Blowup formula in GW theory
Enumerative invariants and birational geometry
Spring 2024
Notes by Patrick Lei
Lectures by Various
Columbia University
Disclaimer
These notes were taken during the lectures using neovim. Any errors are mine and not the speakers’. In addition, my notes are picture-free (but will include commutative diagrams) and are a mix of my mathematical style and that of the lecturers. Also, notation may differe between lecturers. If you find any errors, please contact me at plei@math.columbia.edu.
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Shaoyun Bai for co-organizing the seminar with me. I would also like to thank Song Yu for bringing the works [PSW24; LSW24] about wall-crossing for Grassmannian flops to our attention.
Seminar Website: https://math.columbia.edu/~plei/s24-birat.html
References used
We used the following references in the seminar:
- 1.
The main references for Section 1.1 are [Giv04; Dub96; Coa03].
- 2.
The reference for Section 1.2 is [CG07].
- 3.
The reference for Section 1.3 is [Iri17].
- 4.
The main references for Section 1.4 are [CIJ18; AGV08; Tse10]
- 5.
The reference for Section 1.5 is [CIJ18, Section 3].
- 6.
The reference for Section 2.1 and Section 2.2 is [CIJ18].
- 7.
The reference for Section 2.3 is [PSW24]. Also see the very similar [LSW24].
- 8.
- 9.
1 Preliminaries
1.1 Givental formalism (Patrick, Feb 01)
1.1.1 Introduction
Let be a smooth projective variety. Then for any , there exists a moduli space (Givental’s notation is ) of stable maps from genus-, -marked prestable curves to with . It is well-known that has a virtual fundamental class
In addition, there is a universal curve and sections
In this setup, there are tautological classes
This allows us to define individual Gromov-Witten invariants by
These invariants satisfy various relations. The first is the string equation:
The next is the dilaton equation:
Finally, we have the divisor equation when one insertion is a divisor :
It is often useful to package Gromov-Witten invariants into various generating series.
Definition 1.1.1.
The quantum cohomology of is defined by the formula
for any . This is a commutative and associative product.
The small quantum cohomology is obtained by setting and the ordinary cohomology is obtained by further setting .
Remark 1.1.2.
Convergence of the formula does not hold in general, so quantum cohomology needs to be treated as a formal object.
Definition 1.1.3.
Let be a basis of and be the dual basis. Then the -function of is the cohomology-valued function
Definition 1.1.4.
The genus- GW potential of is the (formal) function
The associativity of the quantum product is equivalent to the PDE
for any , which are known as the WDVV equations. Here, we choose coordinates on and set (only consider primary insertions). In addition, set to be the components of the Poincaré pairing and let be the inverse matrix.
1.1.2 Frobenius manifolds
A Frobenius manifold can be thought of as a formalization of the WDVV equations.
Definition 1.1.5.
A Frobenius manifold is a complex manifold with a flat symmetric bilinear form (meaning that the Levi-Civita connection has zero curvature) on and a holomorphic system of (commutative, associative) products on satisfying:
- 1.
The unit vector field is flat: ;
- 2.
For any and , ;
- 3.
If , then the tensor is symmetric in .
If there exists a vector field such that and complex number such that:
- 1.
;
- 2.
for all vector fields ;
- 3.
for all vector fields ,
then is called an Euler vector field and the Frobenius manifold is called conformal.
Example 1.1.6.
Let be a smooth projective variety. Then we can give the structure of a Frobenius algebra with the Poincaré pairing and the quantum product. Note that the quantum product does not converge in general, so we must treat this as a formal object. The Euler vector field is given by
where a general element of is given by . We will also impose that . There is another very important structure, the quantum connection, which is given by the formula
Here, is the grading operator, defined for pure degree classes by
Finally, in the direction of the Novikov variables, we have
Remark 1.1.7.
For a general conformal Frobenius manifold , there is still a deformed flat connection or Dubrovin connection given by
Definition 1.1.8.
The quantum -module of is the module with the quantum connection defined above.
Remark 1.1.9.
It is important to note that the quantum connection has a fundamental solution matrix given by
It satisfies the important equation
Using this formalism, the -function is given by .
