)
To check that this is a topology, we have to do a lot of work. However, we will list some properties of fpqc morphisms and coverings.
Proposition 1.2.3.
- 1.
The composition of fpqc morphisms is fpqc.
- 2.
Given , if is fpqc, then is fpqc.
- 3.
Open and faithfully flat implies fpqc. Moreover, faithfully flat and locally of finite presentation implies fpqc. This means that fppf implies fpqc.
- 4.
Base change preserves fpqc morphsisms.
- 5.
All fpqc morphsism are submersive. Thus is open if and only if is open.
Note that Zariski is coarser than étale is coarser than fppf is coarser than fpqc.
1.3 Sheaves on Sites
Recall that a presheaf on a space is a functor . Similarly, if is a site, then a presheaf is a functor .
Definition 1.3.1.
A presheaf on a site is a sheaf if
- 1.
Given a covering and such that , then .
- 2.
Given a covering and such that (in the fiber product) for all , there exists a unique such that .
An alternative definition of a sheaf is that is an equalizer.
Theorem 1.3.2 (Grothendieck).
A representable functor on is a sheaf in the fpqc topology.
This means that given any fpqc cover , then applying , if we have that glue on , then the sheaf condition says we can glue to a unique . In the Zariski topology, this is trivial. This also means that the fpqc topology is subcanonical, which means that are all sheaves.
We will prove this result by reducing to the category of all schemes. Note that the topology on comes from the topology on . Then we can show that if is subcanonical, then is subcanonical. Then we use the following lemma.
Lemma 1.3.3.
Let be a scheme and be a presheaf. If is a Zariski sheaf if is a faithfully flat morphism of affine -schemes, then is an equalizer, then is an fpqc sheaf.
Proof.
Given an fpqc covering, let . Then consider the diagram
the columns are bijective, so it suffices to check this for single coverings.
Now if are finite and all affine and the second assumption holds, we have the diagram
Then the middle row is an equalizer. □
Proof of Theorem 1.3.2.
If are affine, then we know that is left exact, so the result follows from commutative algebra. Now it suffices to check the general case for single covers. If is a union of affines, then separatedness follows by restricting to the and using the affine case.
Please read the rest of this yourself. □
2 Caleb (Oct 23): Sieves and Fibered Categories
Recall that a Grothendieck topology on a site is a collection of coverings such that isomorphisms are coverings, pullbacks preserve coverings, and if and are coverings, then is a covering.
Also recall from last time that two important examples of Grothendieck topologiyes are the global Zariski topology and the fpqc topology. We also defined a sheaf and proved that representable functors are sheaves in the fpqc topology.
2.1 Sieves
A sieve is a way to have “your barrel full and your wife drunk.” The motivating question is:
Question 2.1.1.
When do two Grothendieck topologies give rise to the same sheaves?
Definition 2.1.2.
A subfunctor of has and the morphisms are just restrictions.
Definition 2.1.3.
A sieve on is a subfunctor of .
Example 2.1.4.
Given a cover , then are arrows that factor through the covering.
Definition 2.1.5.
A sieve belongs to a topology if for some covering in the topology .
Definition 2.1.6.
A covering is a refinement of if .
This gives a poset structure on Grothendieck topologies, where if every covering in has a refinement that is a covering in . For schemes, we have
Then we know that are equivalent if .
Proposition 2.1.7.
Equivalent topologies have the same sheaves.
Proof.
Note that is a sheaf if and only for belonging to , the map is bijective. □
A real world application of this is that we can construct the sheafification of a functor by
where ranges over sieves belonging to .
2.2 Fibered Categories
We will consider functors . Our notation will be
Definition 2.2.1.
A morphism in is Cartesian if for all and in with , then there exists a unique such that and .
If is a Cartesian arrow, then we say that is a pullback of . Pullbacks (with a fixed map in ) are unique up to isomorphism.
Definition 2.2.2.
A fibered category is a functor such that for any in and with , then we have a cartesian arrow with .
Definition 2.2.3.
Note that the fiber is a category. The objects are such that and morphisms are arrows that map to the identity of (i.e. ).
Definition 2.2.4.
A morphism of fibered categories over is a functor such that is a functor.
Definition 2.2.5.
A cleavage of is a class of cartesian arrows such that for all and , there exists a unique morphism in mapping to .
Question 2.2.6.
Does a cleavage give a functor from to the category of categories?
Unfortunately, the answer is no. This is not a functor, but it does give a pseudofunctor, which is the same as a lax -functor. The idea is that may not be the identity and may not be . However, they are canonically isomorphic.
Definition 2.2.7.
A pseudofunctor on (from to ) is an assignment such that
- 1.
