The Count of Instantons
The Count of Instantons
2023-24
Notes by Davis Lazowski and Patrick Lei
Lectures by Nikita Nekrasov
Columbia University
Disclaimer
These notes were taken during the lectures using neovim (Patrick) and VSCode (Davis). Any errors are mine and not the speakers’. In addition, my notes are picture-free (but will include commutative diagrams) and are a mix of my mathematical style and that of the lecturers. Also, notation may differ between lectures. If you find any errors, please contact me at plei@math.columbia.edu.
Unfortunately, I cannot guarantee that the notation in these notes is consistent. Please do not judge this too harshly.
Description
Graduate level introduction to modern mathematical physics with the emphasis on the geometry and physics of quantum gauge theory and its connections to string theory. We shall zoom in on a corner of the theory especially suitable for exploring non-perturbative aspects of gauge and string theory: the instanton contributions. Using a combination of methods from algebraic geometry, topology, representation theory and probability theory we shall derive a series of identities obeyed by generating functions of integrals over instanton moduli spaces, and discuss their symplectic, quantum, isomonodromic, and, more generally, representation-theoretic significance.
Quantum and classical integrable systems, both finite and infinite-dimensional ones, will be a recurring cast of characters, along with the other (-) characters.
Acknowledgements
Notes were taken by Patrick Lei for all lectures until March 22, 2024 except for the lecture on December 8, 2023. Davis Lazowski provided notes for the lecture on December 8, 2023 and for all lectures from March 29, 2024 onwards. Slight edits (in form, not in content) were made to the notes taken by Davis to make them fit with Patrick’s stylistic conventions.
1 Classical mechanics
We will be discussing three types of physics in an attempt to create something mathematically interesting:
- •
Classical physics;
- •
Statistical physics;
- •
Quantum physics;
1.1 Classical physics
1.1.1 Hamiltonian dynamics
We will begin with a space of classical states, which is most commonly known as a phase space. This is a symplectic manifold , where and satisfies
This carries a function
called a Hamiltonian. Then there is a vector field described by
which generates a -parameter group of symplectomorphisms of . The evolution law of the physical system is given by
Because acts by symplectomorphisms, the graph
is a Lagrangian submanifold. Recall that a submanifold of a symplectic manifold is called Lagrangian if and .
Exercise 1.1.1.
Locally any symplectic manifold is given by with the symplectic form
This coordinate system on is unique up to .
Now if is a vector field such that , then . Thus there locally exists a Hamiltonian . We also need the Hamiltonian vector field to be linear in the local coordinates, so the Hamiltonian itself must be quadratic.
Example 1.1.2.
An important example of a symplectic manifold is for any smooth manifold . There is a -form on given by the following formula. If is a tangent vector at the point , then
Then is a symplectic form.
Example 1.1.3.
Another large class of examples are obtained by symplectic reduction. Here, we suppose that a symplectic manifold carries the action of a compact Lie group by exact symplectomorphisms. This defines a moment map by the formula
There is some ambiguity in the choice of constants, but in the end we obtain a new space
In practice, we want the moment map to be equivariant with respect to the coadjoint action on . Then the manifold has a canonical symplectic form, but this requires a lot of work.
Now consider and , where we write and acts by rotations. Then the moment map is actually
so is a sphere. We then obtain
We made no use of the complex numbers, so the fact that we obtain a complex manifold will be viewed as a bonus. The reduced symplectic form is simply times the Fubini-Study form.
Note that is compact, so the interpretation that phase space records position and momentum breaks down. In this case, our phase space is called the classical spin phase space, where the motion is by rotations rather than by translation.
Remark 1.1.4.
We will often consider time-dependent Hamiltonians, where .
1.1.2 Lagrangian mechanics
There is another point of view, where dynamics on are given by an optimization problem on the space
of paths in . We will consider an action
where we assume that . If we further require that and , our dynamics are well-defined if are Lagrangian submanifolds. Of course, we are looking for paths were .
1.1.3 Classical field theory
Classical field theory should be thought of as an infinite-dimensional version of classical mechanics, where we study loopified versions of finite-dimensinoal manifolds. We want to consider integrals
where is the spacetime, is a metric, and are the fields. Fields could be one of several options:
- •
Scalars , where is a Riemannian manifold;
- •
Connections on principal bundles
called gauge fields;
- •
The metric itself, called gravity.
We can introduce more complexity into the problem by varying the action and looking for solutions of PDEs, introducing boundary to , and other operations. Also note that Lagrangian mechanics can be interpreted as a -dimensional classical field theory.
1.2 Statistical physics
In statistical physics, a point is replaced by a cloud of points, or a probability measure. For example, the measure could contain the term , where was the classical Hamiltonian and is a parameter of our distribution (inverse temperature). The system often flows to a stationary distribution, which is determined by the outside world. In reality, the distribution will have the form
This factor is called the partition function, and most of our energy is spent on computing this partition function.
1.3 Classical physics with multiple times
Suppose we have Hamiltonians such that . Then we obtain dynamics
and an action
defined on paths inside the cube . The extreme case of this is an integrable system where the are functionally independent, and the maximum possible value of is .
Theorem 1.3.1 (Liouville-Arnold).
If the motion is finite (fits in a compact set), then locally is a fibration
such that the factor through and the span the rotations on each factor of .
A typical trajectory is a winding of the torus, where if are the angle coordinates on , there is the formula
Generically, these paths will have dense image.
In the special case of an integrable system, there are action-angle variables, where the symplectic form is
The are defined up to affine transformations. If form a basis, then the are defined by
Here, is transported to other fibers via the Gauss-Manin connection. We should note that the are not well-defined, but the quantities are well-defined.
Because the are defined on the base , we can write . Fixing , we can flow along
we obtain
In “reality,” which is non-integrable, consider an approximation
Then we can understand the approximate evolution with respect to by averaging over .
1.4 Gauge symmetry
We would now like to discuss the idea of gauge symmetries and gauging in the Lagrangian formalism. Recall that the phase space carries an action
and we want to consider the effect of an action of a group on . The moment map
is equivariant with respect to the coadjoint representation. Note that has a symplectic form , and locally looks like
Thus restricted to a tubular neighborhood of has the form
Recall that we are looking for extrema of , and we need to find a path on the quotient space. We need to enlarge the space of variables to include . Now we will define
The space of possible has an infinite-dimensional symmetry generated by
The action is given by
Note that transforms as a connection, not as a -form.
Remark 1.4.1.
The translation by compensates for the change of under the action of .
1.4.1 Rational Calogero-Moser model
The first example is called the Calogero-Moser-Sutherland model. The phase spaces are
with the standard form
For any , the Hamiltonian is given by
These are systems of particles where they start out very far away from each other, are brought closer together, and then repel themselves apart again. These turn out to be integrable systems, and in fact they can be obtained by reduction of a system on a higher-dimensional symplectic manifold.
Define the unreduced phase space
This is a pair of Hermitian matrices with a vector . The Liouville form will be written as
Then we may define the Hamiltonians
The flows look like
so they clearly commute. This system carries a symmetry, where
Because this preserves the symplectic form, we may perform the symplectic reduction. Becuase is not simple, there is a free parameter , so the moment map is given by
We only need to solve up to , so we choose a diagonal representative of . Thus, assume that is diagonal with . Generically, the inequalities are strict. Then
If , then , so the remaining -action can be used to set . We can now compute
for the non-diagonal elements. We cannot compute the diagonal elements of , so we obtain
In this form, the Hamiltonians become
which is what we wanted. We need to show that , so we will compute the Poisson brackets of various functions. Recall that functions on form a Lie algebra with the Poisson bracket
We note that
The functions we will consider are the resolvents
Because the trace is cyclic, we obtain
Therefore
On the reduced space, the functions become
This is equivalent to , so .
Note that this system has an alternative presentation where we assume that and
Then the Hamiltonians reduce to
and the flows are given by
This system is not very interesting, but we could instead consider
and obtain a system with position and momentum exchanged.