1.1.3 Givental formalism
The Givental formalism is a geometric way to package enumerative (CohFT) invariants cleanly. We begin by defining the symplectic space
with the symplectic form
This has a polarization by Lagrangian subspaces
giving as symplectic vector spaces. Choose Darboux coordinates on . For example, there is a choice in Coates’s thesis which gives a general element of as
Taking the dilaton shift
we can now think of has a formal function on near . This convention is called the dilaton shift.
Before we continue, we need to recast the string and dilaton equations in terms of . Write . Then the string equation becomes
and the dilaton equation becomes
There are also an infinite series of topological recursion relations
We can make sense of these three relations for any (formal) function on .
Now let
be the graph of . This is a formal germ at of a Lagrangian section of the cotangent bundle and is therefore a formal germ of a Lagrangian submanifold in .
Theorem 1.1.10.
The function satisfies the string equation, dilaton equation, and topological recursion relations if and only if is a Lagrangian cone with vertex at the origin such that its tangent spaces are tangent to exactly along .
Because of this theorem, is known as the Lagrangian cone. It can be recovered from the -function by the following procedure. First consider . Via the projection to along , this can be considered as the graph of the -function. Next, we consider the derivatives , which form a basis of , which is a complement to in . Then we know that
so
Writing these in terms of the first derivatives and using the fact that is a solution of the quantum connection, so we recover the Frobenius structure of quantum cohomology.
We will now express some classical results in this formalism. Let be a toric variety with toric divisors such that form a basis of and Picard rank . Then define the -function
Theorem 1.1.11 ([Giv98]).
The formal functions and coincide up to some change of variables, which if is semi-positive is given by components of the -function.
Theorem 1.1.12 (Mirror theorem in this formalism).
For any , we have
Another direction in Gromov-Witten theory is the Virasoro constraints. In the original formulation, these involved very complicated explicit differential operators, but in the Givental formalism, there is a very compact formulation.
Define and
Then define
Theorem 1.1.13 (Genus- Virasoro constraints).
Suppose the vector field on defined by is tangent to . Then the same is true for the vector fields defined by for any .
Proof.
Let be a tangent space to . Then if , the assumption gives us . But then , so . Continuing, we obtain for all . □
Later, we will learn that the Quantum Riemann-Roch theorem can be stated in this formalism. Let be the twisted Lagrangian cone (where the twisted theory will be defined next week).
Theorem 1.1.14 (Quantum Riemann-Roch).
For some explicit linear symplectic transformaiton , we have .
1.1.4 Quantization
In the last part of the talk, we will briefly discuss the quantization formalism, which encodes the higher-genus theory. In Darboux coordinates , we will quantize symplectic transformations by the standard rules
This determines a differential operator acting on functions on .
We also need the genus- potential
and the total descendent potential
In this formalism, the Virasoro conjecture can be expressed as follows. Let , where is a carefully chosen constant.
Conjecture 1.1.15 (Virasoro conjecture).
If , then for all .
In this formalism, the higher-genus version of the Quantum Riemann-Roch theorem takes the very simple form
Theorem 1.1.16 (Quantum Riemann-Roch).
Let be the twisted descendent potential. Then
1.2 Quantum Riemann-Roch (Shaoyun, Feb 08)
We will state and prove the Quantum Riemann-Roch theorem in genus , following Coates-Givental.
1.2.1 Twisted Gromov-Witten invariants
Again, let be a smooth projective variety. Let be a vector bundle on . We should note that
is the universal curve, and the universal morphism is simply . We will consider the sheaf
We need to check that this is a well-defined -theory class. Choose an ample line bundle . By definition, for , the cohomology
whenever . This gives us an exact sequence
For any stable map of positive degree, we obtain a long exact sequence
so we obtain
This expresses as a difference of vector bundles.
We will now introduce a universal characteristic class
where are formal variables and is the -th Chern character
where are the Chern roots.
Example 1.2.1.
Let be a vector bundle and equip it with the fiberwise -action by scaling. Let be the equivariant parameter and be the Chern roots. Then
We then rewrite
so for the (equivariant Euler class), we obtain
We are now ready to define the -twisted Gromov-Witten invariants.
Definition 1.2.2.
Define the twisted Gromov-Witten invariants by
for and .
