Deformation theory
Deformation Theory Graduate Student Seminar
Fall 2021
Notes by Patrick Lei
Lectures by Various
Columbia University
Disclaimer
These notes were taken during the seminar using the vimtex package of the editor neovim. Any errors are mine and not the speakers’. In addition, my notes are picture-free (but will include commutative diagrams) and are a mix of my mathematical style and that of the lecturers. If you find any errors, please contact me at plei@math.columbia.edu.
1 Johan (Sep 24): Schlessinger’s paper
The paper by Schlessinger is titled Functors of Artin Rings. Throughout this lecture, is a field, is the category of Artinian local -algebras with residue field , and is the category of Noetherian complete local -algebras with residue field .
Remark 1.0.1.
Every is of the form by the Cohen structure theorem. Then if and only if and only if contains for some .
Remark 1.0.2.
In the paper, there is a more general setup, where is a complete local Noetherian ring with residue field . Then are defined analogously, which will allow things like .
The idea of deformation theory is to look at functors .
Example 1.0.3.
Given , we set sending . This is not necessarily representable because in general, but it is pro-representable.
Definition 1.0.4.
A functor is pro-representable if for some .
Example 1.0.5.
Let be a variety over and . Then define
It is easy to see that is pro-representable by .
Observe that is a singleton. Also note that . Here, is the fiber product of rings and not the tensor product.
Now consider the following conditions on : let be a diagram in and consider the morphism
- •
The morphism is surjective if ;
- •
The morphism is bijective if ;
- •
(later, we will see that we need for formulate this). Here, is the tangent space to ;
- •
The morphism is bijective if .
Example 1.0.6.
Fix a group and a representation . Now define
Better, we will define
In general these functors fail and even fails .
Namely, if and is the trivial representation, then for , we are looking at subsets of
This morphism is always surjective, but in general it is not injective.
For example, if , we can look at elements of the form and see that on the left we can only conjugate together, while on the right we can conjugate both arbitrarily. Here .
Definition 1.0.7.
A natural transformation of functors on is smooth if for all surjections the map is surjective.
Note that this is equivalent to the existence of a lift in the diagram below:
This definition is motivated by the following example: let be a morphism of varieties over . Let . Then the following are equivalent:
- 1.
is smooth.
- 2.
is smooth at .
Definition 1.0.8.
We say has a hull if and only if and there exists a smooth for some which induces an isomorphism .
Now we will say a bit about tangent spaces.
- 1.
When , then .
- 2.
If satisfies and , then has a natural -vector space structure. Here, gives is a bijection, and then we take , which defines addition.
- 3.
.
Theorem 1.0.9 (Schlessinger).
Asssume that . Then the conditions hold for if and only if has a hull. In addition, and hold if and only if is pro-representable.
Very rough idea of proof of for the hull case.
Let . Then and imply the following: Let and . We can find such that
is an isomorphism.
Next, we will choose and consider pairs where and such that . Say that if and . Choose a minimal pair for this ordering. We can choose so that and maps to for bookkeeping purposes.
Choose , which is a quotient of . Set given by sending to the following: choose such that factors as and take .
Finally, we must show that is smooth. Consider the diagram
with and . First, choose making the diagram commute. We may increase such that , so we now have . Now consider the fiber product and , so we obtain . By , we obtain some mapping to and . We may now assume that is a small extension, which means that , and thus is a small extension. Therefore, either is surjective or its image maps isomorphically via to ., so we have which gives lifting our given .
The tricky part is to show that , and this step is deliberately omitted. □
A generalization of this is as follows. Consider a functor . We say that satisfies the Rim-Schlessinger condition (RS) if
is an equivalence whenever . Let and set
where means that such that the diagram
commutes.
Theorem 1.0.10.
If has (RS) then has and . Therefore, if then has a hull.
In this situation, has if and only if whenever and .
Example 1.0.11.
Let be the category of representations with morphisms being isomorphisms of representations. This has (RS).
Example 1.0.12.
Let be the category of smooth projective families of curves of genus over with morphisms being isomorphisms. This has (RS).
Returning to the example of representations, it turns out that , where acts on via by conjugation.
Example 1.0.13.
Consider and to be the trivial representation on . Then . Given two matrices , we have the representation
We get a hull with . We know that is a some quotient of with looking like
and of course is the quotient of the power series ring by the ideal generated by the coefficients of .
2 Ivan and Cailan (Oct 1): Deformations of schemes
2.1 Deformations of affine schemes
We are looking for a Cartesian diagram of schemes
where is flat and surjective and is surjective. This is called an deformation of over . For the beginning of this lecture (the part given by Ivan), we are interested in , where (this category was defined in the previous lecture). This case is called a local deformation, and in the face where is Artinian, it is called an infinitesimal deformation.
For the ring theorists, we will make the following digression. Let be a ring and be an ideal with . Suppose that is an -algebra, is an -module, and is an -module map. Then we are interested in a diagram
which we will call a deformation of . Here are some interesting questions:
- 1.
Is such a deformation unique?
- 2.
If is flat over , does that mean that is flat over ?
Returning to the case of schemes, we will say that two deformations of over are isomorphic if there exists an -isomorphism commuting with the inclusions of the central fibers .
Example 2.1.1.
The most basic example of a family is the trivial deformation
Definition 2.1.2.
A scheme is rigid if all deformations of are isomorphic to the trivial deformation.
Theorem 2.1.3.
If is a smooth affine -scheme and for some local Artinian ring, then is rigid.
Definition 2.1.4.
A closed immersion of schemes is called a first (resp. nth) order thickening if the ideal sheaf satisfies (resp. ).
Definition 2.1.5.
A morphism is called formally smooth (resp. unfamified, resp. étale) if for all first order thickenings of affine schemes and diagrams
there exists a lift (resp. there is at most one such , resp. there exists a unique ).
Example 2.1.6.
- 1.
Open immersions are formally étale. This is cleaer because have the same underlying topological space.
- 2.
Closed immersions are formally unramified. This is clear because induces an injection on -points.
- 3.
is formally smooth. To see this, assume is affine and then consider the corresponding lifting problem in commutative algebra.
Proposition 2.1.7.
The classes of formally smooth (resp. étale, resp. unramified) morphisms are closed under base change, composition, and products and local on both source and target.