1.4.2 Trigonometric Calogero-Moser (Sutherland)
Now consider . Then we have a triple where is Hermitian and is unitary. The moment map is given by
We may choose to either diagonalize as or diagonalize as . Making the latter choice, we obtain
The Hamiltonians in this case are
Making the former choice, we obtain another integrable system called the rational relativistic Calogero-Moser system or the rational Ruijsenaars model. In this model, the Hamiltonians look like
Here, a relativistic particle in dimensions has energy and momentum given by
so .
1.5 Infinite-dimensional symmetries
We will now replace with , which is a central extension of the space of maps with commutator given by
Then is not but instead
with the pairing
We will also consider the Lie algebra , but this requires us to specify some kind of boundary conditions at . We may also consider . In the case of , note that
is a -cocycle and that
is -dimensional, so this is the only nontrivial cocycle.
The corresponding group is given by the following construction. Define
Then is a nontrivial -bundle
Note that . The cohomology is nontrivial with a nontrivial class given by
Then there is an evaluation map
and then
represents . Therefore, we have an identification
where with multiplication
To embed as a normal subgroup, we make use of the fact that , so any map can be extended to . Then we define
The fact that this construction is well-defined is the Polyakov-Wiegmann formula.
We will now discuss the adjoint and coadjoint actions of on respectively. Infinitesimally, we have
The action on the dual space is given by
Therefore, we obtain
Note that is a -connection -form on .
There is now a natural candidate for a symplectic form, which is
Here, is the differential in the space of fields. The moment map is given by
where . We will now compute
We will now solve the moment map equation with the assumption that . We will scale , so the equation becomes
This is a first order matrix differential equation with periodic coefficients which can be studied using Floquet-Lyapunov theory. This says that there exists such that
is constant and lies in a maximal Cartan of . What this means is that we can write
These satisfy the equations and . The monodromy is
This must commute with , so we can bring
Recall that can be brought to and can be brought to and . There is still some remaining symmetry by
where is in the lattice of coroots and is the coordinate. This shifts while preserving monodromy. The second kind of remaining symmetry is the Weyl group . Taking their semidirect product, we obtain the affine Weyl group.
If we consider the weight space decomposition of the moment map equation and is a root of , then the equation for this component is
Because , this is generically not , so . Therefore , and we obtain
Note that parameterizes conjugacy classes of and that . Unfortunately, the reduced space is an orbifold, not a manifold.
We will now attempt to remedy this situation by modifying the quotient. Instead of setting the moment map to be , we want to consider an orbit. We want , and if , acts on by evaluation at some . We choose such that up to , and the modified equation is
Remark 1.5.1.
While most of the orbits are infinite dimensional, we are taking some limit where becomes a distribution on supported on finitely many points.
We first apply Floquet-Lyupanov to make diagonal with . Then on each coordinate we obtain
Because for any , . Using the maximal torus, we may force . Then we obtain
Finally, the initial value is
Note that this appeared in our study of the Sutherland system.
2 Quantum mechanics
2.1 Quantization
The motivation for complexification of our systems is quantization. Recall that if is the action of a Lagrangian system, many systems are not described by solving the variational equation
but by meditating on formal path integrals (due to Feynman)
The classical system is obtained via stationary phase approximation. Mathematically, this is ill-defined, but if is a finite-dimensional manifold, we can consider oscillating integrals
Here, is one of many possible cycles in the complexification and is viewed as a holomorphic top-degree form, so this is just a period. If , then we may consider other such that
converges. These will satisfy
where
is set to force the integral to converge. These are chosen to flow from critical points of (equivalently, of ) in into . We can construct cycles using Lefschetz thimbles. We can choose a critical point which satsifies and then consider the steepest descent flow for , or in other words
where the gradient is taken with respect to some metric on , and finally take the union of descending trajectories. If we choose a Hermitian metric, then is actually constant. For a generic choice of , the critical points have different imaginary parts, but in the special settings we may have Stokes phenomena and wall-crossing behavior of solutions.
Exercise 2.1.1.
What happens for ?
2.2 Holomorphic symplectic dynamics
Now let be a holomorphic symplectic manifold and consider and
We will take and we want to find points with .
Remark 2.2.1.
When we quantize everything, we will obtain
We obtain the equations
If is real, this is the usual Hamiltonian dynamics, but there may not be real solutions if is not real. On the other hand, if is purely imaginary (also known as going to Euclidaen time), then there may be solutions where is real and is purely imaginary.
Example 2.2.2.
Let and
where are parameters. This is usually called the Higgs potential. Then the energy is
We can see that there is a symmetry, so near there are two copies of the same physics. After complexifying, we obtain , while the zero set of is a Riemann surface. If we compactify, we will obtain an elliptic curve with the hyperelliptic form
Note that , so there are two independent cycles corresponding to classically allowed physics. Also, it is clear that
Therefore, this family degenerates to a union of two copies of when (and one of our distinguished cycles is the vanishing cycle) and has another critical point when . Now is a holomorphic differential on , and the Hamilton equation tells us that any
must satisfies . Now in the low-energy region, can be specified by two integers:
where is the vanishing cycle and satisfies . Note is described up to multiples of , so is well-defined, but is defined only up to multiples of . We can then find by the period integral
which are functions of . Therefore, the for satisfy a transcendental equation
We can solve this equation approximately in the limit, where
where is the classical period of very small oscillations around the critical point. This is all obtained by Picard-Lefschetz theory using the fact that
where the can be computed using knowledge of elliptic integrals. The solution where corresponds to classical physics, while the solution where corresponds to tunneling between the two critical points. Therefore, the general solution is some superposition of classical motion and tunneling.
2.3 Algebraic integrable systems
We will now consider the class of systems which generalize the following feature of the previous example: our manifold has a Lagrangian fibration to some open subset of by polarized abelian varieties. These are called algebraic integrable systems. This structure gives the structure of special Kähler geometry on .
For us, a polarization is simply an integral class , where . We will now define action variables on . If we have , this path can be transported canonically over paths connecting to that avoid the discriminant locus . We now obtain a -chain in covering the path, and we can obtain a number
for a distinguished choice of . Therefore, we obtain a map
where is the space of choices , where and is a path connecting to in up to homotopy. The image of is a Lagrangian with respect to , where if is a basis of -cycles in , then . Now because
locally there exists such that
Definition 2.3.1.
This is called a prepotential.
Example 2.3.2.
One example is the elliptic Calogero-Moser system. Here, let be an elliptic curve parameterized by and consider
Then let be the coordinates in the fiber directions and be the coordinates on the copies of and define
This was proven to be an algebraic integrable system by Krichever (before algebraic integrable systems were defined). Set
where the theta function is defined by
Here, we make the usual substitution . This operator satisfies the equations
and has an expansion of the form
Therefore, the spectrum of forms an -sheeted cover over , and in , if , then
Then we will obtain a Lagrangian fibration where the fiber is the Jacobian .
2.4 How to compute some path integrals exactly
Recall our setting of a symplectic manifold with Hamiltonian . We will assume that there is an action of with moment map . We will also assume that is linear in the moment map, so
Example 2.4.1.
Consider with Darboux coordinates , the standard action of , and moment map given by
Then the Hamiltonian
generates an action which is dense for generic .
If we now assume that is compact and the fixed points of the -action are isolated, then to obtain the statistical-mechanical partition function for some inverse temperature , we have the Duistermaat-Heckman formula
where are the weights of the -action on . With these weights, near behaves like
Example 2.4.2.
If and is the cosine of the azimuthal angle, we embed , and the contour corresponding to the south pole goes into the cotangent directions.
The Duistermaat-Heckman formula can be stated in the setting of -equivariant cohomology. If is a Lie group acting on , we will consider the Cartan model of equivariant cohomology.
where we require that
The grading on differential forms is deformed to be
Then the equivariant differential is defined by
where is a linear map. We can now compute
so we set to be the cohomology of this complex. We can now compute equivariant integrals of . Note that and
for all . Also note that
We will now prove the Duistermaat-Heckman formula. If is the moment map, we claim that
This follows from the definition of the moment map. We then see that
and this is actually a Duistermaat-Heckman integral. If the -action is free (and is compact), then every closed form is exact. Because is compact, there exists a -invariant metric. Assuming that for now, choose some generic . Then define
We then obtain
where the function part is nonzero, and finally if
we obtain whenever . Now we can replace the integral in the Duistermaat-Heckmann formula with
where , and finally use Stokes’ theorem to obtain the desired result.