We will now construct the Lagrangian cone for the twisted theory. Let be the coefficient ring containing and define
We also introduce the twisted Poincaré pairing
The symplectic structure is defined by
There is a polarization
with
Finally, we have the twisted genus- descendent potential
Identifying with , we obtain the twisted Lagrangian cone as the graph of . Denote the untwisted Lagrangian cone as .
Theorem 1.2.3.
We have
where
Here, the Bernoulli numbers are defined by
1.2.2 Proof of Theorem 1.2.3
The idea is to use the Grothendieck-Riemann-Roch theorem.
Proposition 1.2.4.
We can write
where
Here, is formed by the nodes of , is a double cover of formed by a choice of branch of the nodes, and are the -classes at the two branches of the nodes, and
is the “inclusion.”
Proof.
We will first assume that , , and are all smooth and that is a normal crossings divisor. In general, we need a Cartesian diagram
Continuing in the ideal situation, we apply Grothendieck-Riemann-Roch1 to obtain
where is the dual Todd class, defined by , and is the sheaf of relative differentials.
We then have two short exact sequences
and
where is the divisor where the marked points collide and their component has exactly three special points. Now we obtain
in -theory. Using the facts that , for , and , we see that is trivial when restricted to and . Now we apply the dual Todd class.
Lemma 1.2.5.
If , then
Using the lemma, we obtain
The first term in the statement comes from the dual Todd class of , the second comes from
and the relation between and , and the last term can be found in Appendix A of Coates-Givental. □
To obtain the Quantum Riemann-Roch theorem, we use the previous proposition and manipulate the generating function. If is convex and is a complete intersection defined by , then is closely related to , so we are able to study the Gromov-Witten theory of using this.
1.3 Shift operators (Melissa, Feb 15)
Let be a semiprojective smooth variety. This means that is projective over its affinization. Also assume that has an action by such that all -weights in are contained in a strictly convex cone in and . All such imply that
- (a)
The fixed locus is projective;
- (b)
The -variety is equivariantly formal. This means that is a free module over and there is a non-canonical isomorphism
as -modules.
- (c)
The evaluation maps are proper.
Using (b), we may choose a basis of over . Let be the dual coordinates.
1.3.1 Equivariant big quantum cohomology
Let be the -equivariant Poincaré pairing, which in general takes values in . Then the -equivariant big quantum product is defined by
This can also be defined using the evaluation maps
as
1.3.2 Quantum connection
We will define
by setting
We can view as the loop variable by setting . If the extra copy of acts trivially on , then
This has a fundamental solution
where
This satisfies the differential equation
which is equivalent to
The solution has the form
1.3.3 Shift operators
Let be a cocharacter of . Then define a -action on by
for . Under the group automorphism
the identity map is -equivariant, so we obtain isomorphisms
Now define the bundle
where acts by
This is an -bundle over with an action on by
Setting and , we see that acts on by and by .
Definition 1.3.1.
A cocharacter is seminegative if all weights of are nonpositive with respect to and is negative if all nonzero weights of are negative.
Lemma 1.3.2.
If is seminegative, then is semiprojective.
Now let be the projection. We now consider section classes, which are those effective classes in satisfying . For the -action on given by , there is a unique fixed component whose normal weights are all positive (one way to see this is to consider the moment map of the corresponding circle action). Therefore, there is a minimal section class corresponding to .
Lemma 1.3.3.
Given , there exists such that and .
Lemma 1.3.4.
If is seminegative, then
Definition 1.3.5.
Let be seminegative. Given , we define the shift operator
by the formula
where and . We also define
Theorem 1.3.6.
We have the formula
where is defined via the commutative diagram
Here, we define
where
is the normal bundle of in and are its Chern roots.
The idea of the proof is to decompose
Using the exact sequence
we obtain the explicit formulae
This gives the virtual normal bundle, and using virtual localization, we obtain
where
Using the unitarity property of , we obtain the desired result.
1.4 Orbifold stuff (Patrick, Apr 04)
1.4.1 Orbifold Gromov-Witten theory
Let be a smooth and separated Deligne-Mumford stack of finite type over .
Definition 1.4.1.
The inertia stack of is the fiber product in the diagram
More concretely, we may think about as parameterizing pairs , where and . There is another description of if lives over . In general, is disconnected. We will write
It also has an important morphism given by .
Definition 1.4.2.