Definition 2.1.8.
A is smooth if it is formally smooth and locally of finite presentation.
We will now consider differentials. Let be an affine scheme over and choose a -point and consider the diagram
If is smooth, then there exists a lift . But this is given by a morphism
This motivates the following definition:
Definition 2.1.9.
Let be a morphism of rings and be an -module. A derivation is an -linear map satisfying the Leibniz rule.
Proposition 2.1.10.
There exists an -module equipped with a derivation that is universal among derivations from . This means that all derivations factor through , and formally, we have an identity
Definition 2.1.11.
For an -module with derivation , define the ring as the module with the multiplication
There is a sequence .
Proposition 2.1.12.
Let be a diagram of rings. Then
- 1.
;
- 2.
The sequence is exact.
- 3.
If for some ideal , we have an exact sequence
- 4.
For all , we havae .
Remark 2.1.13.
If , then .
Theorem 2.1.14.
Let be locally of finite presentation. The following are equivalent:
- 1.
is smooth;
- 2.
is flat with smooth fibers;
- 3.
is flat and has smooth geometric fibers.
We will finally return to deformation theory.
Lemma 2.1.15.
Let be a closed subscheme of determined by a nilpotent ideal sheaf . If is affine, then so is .
Proof of this result can be found in EGA, Chapter I.5.9.
Proof of Theorem 2.1.3.
Recall that we have a diagram of the form
where is flat and is a smooth -algebra. We need to prove that . The first step is to prove this result for first-order deformations. Suppose that is a square-zero extension.
Lemma 2.1.16.
For a ring with flat over , nilpotent ideal , and , then if is an isomorphism, then so is .
To prove the lemma, note that the cokernel of is preserved by , so it must vanish. Returning to our case, we know that is a smooth -algebra. Now we obtain a square-zero extension of and a diagram
with a lift . But now by the lemma, we have . The rest of the proof follows using an inductive argument that was verbalized but now written down. □
2.2 Deformations of schemes
The main theorem of this section is
Theorem 2.2.1.
Assume is a smooth -scheme. Then there is a bijection
Proof.
Let be a smooth deformation over . Then the diagram
is cartesian. Then if is an affine cover of and is an affine cover of , we have a -linear ring isomorphism
Modulo , is the identity on . Without loss of generality, we may assume that is a distinguished open for both and , so let and . Now note that both
induce the identity on modulo . Now we have the commutative diagram
Lemma 2.2.2.
The morphism must be of the form
where is a derivation.
In particular, this means that , where is a derivation.
By definition, we have
Therefore, . Note that
which implies that
and thus .
If two deformations are the same, note that is defined using a ring section of the canonical map . If is defined using another section , then define . We now compute
and thus the two differ by the desired coboundaries. □
We will now consider some obstructions. We are looking for a diagram of the form
for each pair , we have a isomorphism and a cocycle
This induces .
Now we will discuss some examples.
Theorem 2.2.3.
Let be a smooth projective curve, , and . We have the following table:
| degree | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 |
where where , if , and if . For , , and by Riemann-Roch and Serre duality, we have .
Theorem 2.2.4.
has no infinitesimal deformations.
Proof.
Consider the Euler sequence
and use the long exact sequence in cohomology. Because positive degree line bundles have no higher cohomology, we have . □
3 Kevin (Oct 08): Deformations of coherent sheaves
There will be no mixed characteristic funny business during this lecture. Let be a projective -scheme (proper might be fine, but this makes certain facts more true) and be a coherent sheaf on . Consider the deformation functor
We want to study the properties of this functor, which means we will check Schlessinger’s conditions:1 Let be a diagram in and consider the morphism
- •
The morphism is surjective if ;
- •
The morphism is bijective if ;
- •
(later, we will see that we need for formulate this). Here, is the tangent space to ;
- •
The morphism is bijective if .
Recall from Johan’s lecture that are equivalent to the existence of a hull and are equivalent to being pro-representable.
We only need to check for small extensions, which are extensions by a -vector spaace
where is killed by the maximal ideal of .
Theorem 3.0.1.
The functor admits a hull.
Lemma 3.0.2.
Let be a local Artinian ring.
- 1.
If , then .
- 2.
If induces an isomorphism and is flat over , then .
- 3.
If is flat, then is free.
Proof.
We know that , so , and thus . Next, suppose induces an isomorphism after killing . Then we know that the kernel and cokernel vanish because they are killed by , so must be an isomorphism. The last part is left as an exercise. □
Proof of theorem.
We will simply prove :
- 1.
Suppose that is a small extension and consider a pair . We know that we have isomorphisms , and so we take the fiber product
We only need to show that our sheaf is flat over because it clearly restricts to and . We can consider each sheaf as a module , and so we know is free over by the lemma. Choose a basis . Also consider the diagram
Then has -basis . Because surjects onto , we can lift the to , and these form a -basis for . This all implies that is free with basis .
- 2.
It suffices to prove injectivity. Suppose maps to , and so we have morphisms
We will prove that this diagram is Cartesian. By the lemma, the morphism is an isomorphism.
- 3.
We will prove that . We will only prove this in the case where is a vector bundle of rank . In this case, we have . Now we will associate cocycles to deformations. To each , we will associate an open cover and
and we write , where and . The cocycle condition is that
which is the same as
which is exactly the Čech -cocycle condition. Proving that equivalent cocycles give the same deformation is easy. □
Theorem 3.0.3.
The condition holds when is simple, which means that .
3.1 Tangent-obstruction theory
Suppose is a deformation functor. Then a tangent-obstruction theory for is given by finite-dimensional -vector spaces . Suppose we have a small extension
Then we have another exact sequence
which means that
- 1.
lifts to if and only if ;
- 2.
acts transitively on the fibers of ;
- 3.
If , then the action of acts simply transitively on .
Note that because acts simply transitively on , we must have . On the other hand, is not canonical.
Theorem 3.1.1.
The deformations admits a tangent-obstruction theory with and .
Proof.
We claim that if satisfies and , then naturally acts on for small extensions . To see this, note that . We also note that by , . Now define by , and this gives us an action of . To prove transitivity, apply to the diagram
Now we will consider obstructions. We will assume again that is a rank vector bundle, which we will call . Let
be a small extension, so we will consider . Consider an open cover and . We want to lift these to . If this is possible, we have a cocycle
and the cocycle condition is satisfied when . If any other , then we note that
and this gives us a class in . □
Remark 3.1.2.