For all objects of , is a category.
- 2.
For each , is a functor.
- 3.
For all of , we have an isomorphism .
- 4.
For all we have an isomorphism such that given and , we have , and . In addition, we require that for all morphisms and , the diagram
commutes.
Definition 2.2.8.
A cleavage is a splitting if it gives an honest functor.
Apparently every fibered category is equivalent to a split fibered category.
2.3 Examples
- 1.
If a category has fiber products, then the category of arrows is a fibered category over , and the Cartesian arrows are the Cartesian diagrams.
- 2.
If is a topological group, then there is a “classifying stack” given by principal -bundles.
- 3.
Consider the category of sheaves on a site . Given an object, denote sheaves on as sheaves in . Then given , we have .
- 4.
Let . Then given , we have . However, is not an equality. In the affine case, if is a morphism of rings, then recall that quasicoherent sheaves are modules. Then . The problem is that but they are not the same object. However, note that and that are adjoint.
3 Caleb (Oct 30): Étale morphisms and the étale fundamental group
Today we will take a break from the abstract nonsense.
3.1 Flat Morphisms
Definition 3.1.1.
Let be a map of schemes. Then is flat at if the map is flat. Then is flat globally if it is flat at all .
Note if is flat if and only if is flat. The geometric intuition behind flatness is that the fibers form a continuous family.
Example 3.1.2.
Consider the map given by . This is the normalization of the nodal cubic, and we see that the integral closure of the second ring is given by adjoining the element .
Outside , the map of stalks is an isomorphism, but at , we see that
and thus the map is not flat.
Example 3.1.3.
Let be integral domains with the same fraction field. Then is faithfully flat if and only if .
Proof.
The idea is to use that for any ideal of , we have . Then go read your commutative algebra homework (or your favorite commutative algebra text). □
Remark 3.1.4.
Normalization is flat if and only if it is an isomorphism.
Example 3.1.5.
A closed embedding is flat if and only if it is also open. In particular, closed embeddings are generically not flat.
Proposition 3.1.6.
If is a flat map between irreducibles, then is dense in for all nonempty .
Proof.
Reduce to the case . We simply need to be in the image of . Writing the diagram
we see that . This contains the ring by flatness. If , then is nilpotent and this implies . □
Theorem 3.1.7.
Let be a morphism of locally Noetherian schemes. Then
with equality if is flat.
Sketch of Proof.
By schematic nonsense, replace by , so is Noetherian local. We can also assume is reduced. We will induct on . Recall that if , then for not a zero divisor or a unit. □
Corollary 3.1.8.
If be a faithful flat map of algebraic varieties, then is equidimensional and .
3.2 Étale morphisms
From now on we will assume is finite type and locally Noetherian.
Definition 3.2.1.
A morphism of schemes is unramified at if satisfies and is separable.
Definition 3.2.2.
A morphism is étale if it is flat and unramified.
Example 3.2.3.
Let be an extension of fields. Then is étale if and only if is separable.
Example 3.2.4.
Let be a field extension. Then is flat and the separability condition holds. Then is unramified (and hence étale) if and only if it is unramified in the sense of number theory. Here, we consider the product
and is unramified if all . For example, for the extension , we see that and thus this map is not unramified.
Example 3.2.5.
Consider . Then prime ideals are irreducibles dividing . Then is étale at if and only if is separable and is a simple factor of .
More generally, a standard étale morphism for a monic and such that is a is a unit in , then is standard étale.
Example 3.2.6.
Consider . This map is not étale at . To be explicit, note that is not a unit in , but it is a unit after localization at , and thus is étale.
Theorem 3.2.7.
Every étale morphism is locally standard étale.
The proof uses the following theorem:
Theorem 3.2.8 (Zariski’s Main Theorem).
Let be a quasi-finite morphism of finite type between Noetherian schemes. Then can be factored into , where is an open embedding and is finite.
Definition 3.2.9.
A quasi-finite morphism is a morphism with finite fibers.
Remark 3.2.10.
If is a finite-type morphism of schemes of finite type over , then is étale if and only if is an isomorphism. Geometrically, this means that the formal neighborhoods are isomorphic.
3.3 Étale fundamental group
Recall that if is a nice topological space, there is an equivalence of categories
This functor is represented by the universal covering space , and we have .
Now we want to make this work for schemes, so we take finite étale morphisms to be the covers. Then we define a functor
by , where is a geometric point of . We see that is not representable, but it is a projective limit of representables, so we define the étale fundamental group
Example 3.3.1.
Let . Then . Similarly, .