2.5 Infinite-dimensional generalizations and supersymmetry
Now suppose that , where is a Riemannian manifold. Then define for , we can define a -form by
where is the Levi-Cevita connection. The Hamiltonian that generates the standard -action is
Then the partition function of supersymmetric quantum mechanics on (index of the Dirac operator on ) is given by
where is the -genus. The term on the right should be viewed as the contribution of non-isolated components of the fixed locus and can be thought of as Fourier modes of infinitesimal loops. Of course, there is the question of the role of in this formula.
2.5.1 The Dirac operator
First, associated to the metric we have the Clifford algebra, which is generated by symbols for with the relation
This is the analogue of the the Heisenberg-Weyl algebra over a symplectic vector space , which is generated by elements for with the relation
The Clifford algebra has irreducible representations, which are called spinors. If we choose an orthonormal basis of , we can write any element as
In addition, we see that the Clifford algebra relation is a deformation of the exterior algebra, so as -vector spaces. The space of quadratic elements of the Clifford algebra is in fact . Because is not simply connected, representations of its Lie algebra integrate to , which is the universal cover of (at least if ). The group-like elements take the form
Now we impose a complex structure compatible with the metric and define
for . These satisfy the relation
Finally, we define the vector space
We impose that , and in general that moves to the left. We then define if is odd. It satisfies
From now on, we will assume that .
Note that is an irreducible representation of , but recall that is much smaller. It is spanned by elements of the form . There is a -valued conserved charge called which is preserved by . For , it is defined by
Therefore, we can split
by the parity of the -charge. Then for any , we have
These are called Dirac matrices.
Unfortunately, there is not always a global spinor bundle on . The obstruction is the Stiefel-Whitney class
If this is nonzero, then we cannot glue spinors into a vector bundle and thus the manifold does not have a spin structure. Therefore, we will now assume that . We will now define the Dirac operator
by the local formula
Here, is a spin cover of the Levi-Civita connection and is the physicist notation for . We also define to be the same operator applied to . The symbol of or of is given by the well-known formula
Because of the analogy with the Laplacian, the spaces and are known as harmonic spinors. There is a lucky coincidence that if , then
for any . Note here that working on ,
Now suppose that satisfies
Then satisfies
This tells us that
Note that this cancellation is our first example of supersymmetry. Finally, we take the limit.
2.5.2 The heat kernel
If we were considering on flat space the ordinary heat kernel
then is computed by
Note that in flat space, the heat kernel must satisfy the PDE
As ,
There must also be the integral formula
so in fact, it is given by
In our curved situation, we obtain the limit
which can be well-approximated by the expression in flat space. Considering instead the loop space , we now obtain
Note that the carries the term . Also, if we integrate out the , we obtain the previous term
2.5.3 Supersymmetric Duistermaat-Heckmann
We will now rewrite the integral we wanted to compute at the beginning of this section in new notation as
Here, we rewrite
where . The satisfy the formula
Finally, here is the equivariant parameter for the action of on the cotangent directions.
Now, the Duistermaat-Heckmann normalized integral (which is not the Atiyah-Singer normalized integral) is
where splits into Fourier modes as
and thus splits
and are the Chern roots of . This exactly reproduces the -genus. The Atiyah-Singer normalized integral has an extra factor of .
2.6 Duality
There are two main examples: -duality in d sigma-models and -duality in d gauge theories.
2.6.1 -form generalized gauge theory
We will begin with -form generalized gauge theory in spacetime dimensions. For some , define
This is invariant under . The space of fields in the -type theory is given by
In the -type setting, the space of fields is smaller and is given by
where is the space of all -forms alpha such that
for all integral cycles .
Example 2.6.1.
When and , then the -type theory describes maps . Locally, these look like such that . Of course, not every manifold is simply connected. Therefore, the true space of fields is
This has a decomposition by the topological type as follows. Let be a coordinate with
Then the topological type is given by
In general, we will assume that the curvature form is not exact, but instead integral, so
This can be achieved on an open cover by choosing
such that
Then the space of fields is the space of connections on all -bundles and its connected components are parameterized by
The partition function is now given by
where
is a closed form.
We may also replace by functions
We introduce tensors
In this form, the partition function becomes
where and . We also have
We now want to find the critical points of , where . The equations for become
for all . If we set , the equation becomes
which are the generalized Maxwell equations. Therefore, we obtain
where is a regularized version of
which is defined as follows. Define
This is defined for , and taking the analytic continuation, we define
We may need to assume that . For example, if , then the term knows only about the conformal structure of . Finally, is taken modulo torsion.
2.6.2 Duality
The duality is given by inverting
when and inverting
when . We may consider transformations of the form
or more generally
where
Applying Poisson resummation, we obtain
Here, we have the identity
in dimension . Note that when , , while when , . In the -dimensional setting, if we define
the relation is
Therefore,
The duality must give some reassignment of the degrees of freedom. Locally, if
which is noncompact, we must discuss the Hamiltonian system. The phase space is given by the stack
The symplectic form is given by
Here,
is the electric field and is the magnetic field. Now we can write the Hamiltonian as
We return to the space of spatial fields , which has a decomposition into connected components indexed by
The component corresponding to some is
which is the space of flat -connections.
All of this can be understood via the quantum mechanics of a particle on . If we define
then is the analogue of . Then if the standard symplectic form on is given by
quantizes to , and the spectrum of this operator is given by
For example, if , then and have the same eigenvalues, if , then the spectrum is doubly degenerate, and for any other value of the spectrum is simple. Therefore, the duality exchanges the electric and magnetic fields whenever .
3 Instantons
There are three main approaches:
- •
Morse theory;
- •
Twisted supersymmetric -models;
- •
Twisted supersymmetric gauge theory.
These have a Hamiltonian and Lagrangian approach, and the latter will motivate the study of integrals on moduli spaces of instantons.
3.1 Morse theory
Note that this is not the same as what topologists call Morse theory. Let be a compact Riemannian manifold and . Suppose all such that have nondegenerate Hessian, or in other words,
We will consider with the differential
Using the standard scalar form
we define the adjoint
Physicists refer to the study of this package as supersymmetric quantum mechanics. Here, the Hamiltonian is
Note that , and if , then
so we see that if and only if .
There are also excited states where for . Then we compute
so the states , , and are also eigenstates with eigenvalue .
There is then the following trick. If and is fixed for , then
where is a very large potential outside of the critical locus of . We also have
on the ground states, which are isomorphic to . More generally, we note that
Ignoring the term, the Hamiltonian becomes
In the world where and , we obtain states
As , we obtain and , which are distributions.
Example 3.1.1.
Now consider and . Note in this case we need to use differential forms. Then we have basic operators
Finally, we set .
The spectrum is given in the following way. If , then the equality implies that , which is fine if and bad if . Then suppose there is such that . Then we obtain
Then if is a polynomial,
as (here scales ). This tells us that are regular functions, while eigenstates of are monomials. Similarly, are distributions supported at , while the eigenstates of are those of the form . Observe that
Then, note that is an invariant distribution-valued -form. The pairing between the in and out states must be the usual pairing between functions and distributions.
In higher dimensions, there will be both attracting and repelling states, so we can consider something like
and i the end is a distribution supported on the attracting manifold. This concludes the study of the local picture.
However, we must consider the compact picture. For example, consider where the Morse function is attracting at and repelling at . Then near , the states corresponding to monomials will look like . Applying and expanding
then the scaling gives us correction terms of and to . Here, the principal value
is the finite part in the -expansion of
Therefore, we see that critical points can talk to each other via excited states.
3.2 -models
We will consider maps from a Riemann surface to a symplectic manifold. We will also choose an almost complex structure which is tame with respect to . If we consider the functional
its critical points are simply harmonic maps.