Let be the hull of , which means we have a morphism . Then we know . We also know that .
Example 3.1.3 (Good example).
Let be a smooth projective curve and be a rank vector bundle. Then we know that
so deformations of are unobstructed. Now assume that is simple. Then by definition, and we also know that is pro-represented by some ring with
by Riemann-Roch.
Example 3.1.4 (Bad example).
Let be a smoorh projective variety and be a rank vector bundle on . Let . Then , and we would like to lift to .
We will compute the obstruction explicitly. We know give us classes , and after some magical computation, the obstruction to lifting is given by
where the cup product comes from the algebra structure on .
Now let be a product of curves. Then and . Suppose that and with nonzero cup product. Then we simply set and
this gives us our obstructed deformation.
4 Patrick (Oct 15): Deformations of singularities
We begin by fixing some notation. Let be a field and , where and is an ideal. Throughout this lecture, we will denote local Artinian rings with residue field by and rings by Finally, denote .
4.1 Explicit criteria for flatness
We will study (embedded) deformations of singular affine schemes embedded in . The first thing we want to understand is to explicitly understand flatness of some over , where . We will write , where . Recall that over a Noetherian local ring with residue field , a module is flat if and only if it is free, and this is equivalent to by standard results in commutative algebra.
Now consider the exact sequence
After tensoring with , we have
Therefore, we know that is flat over if and only if . We would like to understand this statement.
Consider a presentation
of . Then we know is flat over if and only if after tensoring with , we obtain an exact sequence
Note that to give this presentation is the same as giving a complete set of relations among the generators of .
Proposition 4.1.1.
Suppose that
| (4.1) |
is exact and
| (4.2) |
is a complex such that is exact and tensoring (2) with gives (1). Then is flat over .
Proof.
Note that the hypotheses are equivalent to the fact that all relations in can be lifted to . Now given such that
this clearly descends to a relation in by killing the maximal ideal of . But now if we choose a complete set of relations for , this descends to a complete set of relations in , so we may in fact assume that (2) is exact.
In this case, there exists some such that the sequence splits as
By right exactness of the tensor product, we know is exact. We also know that
is exact, again by right exactness. But this means that is the cokernel of , and therefore . This means that is flat. □
Corollary 4.1.2.
Let and , where and such that is a lift of . Then is flat over if and only if every relation among the lifts to a relation among the .
Remark 4.1.3.
This result essentially gives us that first-order embedded deformations of are given by . The first-order (not embedded) deformations of are given by the cokernel of
which arises from the exact sequence
and this is supported on the singular points of , so when has isolated singularities, this is finite-dimensional.
Note that if is a complete intersection, then is generated by a regular sequence, so in particular the Koszul complex is a free resolution of and therefore there are only trivial relations among the (this means the relations are generated by ). Clearly, because we are only considering commutative rings (after all, this is normal algebraic geometry), this means that all deformations of are unobstructed.
4.2 Hilbert schemes of smooth surfaces
We will prove that deformations of finite length closed subschemes of are unobstructed. In particular, this will imply that the Hilbert scheme is smooth.
Let be a closed subscheme of dimension . Then because has dimension , there exists a free resolution
of . In this case it is possible to understand the matrix , and in fact this is the special case of a more general result. First, when we study the local behavior, we have the following result.
Theorem 4.2.1 (Hilbert, Burch).
Let be a regular local ring of dimension and be a Cohen-Macaulay quotient of codimension . Then there exists an matrix whose maximal minors minimally generate , and there is a free resolution
Proof.
Note that the fact that the free resolution has this length is a corollary of the Auslander-Buchsbaum formula, which says that for a ring and module , we have
and the fact that depth equals dimension for Cohen-Macaulay things. Thus we have a free resolution
where are a minimal set of generators for . Let is times the determinant of the -th minor of . We will prove that the map is the same as the map ; clearly
is a resolution. This is because at the generic point of , we know is injective, so at least one is nonzero. But then we know is torsion-free (because is torsion-free), and so it in fact must vanish by rank reasons. Thus and are isomorphic as -modules.
At a codimension point in , note that is split exact (because has codimension ). This implies that at least one is a unit, and thus has codimension at least . But then the isomorphism is given by multiplication by some nonzero element of which is a unit away from codimension . But this means it is a unit everywhere. □
Considering the global picture in , we obtain the following result.
Theorem 4.2.2 (Hilbert, Schaps).
Let be a Cohen-Macaulay closed subscheme of codimension . Then has a free resolution of the form
where the are the maximal minors of the matrix .
This result in fact holds over any Artinian local ring , which we will use later.
Next, we want to understand what happens if we choose some Artinian local ring with residue field and lift the to , where .
Theorem 4.2.3 (Schaps).
If is a square zero extension of , then the sequence
is exact. Moreover, any lifting of over arises by lifting the matrix .
Proof.
We know that
is a complex. This is because composing the two maps amounts to evaluating determinants with a repeated column. Because is free (and therefore flat), we can tensor with the exact sequence
to obtain an exact sequence of complexes
Note that
In particular, this term is exact by Hilbert-Schaps. In addition, clearly because is a square zero extension, so the complex is exact. By the long exact sequence in homology, we know that is exact. Note that extends to an exact sequence
and extends to an exact sequence
However, by the homology long exact sequence, we have an exact sequence
But this implies that . Finally, by the local criterion for flatness, we see that is flat over .
Let be a lifting of over . Lift to . By Nakayama, these generate , so we obtain a free resolution
where lift the . However, we already have a lift
and so we must show . But we know that the ideals and are isomorphic as -modules. But then if we restrict this isomorphism to , we obtain a unit in . Because functions extend over codimension , we have , so this is a global unit. This gives the desired result. □
This result holds if we replace with any square-zero extension of Artinian local rings and with flat things, and so we see that (embedded) deformations of codimension Cohen-Macaulay subschemes of are unobstructed. In particular, any dimension closed subscheme is automatically Cohen-Macaulay (because it is dimension ), so its embedded deformations are unobstructed. By some cohomological argument, the tangent space to is isomorphic to and has dimension , so
4.3 An obstructed deformation
Let . Note that this scheme has an embedded point at the origin, so in particular it is not Cohen-Macaulay.