If is a variety over , then , where is the profinite completion. In particular, . If , then we have an exact sequence
4 Caleb (Nov 6): More on the étale fundamental group and fibered categories
Recall that étale is the same as flat and unramified. Consider the category of finite étale morphisms over and choose a geometric point . Then consider the functor . Unfortunately, the morphism is not étale, so this functor is not representable. If it was representable, it would be represented by the universal cover, which does not necessarily exist. We will now construct a Galois theory for schemes.
Definition 4.0.1.
For a finite étale morphism , define the degree . This is invariant of the choice of basepoint.
Proposition 4.0.2.
If is connected and we have a diagram
then is determined by where it sends a single geometric point of . In particular, .
Corollary 4.0.3.
There is a faithful action of on .
Definition 4.0.4.
A Galois cover is a finite étale morphism such that is connected and . Equivalently, the action of on is transitive.
Remark 4.0.5.
A transitive action is the same as normality in both Galois theory and topological covering spaces.
Example 4.0.6.
Let . Then finite étale morphisms to are schemes of the form where is finite separable. Then is Galois if and only if is Galois. For a degree extension, the action of on is simply the action on the embeddings .
Lemma 4.0.7.
For connected , there exists Galois over such that the diagram
commutes. In fact, for any pair , there exists a Galois surjecting onto both.
4.1 Universal Cover
This universal cover is not a scheme, but is a projective limit of schemes. We will define the universal cover of with the following:
- 1.
A poset indexing Galois covers .
- 2.
For any , there such that and .
- 3.
If , then we have compactible with geometric points and composition.
Example 4.1.1.
Take all Galois covers and set if and only if there exists . To make everything work, we can adjust the map by an automorphism of because the action of the Galois group is transitive.
Proposition 4.1.2.
Suppose is Galois over and there is a finite étale map over . Then is a subgroup and is Galois if and only if is a normal subgroup. In this case, .
In particular, if are both Galois, then we have a map .
Definition 4.1.3.
Take to be the universal cover of . Then define the étale fundamental group by
Aternatively, recall the action of on . Then we obtain an action of on
Proposition 4.1.4.
is the direct limit of the functors .
Theorem 4.1.5.
The functor
is an equivalence of categories.
By Yoneda, we may define
- 1.
Let
. Then if we take Galois coveringsX = Spec k whose union isL i / K . Then we havek sep π 1 ét ( Spec k ) = lim ⟵ Gal ( L i / K ) = Gal ( k sep / k ) . - 2.
Now consider a normal scheme
with function fieldX . ThenK ( X ) is the composition of all finite extensionsK ( X ) un such thatK ( Y ) unramified. Then we haveY → X π 1 ét ( X ) ≅ Gal ( K ( X ) un / K ( X ) ) . - 3.
Because
has no unramified extensions, we haveℚ . By local class field theory, for any number fieldπ 1 ét ( Spec ℤ ) = 1 , we haveK π 1 ab ( Spec 𝒪 K ) ≃ Gal ( H † / K ) ≃ Gal ( H / K ) ≃ I K , where
is the ideal class group,I K is the maximum abelian extension unramified at finite primes (narrow Hilbert class field), andH † is the Hilbert class field, which is unramified at all primes.H - 4.
If
, then we can prove using some differential form thatX = 𝔸 ℂ 1 . In fact, all finite étale covers are isomorphisms. However, this is not true in positive characteristic.π 1 ét ( X ) = 1 - 5.
Consider the nodal cubic
. Then finite étale morphisms overSpec k [ x , y ] / ( y 2 − x 3 − x 2 ) are of the formX withSpec R n and thusAut X R n ≃ ℤ / n ℤ .π 1 ét ( X ) = ℤ ̂ - 6.
Let
be finite overX k withk connected. Then we have an exact sequenceX k ¯ 1 → π 1 ( X k ¯ ) → 𝑖 π 1 ( X k ) → 𝑗 Gal ( k sep / k ) → 1 . To prove this, first note that the composition of the two middle maps is trivial because the map
factors throughX k ¯ → Spec k (by definition of base change). Then becauseSpec k ¯ is connected, we see thatX k ¯ is surjective by using the fact that forj we have
. Finally, we use some magic to show thatAut X k ( X L ) ≃ Gal ( L / k ) is injective.i
5 Caleb (Nov 13): Fibered categories
5.1 Review of Fibered Categories
Here is a motivating example for fibered categories. Recall that
with objects
is a Cartesian diagram. This means that
Recall the definition of a Cartesian arrow and a fibered category from the second lecture.
Example 5.1.1.
Suppose a category
Definition 5.1.2.
In a fibered category
Recall that a cleavage is a class of Cartesian arrows such that there is one for every
Example 5.1.3.