In the Hammiltonian formalism, consider . If , then
Note that
and
Then can be rewritten as
where is the -field, satisfying . Therefore, the absolute minima are solutions to the PDE
Example 3.2.1.
Consider with the standard symplectic form and complex structure. Let
Let be the loop variable and be the noncompact direction. Then we obtain the equations
which are the Cauchy-Riemann equations. If and , the Cauchy-Riemann equations give
3.3 d supersymmetric Yang-Mills
The word symmetry here is actually a confusing one. There are two types of symmetries one encounters in physics, and one is not a symmetry. Sometimes what we mean by symmetry is a redundancy; mathematically what that means is that we’re studying a quotient of some space by some symmetry , . This is a local symmetry. The other type of symmetry is a global symmetry where we really have acting on the space we are studying . In the case of a local symmetry, platonically there is a space with action of , but that space is not accessible to us. Rather we only can see . Occasionally, it’s the case that we find there exists . We call this a duality.
Because the groups we deal with in physics are typically infinite dimensional groups, for example of a manifold into a finite dimensional group, these groups typically have lots of normal subgroups. Sometimes rather than the full , our local symmetry is some sort of normal subgroup that preserves additional structure: for example, possibly the normal subgroup that sends certain marked points of into certain subgroups of . The global symmetry will then be whatever is left from , for example in this case .
For example, say we are studying a smooth Riemannian 4-manifold, with a compact simple Lie group, and a principal -bundle over . Let the affine space of -connections on . There is a group acting on ; what we really want to study is the quotient
The functional we seek to integrate over is
The measure here is induced from the metric, and refers to the killing form. Our integral consists of two parts.
- •
The first is the Yang-Mills action;
- •
The second is a *topological term* which does not depend on the metric and picks out some topological equivalence class of principal bundles. We normalise it so that the whole thing is an integral class.
Since the second term is topological, we know eventually that our integral is equivalent to
where is the integral taken over bundles of Pontryagin class . We could try to write this on a lattice, viewing as the edges of a graph and as the vertices. But if you did this naively you would find that the coupling has to go to zero. Instead, we can try a trick which we started to discuss last time. If we write
the Yang-mills term in the functional is equal to
Then we can rewrite the whole functional as
where
is some function in the upper half-space. We could try to study the limit , while keeping finite. In that limit the functional goes to
Studying the moduli space of , which we roughly expect to be finite dimensional because , we can at the very least compute its virtual dimension. To do so, assume
- •
is so that ;
- •
so that ;
- •
wherein .
To the linear level, it suffices to computer . Since
the virtual tangent bundle is
which is the first cohomology of the Atiyah-Hitchin-Singer complex
wherein the maps are . If of this complex don’t vanish, we could have singularities or obstructions and therefore trouble counting dimension.
3.3.1 “theory of differential forms on ”
We could try to overcome the infinite dimensionality of the problem by seeking to develop a theory of differential forms on , the space of anti-self dual connections, i.e. those such that . To do so, we would need some notion of local coordinates on . Let’s first try to do this on the space of connections without the ASD condition.
Define
on the space of connections . Then
This is a one-form, hence an ’odd’ object, i.e. a fermion. So meaps even to odd and vice versa.
But remember that is a redundant description, because connections related by gauge transformation are the same. To deal with this, rather than we will deal with *equivariant differential forms*, and write
on the Cartan model for equivariant cohomology, so that this differential is an operator on
Since , if we want this relation not only at the level of chomology but also on the actual space of differential forms, it’s enough to study invariant forms, hence why we’re taking invariants by . This is like passing from , which slightly improves the situation of stabilisers and therefore the space of equivariant differential forms. Then,
| (3.1) | ||||
| (3.2) | ||||
| (3.3) |
The extra factor of the Lie algebra also defines an object , so that where . Here lives in the inside our forms itself, whilst lives in the space we tensor by. Then
on the space of -invariant forms, since is just the Lie derivative associated to transformation along .
3.3.2 Finite-dimensional model
Suppose we are in a similar finite dimensional situation.
- •
Suppose acts on a Riemannian manifold ;
- •
Suppose ;
- •
If acts freely, then there is a well-defined quotient by . If is equivariantly closed,it should correspond go to .
Remark 3.3.1.
Let . If is closed so that for all , with .
Further, characteristic classes of our bundle are represented by invariant polynomials on our Lie algebra, . The functions should somehow correespond to these, ‘it looks too good to be a coincidence’. This consideration hits on the fact that we likely want to use a metric when we make this map.
Let’s do what we already did a previously. Using the metric, we can build a one-form:
It has the following useful property: if , we can multiply
This will not change the cohomology class, but it will change the representative. For example,
is given by
We can write this as
In order to not worry about contours, we treat as complex conjugates. There is a canonical measure on ,
which is just the Haar measure which we have for free. Insert this into the integral as an additional term by which we integrate out .
A procedure like this is ‘universal’ in the sense that it produces a differential form on . Because all the integrations I’ve done commute with , this kind of averaging results in a form which is still equivariantly closed. The secret of Yang-Mills theory is that it does exactly that: it takes something simple on the space of connections and does some sort of integration like that to produce a form on the space of connections.
But there’s a second piece, the anti self-dual condition, which we did not consider. If we have for some section of a vector bundle , how do we restrict differential forms to the vanishing locus of this section? Naively the idea is to just send
where is just a function or form. To do this properly we need to add on a Koszul complex into our complex of forms which effectively has as a differential.
At the level of mysterious formulae, this is achieved in the following way. Extra complexes imply we have extra fields; introduce the field which for our purposes will be the self dual form . This represents the term in the Koszul complex, so that the Koszul differential of is
Then we have a vector bundle over with fibers
Naively is , so not zero on the nose. This is fixed in the following way: we define another field, , and a further field , so that
| (3.4) | ||||
| (3.5) |
Remember also that we had fields
- •
a connection on ;
- •
;
- •
;
- •
;
- •
.
which is a minimal list of fields for Yang-Mills theory. acted on these fields by
- •
;
- •
;
- •
;
- •
;
- •
;
- •
;
- •
.
Note that for all but there is a canonical pairing between fields just by their type, called Berezin measure. This gives us a measure:
where we have only ‘cheated’ in the last term, whose definition leaves something to be said in the fully infinite dimensional setting.
Consider the functional
We got these terms from looking at our metric and applying to create the most general supersymmetric or -closed functional. This is the same as
Since is quadratic, we could integrate it out.
Also integrating out represents the Atiyah-Hitchin-Singer complex, because it imposes the conditions , equivalent to , is orthogonal to , which gives us the first cohomology of the AHS complex.
The zero modes of correspond to the second cohomology of the AHS complex, and the zero modes of correspond to the first cohomology. It’s something to keep in mind because zero modes are significant because they drop out of the exponential and so observables ‘have to provide the missing zero modes’ for the fermionic integrations to be nonzero. Also, we could determine that the functional implies that is ‘the curvature of the universal bundle evaluated at the point x’, but we would need to talk more about this later on.
3.3.3 When M is not compact
There is one important change to the whole story when is not compact; in other words, if the metric is such that there is some ‘end’ which is infinitely far away, the story has to be modified. We don’t need to integrate over all fields, rather we want to restrict to those where the curvature goes to zero at . Naively that’s because the integral would be divergent if the curvature was not zero.
Since we want to approach a constant , , such that , we only use those gauge transformations which approach unity sufficiently fast at infinity. The rate at which they go to 1 is fixed by the requirement that . The result of that is that a finite dimensional group of those gauge transformations preserved now acts as a global symmetry! Instead of integrals over the moduli space of instantons of closed differential forms, one passes to equivariant differential forms for the moduli space of framed instantons, where framed means the vanishing condition above.
4 Gauge-theoretic instanton counting
The difference between mathematicians and physicists is that mathematicians like closed -manifolds while physicists like . For mathematical precision, we will let be a compact Riemannian manifold and be a principal -bundle for some compact Lie group . These are classsified by the second Chern class
which physicists call the instanton charge. We are looking for connections whose curvature satisfies
which are called instantons. This equation in fact only depends on the conformal class of the metric.