We will study embedded deformations of and see that they are obstructed. In particular, we will choose two deformations of over that cannot be simultaneously lifted. We claim that a complete set of relations (using the ordering for the generators of ) is given by the matrix
Now a first-order deformation of is given by lifting over , and the first candidate is to consider . Then we note that
and we can lift to kill this vector with the matrix
Next consider the deformation given by . We note that
and we can lift to kill this vector with the matrix
Now we consider and attempt to lift this deformation to . Note that
and clearly , so in fact we cannot lift this deformation to . This proves obstructedness.
5 Avi (Oct 22): Local-global methods
5.1 Curves with isolated singularities
Here, we will consider the same lifting problems that we have consider before. Let be a curve over and consider be the deformations of as a category cofibered over .
Definition 5.1.1.
A functor is smooth if given and over over and over in , then there exists some over the identity in .
There is an absolute notion, for to be smooth, where we set to be the category of trivial deformations. In this case, we also called unobstructed, and this corresponds to being unobstructed in the tangent-obstruction theory.
Theorem 5.1.2 (Local-to-global).
Let be separated of dimension at most and smooth away from finitely many points. At each singularity , consider the inclusions
into the henselizations and completions, respectively. Then the functors
are all smooth and induce isomorphisms on tangent spaces.
This means that we only have to check unobstructedness at the completions of the local rings at each singular point.
Proof.
First, we can reduce to the affine case.1 If is a curve, then can be covered by two affine opens such that are smooth. Because deformations of smooth affine schemes are unobstructed, we can essentially ignore . To do this, we will prove that is smooth.
Because smoothness (roughly) respects products, the functor
is smooth by formal reasons. Because are smooth, we can ignore (in fact, the arrow is an equivalence) and project down to .
Now is affine. Then each gives a maximal ideal , and so we set . If we consider the completion with respect to , this decomposes as
Applying Lemma 91.12.5 in the Stacks Project, the functor
is smooth and an isomorphism on tangent spaces. The henselization step is similar. □
Example 5.1.3.
Let . Then . We will show that all deformations look like in some sense. Really, we will show that has a hull, which is given by with universal deformation
We want such that is smooth and induces an isomorphism on tangent spaces. Given a morphism
we obtain a deformation
of . We can check that this is smooth, and so we need to check that we have an isomorphism of tangent spaces.
We want to compute . If , set , and we have a diagram
If we consider the exact sequence
and tensor with , by flatness we have an exact sequence
But because , we have a decomposition . If we choose lifts of , the product lifts , so . If we choose different lifts , we see that
But now , and so if we set , then we can write , and so there is a canonical choice of the element of , namely . Thus we can set
and now we have a diagram
By the five lemma, , and so we are done.
5.2 Smooth curves with a finite group action
In this section, we will consider lifting from characteristic to characteristic . This means we will have to redefine what lifting. Here, we will suppose with characteristic . Let be a Noetherian complete local ring with residue field . We define be the category of local Artinian -algebras with residue field .2
Forgetting about the requirement that is algebraically closed, if , then we can set . Let be the ring of Witt vectors in . This is apparently some universal Noetherian local ring lifting , and for example, , and . We will consider some extension of rings and write for the fraction field of .
We are interested in deforming smooth proper curves with the action of some finite group , conveniently denoted as a pair .
Definition 5.2.1.
The pair lifts to characteristic if there exists and a projective smooth curve with an action of such that .
Given the action of on , we can construct the quotient . To remember the data of the action, we remember the ramified Galois cover .3
Consider the action of on . This includes in , which has an action of . We want an embedding , but generally this is not possible. For example, set and consider the matrices
which generate a . But then all finite subgroups of are cyclic, dihedral, , , or , so this action clearly cannot lift.
Proposition 5.2.2.
Suppose is such that for all , the stabilizer has order prime to . Then lifts to characteristic .
Note that this is some local statement, so we need some kind of local-to-global method. Recall that , and this has an action of . Thus we define a local action as some action of a finite group on , and this lifts if there exists with an action of on specializing to the original action on .
Theorem 5.2.3.
For , suppose that the local action of on lifts to characteristic . Then lifts to characteristic .4
It is a fact that if acts faithfully on , then , where is -Sylow and is cyclic.
Proof of proposition.
We will simply prove that if is prime to , then the local action lifts. Then we know that is cyclic of order with generator . If we write
then of course if , then is a unit and hence is a unit, so . Our goal is to replace by some generator with a more explicit action of . Let be the vector space spanned by . Then on our designated basis, we have
This has eigenvalues the -th roots of , so we choose such that and replace . But now the action of clearly lifts to characteristic , so we are done. □
We have essentially proved that local actions of cyclic groups of order prime to lift to characteristic . Here is a mild generalization:
Conjecture 5.2.4 (Oort5).
The local action on by the action of any cyclic lifts to characteristic .
This is now a theorem due to (among others?) Obus, Wewers, and Pop. Because of this, if the stabilizers are all cyclic, then lifts. However, this is not a necessary condition for lifting. If we consider an action of on , this does lift (because ).
6 Caleb and Morena (Oct 29): Lemma 0E3X and applications to contracting curves
6.1 One lemma in the Stacks Project
Lemma 6.1.1.
In Example 0DY7 let be a morphism of schemes over . If and , then the morphism of deformation categories
is an equivalence.
Let be an Artinian local ring with residue field . Remember that is the set of isomorphism classes of diagrams
| (6.1) |
with flat. Also, consists of diagrams of the form
with flat.
Lemma 6.1.2 (Lemma 063Y).
Let be a morphism of first order thickenings such that is flat. Then the following are equivalent:
- 1.
is flat and ;
- 2.
The canonical map is an isomorphism, where is the conormal sheaf.
Proof.
In the affine case, write . Then we are looking for a diagram of the form
The two conditions become
- 1.
is flat and ;
- 2.
and .
To begin, note that is equivalent to , and this implies that and thus that is surjective. To prove injectivity, by flatness of , the map remains injective after tensoring with , so is injective.