A morphism of algebraic stacks is representable if for all schemes and morphisms , the fiber product is an algebraic space.
Theorem 1.4.3.
Let
denote the stack of representable morphisms from classifying stacks of roots of unity to (the cyclotomic inertia stack). Then .
We need to make one more definition, which will appear as a degree shift on cohomology. Let . Because is cyclic, there is a decomposition
where is the eigenspace with eigenvalue and is the order of . Then the function
is constant on , so we denote its value by .
Recall that by the Keel-Mori theorem, (which has finite inertia) has a coarse moduli space , which is an algebraic space satisfying two properties:
- •
The morphism is bijective on -points whenever is an algebraically closed field;
- •
is initial for morphisms from to any algebraic space.
From now on, we will assume that is quasiprojective, and in particular that it is a scheme.
Moduli of stable maps
Definition 1.4.4.
The moduli space of stable maps parameterizes objects
where
- 1.
is a prestable balanced twisted curve of genus . This means that has stacky structure only at nodes and marked points, and the nodes are formally locally , where acts by ;
- 2.
is an étale cyclotomic gerbe over with a trivialization for all ;
- 3.
is representable and the induced morphism between coarse moduli spaces is a stable map of degree with marked points.
We see that has evaluation maps . It is also disconnected, with the connected components being indexed by components of . Let
Then
Each component has a virtual fundamental class
of virtual dimension
given by the relative perfect obstruction theory , where is the universal curve, over the moduli stack of prestable twisted curves. Because we chose to work with trivialized gerbe markings, we need to multiply the virtual fundamental class as follows. Note that the -th marked point is
Here, if , then . Then set
Now consider the morphism given by taking the coarse moduli space. Let be the universal curve and be the marked points. Then the descendant classes2 are defined to be
Quantum cohomology
We are now able to define Gromov-Witten invariants. Let . Then define
We are still able to form generating series as before, and the invariants satisfy the string, dilaton, and divisor equations (although we have to be careful that the marked point we delete is a scheme point), so the orbifold Gromov-Witten theory has a Lagrangian cone .
The orbifold Poincaré pairing is defined by the formula
where denotes the usual cup product. This is well-defined because of the formula
when is proper. When is not proper, we will assume we are working equivariantly. Now we may define the quantum product by the formula
for . Restricting to the degree part and setting , we obtain the orbifold cup product, which is given by
Denote . The orbifold cup product is graded for the grading for . Using the quantum product, we may define the quantum connection and its fundamental solution.
1.4.2 Toric Deligne-Mumford stacks
We will assume the reader is familiar with the fan presentation of a toric variety. If you are not, there are many references.
Definition 1.4.5.
An extended stacky fan is a quadruple of
- 1.
A finitely generated abelian group of rank ;
- 2.
A rational simplicial fan in ;
- 3.
A homomorphism . We will write for the image of the standard basis vector and for its image in ;
- 4.
A subset
satisfying the following conditions:
- 1.
The set of -dimensional cones is exactly the set ;
- 2.
For all , .
We will now assume that is convex and full-dimensional and, that there is a strictly convex piecewise linear function which is linear on each cone, and that is surjective. From this data, we will now obtain a GIT presentation. Define by the exact sequence
Then define . Then define to be the image of the -th standard basis vector in under the last arrow in the exact sequence
Finally, set
Choose a stability condition
Then we define
The ample cone is , which is defined in the same way as after deleting from the extended stacky fan, and the cone of effective curve classes is its dual.
Orbifold cohomology
First, we will describe the equivariant cohomology of . Let . Then if is Poincaré dual to , we have
where
There is a combinatorial description of the components of the inertia stack . Because is a global quotient, the components of the inertia stack correspond to elements such that is nonempty. Equivalently, if we define
then the components of are in bijection with . To give a description in terms of the fan, for any , define
and then
Then there is a natural bijection . For any , is a toric DM stack with the same as for and characters for such that . At the level of fans, this corresponds to killing the minimal cone of containing the corresponding .
We will now give the orbifold cohomology of . Define the deformed group ring as the vector space with product given by
Then there is an isomorphism of rings [BCS05]
Remark 1.4.6.