Being anti-self-dual implies that the connection gives a minimum of the Yang-Mills action
If is a complex surface and the metric is Hermitian, then , which is equivalent to requiring that that . Therefore, any representation of gives rise to a holomorphic vector bundle on . This will come into play later when we cheat by replacing instantons with torsion-free sheaves.
The moduli space of such instantons is
where is the group of sections of the associated -bundle acting by
For generic metrics , this is a manifold of dimension
where is the dual Coxeter number. We should note that even though as a space depends only on the conformal class of the metric, the metric depends on itself. It also lives inside the space of all connections on . Our aim is to understand the infinite-dimensional integral
Here, is valued on . In the limit, the asymptotics of the integral should become
where and the measure is obtained by regularity and determinants of .
Instead of trying to understand this very complicated measure , we can try to study simpler but still interesting integrals. For examples, Donaldson invariants are defined as integrals over of cohomology classes associated to -cycles and -cycles on . The problem is that is non-compact because of the conformal invariance of the equations leading to delta-function solutions. Uhlenbeck discovered that via a complicated system of gauge transformations, these points can be filled in by ideal solutions, so there is the Uhlenbeck compactification
4.1 The case of
This is the case that physicists are worried about. The problem is of course that is non-compact, so we can view either or . There are already interesting solutions in this case, but because our metric is singular at infinity, we will consider the moduli space
where is the set of those elements satisfying as . This is a hyperkähler manifold of dimension when .
It is well-known that this (or a slight modification is a Nakajima quiver variety corresponding to the quiver data
Here, we need to modify the instanton equations to
which in algebraic geometry corresponds to changing the value of the moment map.
This moduli space has an instanton interpretation if we replace by a noncommutative , which has coordinates with commutators
In the case, we have while and .
There is also an action of , where for elements
and
the corresponding vector field is denoted by . Given a choice of
the partition function is
This is not the most general formulation, but it is a distilled version of Yang-Mills with some supersymmetry. It turns out that is actually a rational function of degree in and .
One generalization of this is
where
Here, has the asymptotics
and solves the equation
In the limit as , we expect the asymptotics
so the question now is to evaluate . In the case when , we can do it by localization.
A standard computation tells us that
where and are defined using the (relative) arms and legs of the two Young diagrams. For example, when , we end up with and .
Treating as a probability measure on the set of Young diagrams, we obtain the observables
This function knows essentially everything about the shape of the diagrams, and its vacuum expectation is
It satisfies the property that
has no poles in and is in fact a polynomial of degree . Physically, this is interpreted as an interaction between two neighboring instanton sectors.
If we send , then we then obtain the algebraic equation
where the coefficients of are defined by
This is a hyperelliptic curve.
4.2 Mathematical realization
From now on, we will set and consider the moduli space
Recall that this is a Nakajima quiver variety corresponding to the Jordan quiver. The ADHM equations are
Here, . It can in fact be rotated to by , so we can assume . Here, the action of is given by
Then has an action of given by
and these are symmetries. There is also a -action given by
In fact, if we only consider , it in fact has -symmetry.
We are interested in the fixed points of our action on . To be a fixed point of , the tuple must obey for some depending on . It is in fact enough to consider the maximal torus of , so we may assume that
Now we obtain
To make this compatible with the gauge transformations, the assignment
is a group homomorphism, giving a decomposition
where is a -linear function.
We will now use the Kempf-Ness theorem and solve and then divide by . Given a solution, we want such that solves . This is not always possible, so we need stable solutions in the sense of geometric invariant theory.
Definition 4.2.1.
The tuple is stable if and only if for all subspaces such that , , and , then . Equivalently, .
Theorem 4.2.2.
We have an isomorphism
Using this, write as the standard decomposition into eigenspaces of the standard maximal torus of . Then let . Our equations then become
Then is spanned by eigenvectors of with eigenvalues for integers . Note if satisfies , we have
We are still interested in the fate of , and in fact we will see that , which will imply that .
It is sufficient to replace by and by , so we reduce to the case of . This gives us
so taking the trace gives us . Therefore, , viewing . Next, we see that
Similarly, . This is also true for any powers of , and in fact for any polynomial of , so using the fact that is a cyclic vector for , we see that .
We now see that to each , we obtain an ideal to be the annihilator of under the assignment . Thus we can identify
By a standard argument, the action of tells us that must be a monomial ideal, and this corresponds to a partition of , or equivalently a Young diagram of size . The only thing we know is that
so some of the could be zero. We will call the -th partition and its components
We have therefore proven the following theorem:
Theorem 4.2.3.
There is a bijection
Example 4.2.4.
When , we have
and the fixed points are given by .
4.3 Explicit localization computation
In order to compute our integrals using equivariant localization, we need to compute
as a representation of the maximal torus . Its equivariant Chern character (also the character of the representation) is given by
where and . Then any
must satisfy
up to
Therefore, is the of a complex
where the two arrows are given by
Lemma 4.3.1.
We have .
Proof.
Suppose . Then
But this space is all of , so .
Now suppose there exists such that
for all . But this implies that
which is exactly , which implies . □
To compute the character, we note that
We also know that
where
This also gives us
We are now able to compute
It is also easy to see that
and
so
This is not obviously a pure character, but taking its dual gives us
Rewriting
and noting that
we can compute
We then see that
Taking only the nonpositive part, we obtain
Putting it all together, we obtain
We are now able to compute the integrals we wanted as
We now consider the tautological complex
which should be thought of as a holomorphic square root of the tangent complex. This is given by the formulae
In fact, the ADHM equation is equivalent to this being a complex for all . We see what happens when . In this case, we see that if , then
for all , so it annihilates all of , and thus . Therefore
However, in general, this complex has both and . We will compute these over . We can explicitly see that
is the space of corners. We will compute the character of the using the equation
If we note that
we see that
is the character of the ideal corresponding to . Therefore, the coefficient of is simply
and the first term yields while the second term yields .
To see how this works in practice, fix . Then is a codimension ideal in . We are looking for
and this is given by
4.4 -characters
Notation 4.4.1.
From now on, we will denote and .
The main tool for dealing with instanton integrals (equivalently, sums over ensembles of Young diagrams) is the -character. Here, we will have a discrete set , and the densities for must satisfy
For example, we can consider . It is important to note that depends on
but we can make choices such that all are positive real nnumbers, giving us a probability measure.
Definition 4.4.2.
A function is called an observable if
Before we continue, we will consider a tautological bundle over instanton moduli spaces, which we will call . In fact, it literally corresponds to the in the construction of the Nakajima variety. Then we are interested in quantities
where
We can see that
where
normalizes the sum and si the degree of .
Examples 4.4.3.
- 1.
In pure super-Yang-Mills theory, and is homogeneous in ;
- 2.
In super-QCD, we set
where denotes the homogeneized Chern polynomial. Here, the input is given by
where the are the “flavors” and takes the role of previously.1
- 3.
The theory, or adjoint super-QCD, is defined by
Theorem 4.4.4.
The Chern polynomials at the fixed points are given by
Examples 4.4.5.
For example, in super-QCD, we obtain
This series has a finite radius of convergence and is well-defined for . It also admits a non-trivial analytic continuation.
In the theory, we obtain
Remark 4.4.6.
We should view as lying on , and the points become places where the curve degenerates.
Instead of the tautological bundle, we may also consider the tautological complex
which defines some -theory class. Here, we set to live in degree . For any -theory class
we may define its total Chern class by
Definition 4.4.7.
The -observable is defined by
We may evaluate it at a general fixed point to obtain
where . We can then compute the expected value
which is a meromorphic function of with poles at
where lie in a finite set with cardinality at most at order and satisfy .
Recall the gamma function
which is defined for and has an analytic continuation which is meromorphic with first order poles at the nonpositive integers. We will need the generalization
Before this, recall that and . Similarly, if we set
this satisfies the functional equation
The Barnes -gamma function will be defined the functional equation
Definition 4.4.8.
The fundamental -character for -theory is defined by
where
Definition 4.4.9.
The -character is defined by the formula
where
Remark 4.4.10.
This is the beginning of quantum field theory, where we should think about this as an operator product corresponding to
when we make the collide.