In the other direction, we may cite Lemma 051C. Alternatively, we give the following argument. Assuming that is an isomorphism, we know , and thus . To prove that is flat over , we know that is flat over because is flat and . We will prove that if is an ideal, then is injective.
By some inexplicable brilliancy, we simply need to fill in the diagram
By diagram chasing reasons, we will have exactness. Consider the exact sequence
After tensoring with , we obtain a right exact sequence
This gives us the desired items in the question marks.
Now we want to prove that is injective. If we consider and tensor with , we obtain
but this is clearly actually
For the other part, we simply take
and tensor with . □
Proof of Lemma 0E3X.
We need to prove that is flat. We can compose any thickening as a sequence
Now we apply Lemma 063Y to each square and obtain
Now if we consider the exact sequence
Applying and the assumption that , we obtain an exact sequence
Now if we consider the diagram
we want to prove that is flat starting with being flat. But here, we know
and therefore we have
Now we may apply Lemma 063Y repeatedly to obtain flatness of . □
6.2 Application to moduli of curves
In this part of the lecture, we wish to define a contraction map that deletes a marked point. This was used by Knudsen to prove that is a smooth and proper stack over . Other applications include relations between and and their Chow groups. The roadmap for this section is:
- 1.
We will discuss stable curves over an algebraically closed field and define .
- 2.
We will define in the wrong way.
- 3.
We will define contraction of rational tails and bridges over an algebraically closed field correctly.
- 4.
Finally, we will use Lemma 0E3X to define contraction over any scheme.
6.2.1 Stable curves
We will define -marked genus stable curves over . Here, we will take to be a connected -dimensional scheme of finite type over . We will work only with nodal curves, which are curves where for every either is smooth and is a regular local ring and thus a UFD by Auslander-Buchsbaum or is a node and
Remark 6.2.1.
In fact, is reduced and thus is reduced, so every nodal curve is reduced.
Now let
be the normalization. We know that . To check this, recall that the normalization of a reduced scheme is constructed by gluing the local maps
But now we know that
However, we know that
This implies that is not local because is not local.
Proposition 6.2.2.
The arithmetic genus is given by
Proof.
Recall that . Then we have the exact sequence
Taking the long exact sequence in cohomology, we obtain
Because is finite, the Leray spectral sequence computing degenerates at the -page, and thus
But then we know . By connectedness of , we know that and . □
We now need to add marked points.
Definition 6.2.3.
A -marked, genus nodal curve over is a nodal curve of genus with smooth points .
This definition allows too many curves, so we want to define a notion of stability.
Definition 6.2.4.
A genus nodal curve with marked points is stable if for all irreducible components , we have
where a special point is a node or a marked point.
Example 6.2.5.
Over , consider a genus curve with two marked points , an elliptic curve with marked point , and a nodal cubic with no marked points all intersecting in a triangle. Here, we have three marked points and four nodes.1 By observation, this curve is stable.
Remark 6.2.6.
All of the are stable if and only if , and has at least one special point, or if and there are at least three special points.
6.2.2 Contraction done wrong
We will denote by be the fibered category whose objects over a scheme are given by the following data:
- •
A map proper and flat with sections and for any geometric point , the map and sections form a stable curve of genus .
- •
Morphisms are given by cartesian diagrams
that respect the sections.
Clearly the forgetful functor simply forgets the last section. Unfortunately, this does not actually respect the stability condition. The problem is when the component containing satisfies , because when we delete we lose stability. This only happens when and there is exactly one marked point (which is actually smooth and integral, so is an elliptic curve) or when and there are exactly three special points. In the second case, we may have with three marked points, two marked points and a node (rational tail), or one node and two marked points (rational bridge). Also, we may have a nodal cubic with one marked point.
6.2.3 Contraction done right
In this part, we construct from a prestable curve a stable curve . In the rational tail case, we are contracting the entire to the node and in the rational bridge case we identify the two nodes and collapse the to that point, leaving the two other components intersecting at a node (locally; globally this can be either one or two components). Of course, we need to check that and . Next, we need to check that contraction can be extended to a neighborhood in a canonical way when .
7 Morena (Nov 05): Contraction morphisms between moduli stacks of curves
7.1 Recap of last time
Recall that for , if and , then we have an equivalence of categories
We also attempted to construct a morphism using the forgetful functor, but this does not work. Remember the bad cases were called the rational tail and rational bridge. Also recall that the stability condition for every component was , where special points are nodes and marked points.
7.2 Contraction of rational tails and bridges
In the rational tail case, our stable curve should be the scheme-theoretic closure (so just topological closure) , where is the rational tail. Because is reduced, we see that is the pushout
Of course, this gives us a map by contracting . Now we need to check that is a prestable curve of genus which is actually stable and that if , then and .
To check the sheafy conditions, we have an exact sequence
This gives us a longer exact sequence
To see that , we only need to check that because . But here we have because , and so we need to prove surjectivity of the direct sum onto the skyscraper sheaf. This is clear.
Considering
we see that and
To check stability of , we simply note that stability condition of the component attached to is unchanged, and everything else was untouched, so we have a stable curve.
We now check the rational bridge case. Here we consider the pushout
This exists and has nice properties. What this really means is that we contract and introduce a new self-intersection at . Now the contraction morphism is given by considering the total pushout of
Restricting to an affine piece, where and , we obtain a fiber product diagram of rings
We can now tensor with , and we need to show that that . Because completions are exact, we can consider the fiber product diagram
Because , we see that
and thus is a node.
7.3 Contraction over any base scheme
Theorem 7.3.1.
Let . Then there exists a contraction such that
and the following conditions hold:
- 1.
.
- 2.
and , and this is stable under base change. In addition, for all geometric points , is either an isomorphism or a contraction of a rational tail or rational bridge.
Moreover, is unique up to unique isomorphism.
Corollary 7.3.2.
The morphism is defined over .
Proof.
We know what happens to objects. We know that morphisms are cartesian diagrams
But now we have two candidate contractions of , namely and . But these have a unique isomorphism. These fit into the diagram
This gives us compatibility with morphisms. □
To prove the theorem, we want to work étale locally over , with a cover . Then there exists a factorization , and then we need to check that the cocycle condition works on the overlaps. The existence of a global factorization means that our data is effective, and this is the same as is a stack.