This result also works in families over a base [Jia08], where is replaced by a direct sum of line bundles on . Then we need to add a to the relations and obtain
1.5 Gamma-integral structure (Patrick, Apr 04)
Let and be the restriction of . Let be a -equivariant vector bundle on . Recall that corresponds to some , so we obtain an eigenbundle decomposition
where is the subbundle where acts by . We now define the orbifold Chern character to be
Now let be the Chern roots of . We define the orbifold Todd class to be
The -class should be a square root of this and is defined by
where we expand around . The reflection formula for the -function implies that the -component of is given by
Here, is the grading operator given by the degree without age shifting.
Definition 1.5.1.
Define the -group framing by the formula
where is the fundamental solution to the quantum connection, is the usual grading operator given by on homogeneous elements, and .
Proposition 1.5.2.
Define the equivariant Euler pairing by
and the modified version by replacing the equivariant parameters by . Then
Remark 1.5.3.
Everything we have discussed so far makes sense for toric DM stacks after specializing .
2 Crepant transformation conjecture
2.1 Toric wall-crossings in GW theory (Davis, Apr 11)
Our goal is to study GIT wall-crossing in toric Gromov-Witten theory. For toric varieties related across a wall, we want to define such that , as well as quantum connections on that restrict to appropriately.
2.1.1 GIT wall-crossing
Recall that the data of an (extended) stacky fan is equivalent to GIT data consisting of
- 1.
A vector space of dimension ;
- 2.
A torus ;
- 3.
Characters for ;
- 4.
A stability condition ;
- 5.
A set of anticones .
Remark 2.1.1.
The DM stack is defined to be , where
is the semistable locus. Therefore, if are stability conditions, there is a birational map induced by identifying the dense open tori.
Suppose that are separated by a wall in the space of stability conditions. Choose and let
which may not be Deligne-Mumford. Choose a resolution of completing the diagram
We will assume that . Under this assumption, the wall-crossing is crepant:
Example 2.1.2.
If is a vector perpendicular to , the it generates may not be fixed. For example, let and . Let , , and . Therefore,
Let . If , then . Then appears if either
Therefore, there is a wall givven by . In the chamber , we have
and therefore . Taking the quotient, we see that
In the other chamber, we have
which implies that , so
For a stability condition on the wall, we will obtain
The middle is fixed by the cocharacter , so is non-DM.
2.1.2 The secondary variety
Definition 2.1.3.
The wall and chamber structure on defines a fan on called the secondary fan. The associated toric variety is called the secondary toric variety. For us, we will consider the subfan consisting of cones , and their faces. Call the corresponding toric variety . This is a moduli space of Landau-Ginzburg models mirror to the .
Unfortunately, is generally singular, so we will consider a smooth finite cover . Explicitly, we see that
Call the charts . Define
and let be the free -submodule of generated by .
Example 2.1.4.
Continung with the previous example, recall that
If we want , then we see that , so .
Remark 2.1.5.
Recall that
where
is the set of indices contained in every anticone. Therefore, we can split
Claim 2.1.6.
There exist such that
- 1.
for all ;
- 2.
For all , ;
- 3.
All .
Claim 2.1.7.
We have a decomposition
Furthermore, .
Proof.
If , then for all , so . Thus . In the other direction, if , because . Therefore,
Corollary 2.1.8.
There exists an integral basis for of the form
such that live in the closure of the ample cones of and as classes of .
Now we have maps
given by the formulae
for cocharacters .
Remark 2.1.9.
We may reorder the basis as such that is the unique vector not on the wall . Dually, we may write as such that is dual to . In these coordinates, we can write
Let be the analytification of .
2.1.3 Extending the -functions
Let
be the decomposition of some . Then the -functions of are given by
Precisely, we have
In the above formula, we will make the substitutions and
Here, , where is the restriction to , and .
A more explicit formula is given by
where is the twisted sector.
Claim 2.1.10.
The -function defines a convergent power series.
Idea of proof.
Choose and such that . Then is a connected component and a closed substack of . The restriction
is injective. Then
where , , and
For , because for and , the -term vanishes. Convergence follows by the ratio test. □
Because solves an explicit differential equation1 with singularities only at , it can be analytically continued to
For just , there are differential operators such that
where and . Therefore, we may determine by Birkhoff factorization. This gives us quantum connections on .