We would also like to discuss the expected value more precisely.
Definition 4.4.11.
The expectation value of the -observable is
Using equivariant localization, we see that
To speed up our calculations, we will express as a plethystic exponential
where
In addition,
where
is the character of at . Using the plethystic exponential, we can write
where
Theorem 4.4.12.
The expected value
is an entire function of .
Sketch of proof for fundamental -character.
We need to check pole cancellation for the expression
Note that is a pole if there exists and such that
and . Therefore, we have
Considering the other term, we need to compute the residue
The poles of this expression require . All of the combinatorics works out, so it remains to check that the measures work out, or more precisely that
Using the plethystic exponential and setting , we can write
We are now able to evaluate the residue. We see that
The desired result follows from more computation, namely that
and that
In the -theory, the partition function is defined to be
where we magically have new parameters and . In this case, the measure is given by
This is invariant under swapping and , which corresponds to transposing . In this case, the fundamental -character is given by
Previously, we were integrating over generalisations of . Today we will generalise even further, and integrate over products of such:
Definition 4.4.13.
We will call spaces like the above moduli spaces of quiver instantons.
4.5 The theory for general quivers
Definition 4.5.1.
Let be a quiver, wherein is its set of vertices, its set of edges, and the source, target maps . sending an edge to where it starts or ends.
Definition 4.5.2.
Let a quiver. Let be its flavours, and its colors. Then the moduli space of quiver instantons is
Remark 4.5.3.
Each is acted on by a torus . Further, we can work equivariantly with respect to each . Define
Remark 4.5.4.
Each has a tautological bundle, . We could choose a tuple of complex numbers , one for each vertex, and a tuple of complex numbers , one for each edge, and evaluate
Definition 4.5.5.
Let denote the sheaf on
parametrising the data of two points in our moduli space corresponding to two torsion-free sheaves. Then define
wherein is the projection map forgetting the factor.
In principle, we could imagine integrating the above integral. However, not every leads to a nice story. One possible restriction would be to hope that our integrals converge. A basic condition for that would be:
that is, the dimension of our moduli space is at least the degree of the chern class of the bundle we’re integrating over. (The tautological bundle term is clear, and
gives a term like
Also note
Remark 4.5.6.
The above restriction is linear in on both sides. We could for the restriction to be true for every . That leads to the condition that
Theorem 4.5.7.
Fix . There exists satisfying the above condition if either
- 1.
is an ADE Dynkin diagram as an unoriented graph;
- 2.
is an affine ADE Dynkin diagram as an unoriented graph, , and is related to the Dynkin indices.
Example 4.5.8.
Choose the quiver with one vertex and loops. Then the inequality reads
This is satisfied if either
- 1.
, (the case);
- 2.
(the case).
In more detail, the solutions are (described here but not drawn due to the note-taker’s inadequacy)
- 1.
: a cyclic graph with nodes, all with the mark ;
- 2.
: a linear graph of nodes, with two additional nodes attached to the first and last nodes. The marks of the linear nodes are all ; the marks of the additional nodes are all .
- 3.
: an exceptional series of graphs.
- (a)
, the graph with 7 vertices, a linear graph with three nodes with two chains of length two added at the end. Dynkin marks are on the linear part and then on each chain.
- (b)
, the graph with 9 vertices, namely a linear graph of length 7 with one additional node attached to the sixth node. The marks on the linear component are and the added node has mark .
- (c)
, left as an exercise.
- (a)
Remark 4.5.9.
In physics, this inequality is related to the condition of asymptotic freedom for the gauge theory associated to the quiver. It’s hard to explain this precisely. These integrals approximate the partition function of the gauge theory, which is a path integral over the space of all connections. You could try to define the path integral rigorously by discretising. Asymptotic freedom, in that picture, is an equation relating to when the discretised path integral is a good approximation to our original path integral.
Example 4.5.10.
The standard model could be related to the quiver with and (though we are of course modeling supersymmetric versions of the theory with our integrals.)
Remark 4.5.11.
If you’ve found a solution of this inequality, you could take a limit:
This limit is a finite dimensional shadow of renormalisation group flow. Taking this limit removes one factor from our chern class; essentially it just removes one flavour. This means that, replacing , we could find a solution to the inequality for the new . So it suffices to solve for solutions where the inequality is an equality: together with the trick of ’freezing’ one of the nodes, this gives all solutions. For example, we can get by freezing a node on , sending .
Remark 4.5.12.
We have parameters
and
Example 4.5.13.
When we seek to get by freezing as above, after a little bit of computation we find that
and
Let’s reiterate the idea of how we study integrals like the above, namely the use of -characters. Since there is some ADE structure to this story, it might not be so surprising that what we called -characters have something to do with the characters of algebras related to the ADE series. Again will be related to a combinatorial sum, namely a sum over a doubly-indexed set of Young diagrams , where and .
Definition 4.5.14.
Let
Then start to define
Theorem 4.5.15.
There is a completion of this sum such that has no poles in . This has the same size as the sum defining characters of affine Kac-Moody groups.
Example 4.5.16.
Let’s study the case with marks and two framing nodes . Redefine so by rescaling. Then,
Here, the term we needed to add was , and this exactly cancels all remaining pools. So it stops after 3 terms. Why 3 terms? is related to . This looks like a character: a character of what? The large asymptotics are like
There’s something called a conformal extension of a simple Lie group . It has to do with the fact that there’s a centre. For any group with a centre, we can add a torus factor for every cyclic factor in the centre. This relates, for example, to .
Remark 4.5.17.
The “fundamental” in -characters denotes that they’re related to highest weight.
4.6 General -characters
Definition 4.6.1.
A general -character depends on
For . We could try to define a -character . It would look like
The point is that it’s not just the product of fundamental characters; there are corrections. You’re trying to encode all orders of expansion of this function.
Once we define a general qq-character, we’ll then be able to set the stage for the limit shape story, that is, Seiberg-Witten geometry.
Remark 4.6.2.
Remember that a quiver is an oriented connected finite graph, possibly with more than one arrow between nodes. Then quiver gauge theory depends on the data of , vector spaces for each .
Recall there is an ADE classification given by imposing the condition that
The are discrete parameters of our theory, but there are also continuous parameters , and . Further there are , complex numbers of small absolute value.
Finally there are parameters , for , and there are two parameters
Definition 4.6.3.
We may then define a partition function
wherein is the color parameter, and runs from to , and
Remark 4.6.4.
There is some redundancy in this description. For , , we may shift
Remark 4.6.5.
There are physics expectations that as , or even just , the asymptotics might be computable.
To study all of this, we’ll need another auxiliary object.
Definition 4.6.6.
A Nakajima quiver variety depends on the data of a quiver and data defined by tuples of integers , . We want at least one and the remaining to be positive. To this data, we assign complex vector spaces . Then the Nakajima quiver variety is defined as
where denotes the symplectic quotient. We may estimate its dimension to be .
Remark 4.6.7.
These spaces carry obvious tautological bundles
and hence a tautological complex :
wherein all the maps are the obvious ones given by the quiver representation. The complex moment map condition is precisely the condition that this is a complex.
Remark 4.6.8.
has a -global symmetry. There is another symmetry factor, namely by permuting edges, and finally a which acts by scaling the moment map. There is some redundancy in this description.
Definition 4.6.9.
Let the observable defined by
We will now give a general formula for qq-characters. Let’s fix vectors
which we think of as equivariant parameters for , and an equivariant parameter for , and define
where everything is taken equivariantly with respect to all symmetries listed above and
Definition 4.6.10.
is a fundamental -character.
Proposition 4.6.11.
has no poles in .
Example 4.6.12.
Let’s recover the -case we studied earlier. Here, . The symmetry group is . The maximal torus acts with isolated fixed points, labeled by the -dimensional planes spanned by the coordinate axes in the basis chosen by our choice of maximal torus. In other words, fixed points are labelled by partitions of into two disjoint sets, so that .
In terms of the Nakajima data, let , and impose the stability condition that is of maximal rank. Hence it’s the space of operators
So the tangent space is
At the fixed point , we can identify the tangent space as
Therefore,
where the first summand comes from , and the second from .