To prove existence of a factorization étale locally, over , we have a contraction . We want to prove that there exists an étale neighborhood such that there exists a factorization extending . In order to do this, we need to do some reduction. If is affine is of finite type over , we want such that , and thus .
Lemma 7.3.4.
The category of schemes of finite presentation over is the colimit of the categories of schemes of finite presentation over .
Now if , then . Thus we may consider . Write for this henselization. Then if we consider , we have fiber product diagrams
This gives us a formal object of . But now we know that
and thus we actually have deformations of over . But this gives us a formal element of
Now using 01W0, we have .
Theorem 7.3.5.
The data is effective.
For a sketch of this, note that the first stability condition is an open condition. If are the marked points, then write . Stability is equivalent to being ample, and so over we have an ample line bundle . We can lift this to because obstructions live in
Using the Grothendieck algebraization theorem, we see that if is proper and is ample, there exists a proper morphism and an ample line bundle such that base change to recovers .
Here, we know that is finite type and separated while is proper, and so there exists a unique . We now need to return back to . But now we know that is the direct limit of its finitely-generated (over ) subalgebras. This gives us . We know that
is regular, it is flat, and thus is noetherian and geometrically regular over by Popescu. We have the diagram
Because is henselian, we have a section , and thus we have a base change to .
8 Baiqing (Nov 12): Deformations of group schemes
8.1 Deformations of abelian schemes
Definition 8.1.1.
An abelian scheme is a proper smooth group scheme over a connected scheme with geometrically connected fibers.
If is a field, then is projective. However, this is not true in general.
Definition 8.1.2.
The deformation functor is defined for an abelian variety over and the category of local Artinian -algebras with residue field . It is given by
where if there exists an isomorphism of abelian schemes such that .
Theorem 8.1.3.
Let be an abelian variety of dimension over . Then the deformation functor is pro-representable by .
Recall Schlessinger’s criterion from Johan’s lecture.1 Note that if is formally smooth and is surjective for all , then is pro-representable by a power series ring , where .
We will prove the conditions and then prove that the deformation functor is formally smooth. Before this, we will consider the geometry of abelian schemes.
Lemma 8.1.4 (Rigidity lemma).
Given a diagram
suppose that is connected, is flat and proper, and for all . If for some point , is set-theoretically a single point, then there exists a section such that .
Corollary 8.1.5.
Let be abelian schemes over and . If , then is a homomorphism. Here, refers to the identity section.
This result holds in general if we replace be an arbitrary group scheme.
Sketch of proof.
Consider the diagram
Consider the morphisms given by and . Now we argue that . □
Also, it is clear that abelian schemes are commutative because inversion takes the identity to itself and thus is a homomorphism. If are two homomorphisms and for some , then . Next, if is a morphism of schemes between abelian schemes, then is a homomorphism.
We will now prove for . For a small extension , we show that
is a bijection. This is equivalent to proving that in the diagram
if along the bottom arrow, then .
Proposition 8.1.6.
is the set of isomorphism classes of such that is flat over and is an isomorphism as schemes over .
Choose . Then there exists an isomorphism of abelian schemes. Now we will send . Checking uniqueness is easy with the diagram
Now we check that if , then they are sent to the same thing. This was erased from the board by Baiqing before I could process it.
Now we prove injectivity. If map to equivalent , then there exists such that . This implies that . Unfortunately, is not an isomorphism of abelian schemes, so we can replace it by .
Finally, we prove surjectivity, which is the difficult part of the argument.
Proposition 8.1.7.
Let , where is an Artinian local ring, be the maximal ideal, and such that . Let be proper and smooth, be a section of , , and . Then if is an abelian scheme with identity , then is an abelian scheme with identity .
Theorem 8.1.8.
Let are smooth schemes. Suppose that is a small extension. Let and . For any over , there is a canonically associated class . If , then .
Proof of proposition.
Given , we want , where . We have on , and so we want to deform this to on . We know that
but because is an abelian variety, we have
We want to show that . Consider and . Then , and thus . Also, and . We know that
Consider the morphisms and . But now we see that they are given by and , and so .
Now consider and let be a deformation of . Then
is a deformation of . Under the identification
and using what we have done previously, we have and therefore an abelian scheme structure. □
Finally we prove that is surjective for . Let . Then . We want to prove that is nonempty. We know that induces on , and so , and if we are working not in characteristic , .
To compute the dimension of the tangent space, we want to compute , but this is , which has dimension .
8.2 Deformations of smooth affine group schemes
We will now discuss deformations of and . Let be an affine smooth algebraic group scheme. We will consider the deformation problem
For example, for , we know that is a deformation of . We want to deform the multiplication, and so we have . To check associativity, we obtain
We will also consider equivalent if there exists such that . Therefore we have
Proposition 8.2.1.
In fact, we have .
Proof.
let . Then . If we set
adjust by such that . Now we have the equation
and thus . □
For the additive group, our deformed multiplication is given by . Associativity is equivalent to the condition
The trivial deformations are given by , and thus we have
This deformation space vanishes in characteristic and is infinite-dimensional in positive characteristic. If we apply to the associativity relation, we obtain
and if we apply , we obtain
and therefore . In characteristic , has a primitive, and so taking the primitive twice we obtain a desired . Primitives do not exist in positive characteristic, so this proof does not work. However, it is possible to work out the following:
Proposition 8.2.2.
In positive characteristic , is a linear combination of for and for , where .
9 Haodong (Nov 19): Artin’s axioms
9.1 Prestacks and stacks
First, we will generalize the Zariski topology a little bit.
Definition 9.1.1.
Let be a category. Then a Grothendieck topology on is given by a set for each , where each element in is a collection of morphisms in . We require that
- 1.
All isomorphisms are in .
- 2.
If and , then exist and .
- 3.
If is a covering of and is a covering of for all , then is a covering of .
A site is a category with a Grothendieck topology.
Example 9.1.2.
Let be a scheme and let . For every , we say that is a covering if all are open immersions and the are jointly surjective. This gives the big Zariski site of . If we replace open immersion with étale morphism, then we obtain the big étale site.
9.1.1 Prestacks
Definition 9.1.3.
Let be a category and be a functor. We will denote objects of by and objects in by . We will denote morphisms in by respectively. We say that is a prestack if the following conditions are satisfied:
- 1.