2.2 Crepant transformation conjecture for toric complete intersections (Davis, Apr 18)
Our goal is now to relate to each other. More precisely, they will differ by a gauge transformation, which is a Fourier-Mukai transform. The main tool will be to compute in localized equivariant cohomology.
2.2.1 Gauge transformation
First, we will rewrite the -functions as ratios of -functions:
where is the age. We will not work directly with these. Instead, we will consider
Using the class, it is related to the -function by the formula
Recall that -fixed points on correspond to pairs , where is a minimal anticone and . Then we compute
Note that for , . In addition, , so if it is negative, then the corresponding -function vanishes. Therefore, we define
and the -function becomes
If , then . Otherwise, has the form , where all for and for the normal vector to pointing towards .
Definition 2.2.1.
A pair are next to each other if both are of the form
where . Likewise, are next to each other if are and .
Lemma 2.2.2.
If is next to , for all and for any ,
Proof.
Expand
Then . Because
and , we see that
This implies that
Claim 2.2.3.
Proof.
Idea of proof If , then for all , so we can write , where and . We now obtain
Using the reflection formula
we may write
We obtain poles at the following locations:
- (1)
gives poles at ;
- (2)
gives poles at ;
- (3)
The last term gives poles at .
We can then rewrite this as a contour integral where the contour is such that all poles of type (1) are on the right and all poles of types (2) and (3) except the one at are on the left. For small , we have
and for large , we have
Choose some for which , we obtain
Setting and
we use the lemma to rewrite some in terms of and conclude. □
We have therefore obtained the formula
Now define
We have a commutative diagram
2.2.2 The Fourier-Mukai transform
We will now prove that is given by the Fourier-Mukai transform. Here, let be a common toric blowup of as in
and . We see that is generated by , where and is generated by . We will now move to the fixed point basis and see that
Remark 2.2.4.
Let be a fixed point of and be in its isotropy. Then .
We now compute .
- 1.
If , then ;
- 2.
Otherwise, we have a complicated formula.
The computation involves doing localization and relating anticones of to those of . We then obtain a commutative diagram
| (2.1) |
by direct computation.
2.2.3 Crepant transformation conjecture
We are now ready to state the crepant transformation conjecture.
Theorem 2.2.5.
Let . Then there exists a degree-preserving symplectic transformation
such that
- 1.
after analytic continuation;
- 2.
If is the map to the toric blowdown, then
for all ;
- 3.
fits into the commutative diagram Equation 2.1.
Theorem 2.2.6 (Crepant transformation conjecture for toric DM stacks).
Let be the quantum connections on . Then there exists a gauge transformation
such that
- 1.
;
- 2.
is homogeneous of degree ;
- 3.
preserves the orbifold Poincaré pairings.
The proof starts by applying differential operators to to obtain
We then set and obtain
2.3 Wall-crossing for Grassmannian flops (Kostya, Apr 25)
We will now consider a wall-crossing in a nonabelian situation. This relies on reducing to the abelian case and citing CIJ.
2.3.1 Geometric setup
Let be a smooth projective variety and let be vector bundles on which split as direct sums of line bundles
Now let
and . acts on the total space of by the formula
Let be the corresponding GIT quotients of . We obtain
The birational transformation here is known as a Grassmannian flop.
Example 2.3.1.
Consider the quiver given by
The corresponding moduli of semistable representations is
Then
There is an action of on the total space of , which induces an action of on . Denote
Let , viewed as a right -representation. Then is a -equivariant vector bundle on which descends to and are the pullbacks of and , repsectively. Now denote by
the Chern roots of . Then
where is the ideal given by
and is defined similarly. Let and . Finally, let be a completion of containing exponentials and -functions. The -fixed loci in correspond to minors of the corresponding Grassmannians. We encode them by
which are strictly order-preserving, as in if . In other words,
Lemma 2.3.2.
We have
This implies that
2.3.2 Abelianization
Let be the maximal torus which acts diagonally on . Then the abelianized quotients are
Note that has many more stability conditions than . Denote
and the GIT quotient
Therefore, and .
The cohomology of is given by
where the ideal is given by
The -fixed loci are indexed by points in . These are denoted by arbitrary functions
Note that is not required to be injective. Thus we have a decomposition
The first abelianization in cohomology is
Next, note the diagram
gives us a rational map between the abelian and nonabelian quotients. This gives us a surjection
The kernel of this morphism are those which are not injective.