So the qq-character takes the form
Of course the canonical complex takes the form
Since and is injective, up to equivariant weight, , and , .
Hence the final factor gives an overall answer of
This is the qq character for -quiver theory, namely SQCD. It has terms. This formula is already indicative that not all such formulas come as rational expressions in the whose arguments are just shifted. If we were to set for example , we would have a smaller torus. The fixed point locus would not be isolated but it would still be compact. So this integral is finite. So even though there’s terms like , we should expect the limit as these two things approach to exist, but we might get some derivatives of appearing.
4.7 Limit shapes
We’ve defined many partition functions
dependent on many parameters. The parameters were special, recording the weights of symmetry for . These partition functions were essentially sums over infinite sets whose elements are finite subsets of . So these subsets had the form
Each such set carries a certain complex weight. There is a way to specify all the parameters of the problem such that this weight is real and positive. In that case we could talk about the induced probability distribution. Then we could be interested in the limiting behaviour as . In this probablistic case that would require us to find the limiting measure. We can draw a curve which describes the boundary of these finite sets, and seek its limiting shape as .
Physically, effectively confine instantons into a polydisc of volume . Then taking the limit is a thermoydynamic limit. We view , and our goal is to extract the function . The typical size of a partition will be
Remark 4.7.1.
A probabilistic interpretation of exists at all because the moduli space of instantons, , is a complex symplectic manifold. So each tangent space is a symplectic vector space, and so the weights of the symmetry group therefore split in pairs. So if appears in , so does . That defines a symplectic form on , which roughly descends from that on the space of all connections:
If we specialize , then
Each is a linear function of the terms. Choosing , then . The numerator is trickier, but can also be made positive real by judicious specialisation of our parameters.
If we stay away from the locus wherein
which is the locus wherein some of the weights could become 0 in the denominator, we won’t have any convergence issues.
Remark 4.7.2.
Remember our
has with compact support near , and we remember that
Then
All these -functions have signs. We should think that the density between these will concentrate, so we might thank that in the limit we might get a continuous function which equals zero almost everywhere except at a finite number of intervals where the signs concentrate. The question is: can we express in terms of this limiting function?
We have
wherein
The advantage of writing it this way is that it’s a quadratic functional, so extremising it is straightforward.
Now let’s extremise subject to the constraints that , . Doing so, we will get linear equations on the . The most concise way to write those linear equations is via
wherein .
After analytic continuation, the only thing we’ll be able to control about the are their moments
Studying analytic continuation is related to the action of the Weyl group. So to solve these equations, it suffices to find the invariants of the Weyl group action. So the strategy now is to find Weyl invariant functions of the .
4.7.1 Review of Lie theory and Weyl groups
Let’s review some Lie theory so that in the above formula for . You will recognise something of classical mechanics.
Let wherein is our maximal torus. The weights form the dual lattice (they are subsets of the dual to the Cartan). It’s formed by all elements so that for every coroot. We let
for .
Remark 4.7.3.
In the lattice of coroots, there is a basis of simple coroots such that the adjoint action decomposes , wherein is a root (it’s a lattice of weights, namely the weights of the adjoint representation). This has a basis of roots, . Finally there is a lattice of coweights,
wherein is the centre of . Also, .
Definition 4.7.4.
For , define simple reflection by . It is an interesting theorem that is the action generated by the . This can of course also be defined in a multiplicative form. For , an element of the maximal torus, we may parametrise . Applying to such an element, the coordinates of this torus will transform in the following way:
wherein is the Cartan matrix. My point is that if you look closely at this formula, you will see that analytic continuation of the across the cuts is essentially the action of the Weyl group by simple reflections.
Remark 4.7.5.
The more precise statement is the following. Let , the group associated to the quiver somewhat extended. Specifically denotes the conformal extension of our group, which is given by
Essentially, it’s where we replace all cyclic factors in the centre by factors. Write , where denotes that we need to take the universal cover. The claim is that under analytic continuation
Remark 4.7.6.
I don’t know how well this is known in the case of matrix models, but at lesat for some matrix models, there is a very similar property where this is some combination of resolvents of densities of matrices which, continuing across the cuts, they transform in the vector representation of the Weyl group. Therefore what I’m about to say here also applies there.
Claim 4.7.7.
In any linear representation , is an analytic function of . With proper normalisation, it is just a polynomial in .
Claim 4.7.8.
Choose a fundamental representation of . The equations define curves in . The tori give coordinates ; the last coordinate is . There is a Weyl group which acts on this vector space, under which the curve is Weyl invariant. This curve is called a Cameral curve. Of course you have heard about spectral curves, which are curves you can assign to a matrix; its eigenvalues form a curve. That’s what you would do in the case of . But in general these guys are subject to more intricate Weyl symmetries, so it’s not really clear what sort of spectral object to consider. What one can do, for any , one can try to form a smaller curve by taking the quotient.
Example 4.7.9.
Let’s take the quiver, and take the case wherein we have fundamental matter fields at the first and last node and all labels are . Then . Then invariants are given by
the claim is this is a monic polynomial in of degree .
This is an example of a Cameral curve. It maps with degree since any permutation gives another solution of our equations. Now acts on this curve, and inside we for example have a subgroup . Now is the spectral curve. It keeps track of one eigenvalue. However, for example, we could also consider to remember two eigenvalues. This special branched structure of course has to do with Gelfand-Tsetlin patterns and is special to -type.
Spaces of curves like this describe either monopoles in for ADE type or instantons on for affine ADE type. This curve in question is actually a quasimap of degree (in affine type at least) from into the moduli spaces of -bundles on an elliptic curve.
4.8 Use of -characters
The main idea is to use the analyticity of , together with the fact that for large the observables behave like polynomials, to conclude is a polynomial in . Therefore, the moments
are zero for . This will give us a set of equations on the partition function.
Remark 4.8.1.
One can amputate legs with . Recall that we have a harmonicity condition; if there exists for which , then it imposes the stringent requirement that . That is, it cannot be connected to ‘too many’ other nodes. There were limited possibilities:
- 1.
theory: one node and one loop.
- 2.
Two more complicated graphs separated by a node with marking .
Since , there is only one partition at this node. Hence,
Now, as , to , we find
The good thing about the size of the partition is that its expectation value
is simply the logarithmic derivative with respect to fugacity of the partition function.
Example 4.8.2.
Consider -theory wherein the framing node has rank 2 and the other node has rank 1. Then
We have another formula
wherein is arm length, is leg length, is content. For this theory, we have a unique qq-character, so
since it has no poles.
Now use the computation in the above remark to expand . Specifically, let’s try to interact the coefficient of . From the first term, this is going to be
From this, we derive a differential equoation for :
gotten from
Define
formally. However, we can do better. Take the Gaussian
The main point is that you can use tricks like this to get rid of all degree 1 nodes.
Example 4.8.3.
Consider the example of -theory. Write the shape symmetrically, so that there’s one central node with , three rank one gauge nodes and a framing node also of rank 1 attached. Also give the framing node mass and give gauge node the fugacity , where is the label of the central node. Then this can be amputated in the sense that
where
(think of ).
Remark 4.8.4.
This is related to the phenomenon known as bubbling. In an ideal world we would be integrating over actual moduli spaces of instantons, but here we have compactified these moduli spaces by relaxing the condition that they correspond to actual vector bundles. The price we pay is that the rank 1 story is already nontrivial, even though Maxwell theory doesn’t admit instantons on manifolds without holes.
Nonetheless, say that you performed a blowup, luing in a small . Then this manifold has nontrivial , i.e. it has holes. Then these solve Maxwe’ll’s equations, but from differential geometeric point of view you have a family of metrics that diverges as the exceptional divisor goes to 0. Unfortunately it’s not defined at a point unless you blow up this point.
Remark 4.8.5.
This is somehow related to mirror maps.
Example 4.8.6.