If and is a morphism, there exists and a morphism such that filling the diagram
- 2.
If we have
there exists a unique morphism filling in the above arrow.
Exercise 9.1.4.
For every , the category over has morphisms those lying over the identity and is thus a groupoid.
Example 9.1.5.
Let be a functor. We will define to have objects , where and . Then morphisms are morphisms such that . We will define , and this defines a prestack, which we will simply call .
Example 9.1.6.
Let be a scheme and . If is an -scheme, then is a presheaf on and by the previous example defines a prestack over , which we will call .
Example 9.1.7.
Consider the functor where the objects are morphisms , where is a scheme over and is smooth and proper with all geometric fibers connected curves of genus . Morphisms are simply pairs such that .
Definitions 9.1.8.
Let be a site.
- 1.
A morphism of prestacks is a functor such that for all , .
- 2.
If are morphisms of prestacks, then a -morphism is a natural transformation such that for all , lies over the identity in . In particular, is an isomorphism.
- 3.
A diagram
is a -commutative diagram if there exists a -morphism .
- 4.
is called an equivalence if there exists such that and .
Lemma 9.1.9 (2-Yoneda lemma).
Let be a prestack and . Then is a prestack on and the functor given by is an equivalence of categories.
Now we want a fiber product of prestacks for , which is simply the final object in all -commutative diagrams
Fortuantely, these do exist.
Example 9.1.10.
The product exists and is a prestack. We also have a diagonal .
Example 9.1.11.
Let be a prestack and be morphisms. Then there exists a -cartesian diagram
9.1.2 Stacks
Definition 9.1.12.
A prestack over a site is called a stack if for every , we have
- 1.
(morphisms glue) There exists a unique filling in the diagram
lying over
Precisely, this means that given and such that , then there exists a unique such that for all .
- 2.
(objects glue) Given and isomorphisms satisfying the cocycle condition on , there exists and isomorphisms such that .
Example 9.1.13.
Consider the prestack over with objects , where is a sheaf on . Then is a pair and such that the adjoint of is an isomorphism . We know that sheaves and their morphisms can be glued in the Zariski topology, so the prestack is a stack over .
Example 9.1.14.
Consider the prestack over with objects and morphisms is a pair and such that the two compositions agree. Of course schemes can be glued in the Zariski topology, so is a stack in .
Proposition 9.1.15.
is a stack over for .
Remark 9.1.16.
The stackiness conditions mainly come from descent theory.
9.2 Algebraic stacks and Artin’s axioms
From now on, we will work in the category of schemes over .
9.2.1 Algebraic stacks
Definition 9.2.1.
A morphism of prestacks is representable by schemes if for all schemes , the fiber product is also a scheme. A representable is surjective, smooth, etc if for all schemes , the morphism is surjective, smooth, etc.
Definition 9.2.2.
An algebraic space is a sheaf on such that there exists a scheme and a surjective étale which is representable by schemes.
Definition 9.2.3.
A morphism is called representable if for all schemes , is an algebraic space. Moreover, a representable is called surjective, smooth, etc if is surjective, smooth, etc.
Definition 9.2.4.
A algebraic stack over is a stack such that there exists a scheme with a morphism that is smooth, surjective, and representable.
This is equivalent to the following conditions (taken together):
- 1.
The diagonal is representable.
- 2.
There exists a scheme and a smooth surjective morphism .
A useful fact that the product and fiber products of algebraic stacks exist (in the category of algebraic stacks), and this is the same as their fiber products as prestacks.
Definition 9.2.5.
We say that of algebraic stacks is locally of finite type if for all (for some) smooth presentations and , the composition
is locally of finite type.
9.3 Artin’s Axioms
Definition 9.3.1.
Let be a stack over . Then is limit-preserving if
is an equivalence of categories. Explicitly, this means:
- 1.
Every object on the right hand side comes from for some and some .
- 2.
For , we have
This should be viewed as a finiteness condition because if is a scheme, then is limit-preserving if and only if is locally of finite presentation.
Definitions 9.3.2.
Let be a prestack over . A formal object of is , where is a complete local Noetherian -algebra, , and are morphisms in lying over .
A morphism of formal objects is a collection of morphisms such that
commutes. These define morphisms that are compatible, and hence a morphism .
There is a functor from to the category of formal objects . We say that a formal object is effective if it is in the essential image of this functor.
Definition 9.3.3.
Let be a complete local Noetherian -algebra and . We say that is versal if for any diagram
such that is a surjection of local Artinian -algebras and is an isomorphism, then there exists such that extending .
A formal object is versal if in the same diagram, if we replace wuth and with , we can find a lift to for some .
Theorem 9.3.4 (Artin’s axioms).
Let be a stack over . Then is an algebraic stack locally of finite type over if and only if
- 0.
is limit-preserving.
- 1.
The diagonal is representable.
- 2.
(formal deformations) for every , there exists a complete local Noetherian -algebra and a versal formal object such that .
- 3.
Every formal object is effective.
- 4.
(openness of versality) Let , where is a scheme of finite type over , and be a -point such that is versal. Then is versal at all -points in an open neighborhood of .
Remark 9.3.5.
Suppose we want to prove that Artin’s axioms imply that is an algebraic stack locally of finite type over . Given a formal object , we have an actual object . By approximation and algebraization, we have finite type and versal at . Now is smooth, so we have smooth, surjective, and representable.
Remark 9.3.6.
In many modular problems, the condition about formal deformations follows from the Rim-Schlessinger condition that for a diagram
of Artinian local -algebras, the map
is an equivalence of categories. Here, if , define by such that lies over . Then is a -vector space. If , then we have the condition on formal deformations. Then smoothness of gives versality.
Remark 9.3.7.
The third condition follows from Grothendieck’s existence theorem, and a deformation-obstruction theory gives openness of versality.
10 Che (Dec 03): Stack of coherent sheaves
Let be an algebraically closed field of characteristic , be the étale site of schemes over , and be a projective scheme over .
Definition 10.0.1.
Let be the category defined as follows:
- •
Objects are tuples of a scheme and is a quasicoherent sheaf on of finite presentation flat over .
- •
Morphisms from to are pairs , where is a morphism of schemes and is an isomorphism of -modules. Here, is the morphism induced from .