2.3.3 Fourier-Mukai transform
Consider the mutual blowup
and let
Here,
Then the morphisms are
The fixed loci in are indexed by .
Lemma 2.3.3.
The projections map isomorphically to or , respectively. Moreover,
Lemma 2.3.4.
The localized -equivariant -theory of is spanned by classes of the form
for and similarly for .
Lemma 2.3.5.
We have
Proposition 2.3.6.
The following diagram commutes:
Here, is an explicit -linear operator given by the formula
where
The strategy to prove this result is first to replace cohomology by the symplectic space and replace the Chern character by the -group framing. Then we use abelianization for -functions [Web23] and repeatedly apply CIJ to each wall-crossing from the . We then compose the symplectic transformations from CIJ and check that it equals the one given above. Finally, a statement about deforming the contour into the Weyl-invariant part gives the desired result.
3 Quantum cohomology of projective bundles
3.1 Mirror theorem (Che, Feb 22)
3.1.1 Setup
Let be a smooth projective variety, be a basis of , be the dual basis, and
We will let
which is the -function in Definition 1.1.3 multiplied by .1. Also, recall the inverse of the fundamental solution of the quantum D-module
which is defined by
Remark 3.1.1.
By the string equation, we have
3.1.2 The vector bundle case
Now let be a vector bundle with . This has an action of scaling the fibers. Then we have
Now we may take to be -valued coordinates.
Remark 3.1.2.
Equivariant localization is required to define the Gromov-Witten invariants of , which lie in .
In order to avoid this issue, we will assume that is globally generated. This implies that is semiprojective, meaning that the evaluation maps are proper. As before, we may define the fundamental solution
and the -function
Because the evaluation maps are proper, they can be defined without localization.
3.1.3 Statement and discussion of the mirror theorem
Theorem 3.1.3.
Define the -valued function
where are the Chern roots of , is the Novikov variable, and . Then lies on the Lagrangian cone of .
Let be the Lagrangian cone for , which has the explicit form
| (3.1) |
Definition 3.1.4.
For a set of variables , we say that is a -valued point on if is of the form 3.1 for some with .
Example 3.1.5.
The point is a -valued point on .
Given this, define . By Theorem 1.1.10, we obtain
which means that any -valued point on can be written as for some and such that and . This property will be used to construct the Fourier transform later.
3.1.4 Proof of Theorem 3.1.3
We will now sketch a proof of Theorem 3.1.3. First, we will need Quantum-Riemann-Roch for a vector bundle in two cases:
- (a)
When the vector bundle is convex, which means that for all stable maps of genus , and is the equivariant Euler class, which corresponds to setting
- (b)
When is globally generated and .
In the first case, we obtain the Gromov-Witten invariants of the zeroes of a regular section of via
In the second case, we obtain the Gromov-Witten invariants of via
We are now ready to begin the proof. Because is globally generated, there is a surjection
This gives an exact sequence
embedding . By a result of Brown-Elezi, we have
Now define
on . This has a section given by
which satisfies . Because is convex, we use Quantum-Riemann-Roch in case (a) to relate the Gromov-Witten theory of to the -twisted Gromov-Witten theory. We now require two more techinical ingredients.
Moving points on the Lagrangian cone via differential operators
Lemma 3.1.6.
Let and be formal variables. Let
be a differential operator. Then preserves -valued points on .
Definition 3.1.7.
A -valued point on is called a miniversal slice if
For example, the -function is a miniversal slice.
Lemma 3.1.8.
Any miniversal slice on can be obtained from be applying for some differential operator as in the previous lemma satisfying .
The rest of the proof (ignoring convergence issues)
First, we introduce
Because and have similar asymptotic expansions, we have
Using the exact sequence
we see that
which preserves the Lagrangian cone . We see that
Applying Quantum-Riemann-Roch in case (b), we see that
and thus
By Lemma 3.1.8, there exists such that
By Lemma 3.1.6, we obtain
Now we compute
where runs over the Chern roots of . Taking the non-equivariant limit , we obtain the in the statement of Theorem 3.1.3.
3.2 Fourier transform (Kostya, Feb 29)
Technically, there are two different Fourier transforms:
- 1.
The discrete Fourier transform ;
- 2.
The continuous Fourier transform .