Finally, let’s consider the example of theory. It’s related to earlier work of Nekrasov-Okounkov. In full generality,
Of course,
Setting and , the sum becomes something like
which vanishes if . We will prove some formula like
The fundamental qq-character of this theory is
This is a complicated formula, but we don’t want to study the full story; we just want to extract its coefficient. The result is that
This is already a differential equation for .
But the partitions describe certain ideals in , i.e. they parametrise -dimensional subschemes in a plane with coordinates . However, somehow in this story a second plane emerged with equivariant parameters whose points were also related to . This relation says there is some sort of correspondence between instantons on either plane. This is a transverse intersection of two planes in 4d, and there is no flat deformation of this cross into a smooth surface. So there is something useful coming out of this. This whole structure is called crossed instantons.
We don’t know what crossed instantons are, even though we do know what their moduli space is. Potentially, could be singular when is a positive rational number or 0 or . However no poles appear in . Moreover, if , then this whole thing collapses because if the partition is nontrivial you have boxes for which the armlength is zero. So we may write
where is regular. We can more naturally write this as an equation of logarithms as
which means that if we define
and note that
the denominator is symmetric under exchanging . Further in the small expansion we have no singularities. Further, the differential equation we wrote above implies we can exchange the to obtain
This is a meromorphic function on with no singularities, therefore it is constant in the . It suffices to evaluate it at any point. We find that it’s , where is the Euler function. Many years ago, Nekrasov-Okounkov proved it by representing this formula as a trace. That proof was much more complicated than this qq-character method.
Example 4.8.7.
Consider the case of an quiver with all gauge nodes rank and framing nodes of rank 1 at either end. Add Coulomb parameters and sometimes write for more symmetric notation. Then,
There are fundamental -characters in this case. The result is that
where , .
Here, we pass to parameters so that . What this formula should make us think about is that a chiral block of a partition function of a Gaussian free field living on a sphere with vertex operators inserted at points . This would, for example, be a relevant computation in string theory with strings coming from infinity somehow. The pieces that go off to infinity would be represented by a vertex operator.
Remark 4.8.8.
Studying a Gaussian free field
the Green’s function of the Laplacian, for a plane, is
There’s a small issue since this quantity isn’t dimensionless, which is related to the fact that the constant/zero mode does not enter into the action and so we must make a choice. In principle, we should add
Then we’d like to define vertex operators
which give us
where is the Green’s function. The analytic piece will look very much like our expression for except has two types of momenta, unless .
One can slightly modify the Gaussian free field action to include a term
depending on the scalar curvature. Having this scalar term with some coefficient modifies our computations, and can be fine-tuned to exactly reproduce our formula for .
Remark 4.8.9.
Let us list the topics which we have not covered yet:
- 1.
Spiked (and the special cases of crossed and folded) instanton moduli spaces. Their study goes under the name of gauge origami. It’s a kind of model-building device which builds statistical models of random partitions which can also be interpreted as tools to produce natural observables, e.g. -characters, defects, etc.
- 2.
Compactness theorem (hence, regularity of expectation values of observables).
- 3.
cases where one can write closed (system) of PDEs on the partition function , or on some expectation values .
It turns out these equations, which often are derived more-or-less combinatorially, are actually the same as the BPZ equations (Belavin-Polyakov-Zamolodchikov) in 2d CFT, or the KZ equations (Knizhnik-Zamolodchikov). This is one of the best incarnations of the somewhat mysterious, but nowadays better understood, correspondence known as the BPS/CFT correspondence.
Since the world of CFT includes representation of things like Kac-Moody algebras, and the BPS world includes things like Donaldson invariants, this is a very powerful relation.
4.9 Gauge origami
Previously, we explained that the basic example of the -character is an observable in the statistical mechanical model wherein we sum over -tuples of partitions
which represent a subset of of the form .
We discovered that a -character , which is an observable for this model, is described by a formula like
wherein the sum labelled a subset of of the form
However, if we tried to trace the algebrogeometric origin of these two subsets, it was different: the first subset came by doing gauge theory on the plane described by whilst the second subset was in fact derived from a partition function on a transversal plane .
The only connection between these two planes is that . So there’s a 3d torus acting on a 4d space relating them. We now aim to present a more unified story where we show that the qq-character is the result of projecting a moduli space involving both planes onto one of the planes. Let us proceed to define that. Unfortunately, the story is local, although there are many indications it can be globalised.
4.9.1 Local story
Think about the union of wherein , labels the 6 coordinate hyperplanes, and are the possible integer multiplicities of the hyperplanes.
We view
and act on it with a 3d torus. We seek to understand the in terms of certain sheaves. As before, fix . Pictorially we can draw a tetrahedron with vertices , so that the edges label pairs of vertices, hence 2d planes. So attach to an edge the number . Within the tetrahedron draw an interior ball labelled by with arrows from and to edges to the ball. We also label endomorphisms of , .
This is some homogenised version of the ADHM construction, however in the ADHM construction we only have one multiplit=cty so in that setting one doesn’t see the point of all the operators we have introduced above. To start, let’s define an operator for with :
Then the equations look like
These equations are valued in , but we may also represent that as taking values in six copies of by endowing with Hermition structure. The here is actually an irreducible representation of .
Furthermore we will impose a unifying equation:
Why is seven important? It’s . There are hermition operators acting on . Modding out by the action of by
we seek to introduce as many equations as variables.
The intuition is the following: if we draw a ’spiked’ picture where we connect the planes by another plane which bounds them, the somehow ’injects’ this plane. Since the are roughly operators of multiplicationby the . You can ask: why are we writing the in a sort of strange way, ? There is a vaninishing theorem which says
Theorem 4.9.1 (Vanishing theorem).
The all vanish individually, the if , and .
The way this is proven is by squaring the equations. To do everything algebraically, we would have to introduce derived geometry at this point. But the differential geometry is a little easier.
Remark 4.9.2.
This story is a precursor to generalising Donaldson-Thomas theory to CY4s. It has to do with how we really want to integrate the Pfaffian, and we somehow do this by imposing half the equations.
Ultimately, we find that
This is to be conmpared with the ordinary ADHM construction
Remark 4.9.3.
The subspaces can overlap. For example, , and , so if , the overlap (call it ) must satisfy , etc.
In a box picture, the corner boxes correspond to . So elements in must come from corner boxes. The situation relevant for crossed instantons is when , and rest . To take a shortcut, just look at the fixed points of the torus action
which is associated to the box . The vectors which conceivably could belong to here are those annihilated by , again the corner boxes.
On the other hand, look at the corner boxes of . Generically these don’t intersect, but nongenerically, these cornes can become 1 or become linearly dependent. They will form a ’butterfly configuration’ where some corner boxes overlap. This will happen when we choose the equivariant torus to be a smaller subtorus, and hence have some relation between the equivariant parameters. That is, we have some equation like
which is, notably, one of the conditions for a qq-character to have a pole.
Example 4.9.4.
Set . Then the ; since they are just numbers, they drop out of our equations. Therefore we just have equations
where . Further there are lots of equations like . There is also a stability condition stating that there exist so that .
Let’s start by assuming that at least one of . On this branch, by our assumption that one of the doesn’t vanish. Hence the stability condition implies . Working this out, we get a copy of . So one branch of the moduli space is . The other branch of the moduli space comes when one of . On this branch,
Further, there is another branch wherein all the are zero, and we get a copy of which parametrises relations between the .
Remark 4.9.5.
In general, let denote the moduli space of spiked instantons which depends on .
There is then a function
wherein .
We can also map
Then,
Further,
Then what is the variable ? It has to do with the framing symmetry. We have groups which act only on the . The diagonal subgroups act trivially except acts nontrivially. Here in equivariant parameter.
Remark 4.9.6.
Consider which acts by multiplying the . Let
Consider the orbifold classification by . We get answers of type ADE. An interesting case is . To be specific, we need to embed into by specifying all the decompositions
and similarly for , where , for example. Now is connected, but its fixed point locus might not be. It splits,
which gives us more parameters for our basic counting problem. That is, the generating function will now depend on many additional fugacities in addition to our other parameters:
One can reverse the roles of . Then, the same calculation will be computing some integrals over the moduli space of instantons related to the work of Kronheimer-Nakajima.