Recall that a group is a category with one object. If
5.2 2 -Yoneda Lemma
Recall that if
Given
If
Lemma 5.2.1 (Weak 2 -Yoneda).
For
Lemma 5.2.2 (2 -Yoneda lemma).
Let
5.3 Categories fibered in sets and groupoids
All moduli problems will be fibered in groupoids, and when they are representable by schemes, this is when the functor is fibered in sets.
Definition 5.3.1.
A category is fibered in sets if
Now recall that we have embeddings
Theorem 5.3.2.
The functor from presheaves to categories fibered in sets is an equivalence.
Definition 5.3.3.
A category is fibered in groupoids if
Definition 5.3.4.
Recall the Grassmannian
where
6 Caleb (Nov 20): Stacks
6.1 Pursuing Stacks
We have been discussing fibered categories, and now we will be discussing fibered categories over a site. Our slogan to keep in mind is that a stack is a fibered category over a site with descent. Alternatively, a stack is a
Remark 6.1.1.
Algebraic stacks are very special kinds of stacks and we have the following analogy: algebraic stacks are to stacks as schemes are to sheaves.
Example 6.1.2.
The basic prototype of a stack is the arrow category of
Definition 6.1.3.
We now define an object with descent data. This is a collection
Remark 6.1.4.
The choices of
Here, we have the diagram
Given a covering
- Objects:
-
These are simply objects with descent data.
- Morphisms:
-
These are morphisms
such that the diagramα i : ε i → η i commutes.
Definition 6.1.5.
A functor
Note that this is a sheaf-like condition.
Definition 6.1.6.
An object with descent data is effective if it is isomorphic to the image of an object in
Thus by definition, stacks are prestacks such that all objects with descent data are effective.
Example 6.1.7.
Let
We now give some examples of stacks.
- 1.
Let
be a site. ThenC is a stack. This example is called a topos. This was apparently one of Grothendieck’s most profound ideas.𝖲𝗁 / C → C - 2.
Let
be a scheme. Then the categoryS is a stack in the fpqc topology. Apparently this is important.𝖰𝖢𝗈𝗁 / S → 𝖲𝖼𝗁 / S - 3.
The category
of affine arrows over𝖠𝖿𝖿 / S → 𝖲𝖼𝗁 / S is a stack in the fpqc topology.S - 4.
Because the speaker has been traumatized by combinatorics, we give the following: Let
be the category of trees with morphisms the embeddings and coverings the jointly surjective ones.1 Then fiber products are just intersections. We will defineT to be the category of proper colorings ofF ( T ) .T At risk of further infecting these notes with combinatorics, consider the chromatic symmetric function
X T = ∑ proper colorings x i # ( i appears ) . Then the conjecture is that
definesX T . It is easy to see that the category defined above is a stack.T
7 Caleb (Dec 04): Jacobians I
7.1 Divisors and Picard Groups
Let
Definition 7.1.1.
The group
Because
Example 7.1.2.
Let
Definition 7.1.3.
The Class group
Definition 7.1.4.
The principal divisors of
Now let
Definition 7.1.5.
We define the degree of
Now if
Example 7.1.6.
Define
Definition 7.1.7.
The Picard group
If
Example 7.1.8.
Let
7.2 Jacobian Functor
Now we will always assume
Definition 7.2.1.
Define the functor
However, we don’t want line bundles on
Unfortunately, this is still not necessarily representable.
Theorem 7.2.2.
There exists an abelian variety
Now let
Proposition 7.2.3.
There exists an exact sequence
where
The idea of the proof is that to show injectivity, let
Now suppose
Proposition 7.2.4.
Suppose
7.3 Relation to Complex Analysis
Consider
with kernel
8 Caleb (Dec 11): Jacobians II
8.1 Construction of the Jacobian
Let
If
We will use the correspondence between
Recalling the Riemann-Roch formula
Now we may define the map
Theorem 8.1.1.
For any birational group
In our case, we have
Theorem 8.1.2.
The idea of the proof is to define a map
8.2 Some results about the Jacobian
Here are some results about Jacobians. We are very far away from proving any of them.
Theorem 8.2.1.
For any abelian variety
Theorem 8.2.2 (Torelli).
Let
The proof allegedly involves complicated combinatorial arguments. For arithmetic geometers, there is the Shafarevich conjecture:
Conjecture 8.2.3 (Shafarevich).
Let
Using various facts about Jacobians, this implies Faltings’s theorem.
Theorem 8.2.4 (Faltings).
Let
Finally, there is a very roundabout way to prove the Riemann Hypothesis for curves. We can prove it for abelian varieties and then deduce it for a curve using the Jacobian.