There is a functor given by , and we want to prove that is an algebraic stack. Also, we will abuse notation and write for . We will prove that satisfies Artin’s axioms. Recall that these are
- (0)
is a stack. This means that is a prestack and objects and morphisms glue.
- (1)
is representable by algebraic spaces.
- (2)
is limit-preserving.
- (3)
satisfies the Rim-Schlessinger condition.
- (4)
The tangent spaces and are finite-dimensional.
- (5)
Every formal object is effective.
- (6)
satisfies openness of versality.
These will imply that there is a smooth surjective covering of by a scheme.
10.1 is a stack
First, we will prove that is a prestack. We note that has objects finitely presented on flat over and morphisms , where is an isomorphism. Thus is a groupoid. We now want to prove that pullbacks exist, which is clear because given and an object , our pullback is simply . To show that pullbacks are universal, consider . Now suppose that we have morphisms and . Now we want to prove that there exists an isomorphism . But we know that
and so we are done.
Now we want to check that objects glue. Given and a covering , suppose we have on flat over . Suppose that the are isomorphic on intersections and satisfy the cocycle condition. We want to construct a on of finite presentation, flat over . This follows from étale descent, so we are done.
We now want to prove that morphisms glue. To do this, we need to introduce some new notions.
Definition 10.1.1.
Given and , define the Isom presheaf sending a scheme to the set in .
It is easy to see that morphisms glue if and only if this is a sheaf, and we will omit the proof.
10.2 Representability of the diagonal
We want to prove that for all schemes over , the stack given by pullback in the diagram
is an algebraic space. By the -Yoneda lemma, a map is given by in . If we compute the fiber product , we actually obtain the Isom presheaf . We will use without proof the fact that is a closed subfunctor of (defined by ).
10.3 Preservation of limits
Given , we want to prove that is the colimit of the . Given on of finite presentation and flat over , we want to show that there exist such that .
Proposition 10.3.1.
Let be rings such that is the colimit of the . Let be an -module of finite presentation. Then there exists and a finitely-presented -module such that .
Proof.
We know that is finitely presented, so we have an exact sequence
Because is the colimit of the , there exists such that lift to . If we define by
this is clearly the desired . □
Checking flatness is too hard, so we will not do it.
10.4 Rim-Schlessinger
We will not prove this, but we will see that this is a natural condition to satisfy. Given a pushout diagram
where are spectra of local Artinian rings of finite type over and is a closed embedding, we want the functor
to be an equivalence of categories.
10.5 Finiteness
We want to prove that the tangent space and the infinitesimal automorphisms are finite-dimensional. Given (which is just a finitely presented sheaf on ), the tangent space is
In addition, we know that
Because is projective, these Ext groups are finite-dimensional.
10.6 Formal objects are effective
We will now prove that formal objects are effective. Let be a complete Noetherian local ring. Recall that a formal object is , where along with living over the natural inclusions. A formal object is effective if it comes from an actual object over .
In our case, a formal object is given by on flat and finitely presented and . We want to show that there exists over restricting to each .
Theorem 10.6.1 (Grothendieck existence theorem).
Let be a Noetherian ring which is complete with respect to some ideal . Let be a proper morphism. Let . Then the functor
is an equivalence.
In our case, take and , and now we are done.
11 Johan (Dec 10): Openness of versality
Let be an algebraically closed field. In this lecture, all schemes live over for simplicity.
11.1 Moduli of curves
Recall that is a stack such that a morphism is a family of stable curves of genus . Assume that is of finite type over and let .
Definition 11.1.1.
We say that is versal at if and the map
given by are a hull.
Lemma 11.1.2.
is versal if and only if is smooth at and is surjective.
Proof.
Earlier, we discussed that deformations of are unobstructed. Therefore any hull is a power series ring over . Thus must be smooth at . If is smooth at , then look at , where is the deformation ring of . But now this is a map of power series rings, and therefore defines a smooth transformation of functors if and only if the map on tangent spaces is surjective. □
Lemma 11.1.3.
We have openness of versality for and .
Proof for .
By the previous lemma, we may assume that is smooth. Call and consider the exact sequence
This gives . Taking fibers aat , we obtain
Also, is a vector bundle of rank over . By the lemma and the assumption of versality at , we see this is surjective. Thus this is surjective in an open neighborhood. □
Proof for 1.
Consider the exact sequence
We think of this as in the derived category, and now if we tensor with the relative dualizing sheaf, we have
where is the right adjoint to in this case. This gives
By positivity properties, . Taking the fiber at , we have
By the same argument as before, we are done. □
11.2 Properties of cotangent complexes
Suppose that is of finite type over . Then there is a complex such that called the cotangent complex. Suppose we write
with minimal. This implies that . Then is the cotangent space of at and thus has dimension . Next we note that
and this has dimension .
Now let be a morphism of schemes of finite type over . Write . Then if we consider the distinguished triangle
we see that is smooth at if and only if is injective and is surjective.
Remark 11.2.1.
Suppose that is a proper flat morphism corresponding to , where is the prestack pramaterizing families of of flat proper schemes. Then we have , and tensoring with the dualizing complex, we have
We should consinder instead
Versality is then related to properties of for .
11.3 Coherent sheaves
Let be proper. Then is a stack such that for all of finite type, a morphism is a coherent sheaf on which is flat over .
Lemma 11.3.1.
We have openness of versality for .
Easy case.
We will assume that is a vector bundle and . As before, we may assume that is smooth and is a vector bundle. We then have the Atiyah extension
and a map . Then we have the Atiyah class
Dually, we have ,
etc. By similar arguments as before, we obtain the desired result. □
General case (terrible).
We have an Atiyah class
This yields
The adjunction gives us
We need to show that formation of the left hand side commutes with base change and that
and then we can use cohomology and base change. □
11.4 A trick
Sometimes we can get openness of versality for a prestack . Here, openness of versality holds for the prestack if
- 1.
is representable by algebraic spaces.
- 2.
We have the condition , which is a version of RS where the rings do not need to be Artinian.
- 3.
is limit-preserving.
- 4.
The following effectiveness holds: If where
where each is surjective with square zero kernel, then .
In the example on , we have on , and then we can attempt to take the limit of the . This fails because the limit is not quasicoherent, but we can fix it.