3.2.1 Quantum -modules and symplectic spaces
Let be a rank vector bundle. The quantum -module of will be
where is the equivariant variable, is the Novikov variable, and for counting a basis of and records the degree of . It is equipped with the Dubrovin connection
given by
Note the last line is only -linear. Recall the fundamental solution is a fundamental solution in the cohomology directions (but not the conformal direction) in the sense that
and intertwines the shift operator by
where
Now, the symplectic space for is
with its Lagrangian cone . It has the important property that is in means that there exists and such that
which can be seen as a Birkhoff factorization.
We now turn to . There is a decomposition
where runs over the Chern roots of . This receives the Kirwan map
Thus the quantum -module for is
where is a basis for and is the Novikov variable of the fiber curve class. It is equipped with the connections .
Remark 3.2.1.
Note there are no shift operators, but there is an additional -direction in the quantum -module for
We also have the symplectic space , the Lagrangian cone , and the fundamental solution . Finally, we will recall the mirror theorem in the form that
lies on .
3.2.2 Discrete Fourier transform
Definition 3.2.2.
The discrete Fourier transform is the transform
In this framing, the mirror theorem states that the discrete Fourier transform of the -function of lies on the Lagrangian cone of .
Theorem 3.2.3.
There exists a “mirror map”
and an isomorphism
of -modules intertwining the connections in the natural ways.
Remark 3.2.4.
One has to be careful with the Novikov variables and think about approximately eight other points of the theorem, but we will ignore these for now.
Because the Fourier transform intertwines the connections, we have the commutative diagram
Idea of proof.
The idea of the proof is to start from the mirror theorem (the bottom row) and apply Birkhoff factorization. The mirror theorem states that
for some mirror map and . Using the intertwining properties of , we see that
Defining
and to be the mirror map appearing in the Birkhoff factorization, we are done. □
Remark 3.2.5.
The mirror map satisfies
and the Fourier transform satisfies
Remark 3.2.6.
The Fourier transform intertwines the natural pairings on the quantum -modules.
3.2.3 Continuous Fourier transform
Definition 3.2.7.
Define
where depending on parity.
Theorem 3.2.8.
For , there exist maps given by
and an isomorphism
intertwining the pairings and quantum connections in a natural way, namely that
Writing , we have
Idea of proof.
We use another realization of the Fourier transform on and
If we consider arising from Quantum Riemann-Roch, it is given as
Shifting by , we see that
We now consider the transformation
for . Because this integral intertwines with and with , it formally gives a solution to .
To make sense of this terrible expression, we use the stationary phase expansion of the integral. Setting
where is the Stirling asymptotics of , given by
The critical points of are given by
which tells us that . Thus, we obtain solutions
We now consider the formal expansions around . These produce a “continuous Fourier transform”
such that
These intertwine the quantum connection and multiplication by , as in
so is on the Lagrangian cone of . We then use the following result:
Proposition 3.2.9.
We have
for some .
Unfortunately, does not intertwine correctly. To fix this, define
and by a shift of . □
3.2.4 Discrete equals continuous
Warning 3.2.10.
Everything in this subsection may be false.
Consider the Fourier transform
This can be computed either using residues or using stationary phase asymptotics. Using residues, we obtain
which is precisely
Using stationary phase asymptotics, we obtain the defined previously.
4 Quantum cohomology of blowups
4.1 Setup (Kostya, Mar 07)
Let be a smooth projective variety, be a smooth closed subvariety of codimension , and
be the blowup of with center . Denote the exceptional divisor by
As a vector space, there is an isomorphicm
Our goal is to upgrade this to the level of quantum cohomology. However, this is very tricky because of convergence issues, so it will be a corollary of a decomposition theorem for quantum -modules.
Recall that the quantum -module of is given by
with the Dubrovin connection
and pairing
4.1.1 Statement of the theorem
The first problem we need to fix is that the cohomological and Novikov variables of are different.
Definition 4.1.1.
The extended Novikov ring is defined as
where and .
Introducing another formal variable , we can embed the Novikov rings of into , where is either or depending on the parity of (we want to be even):
- •
embeds as ;
- •
embeds as ;
- •
embeds as , where .
Later, we will see that , where will be an equivariant variable for a action. Denote
We can now state the main result.
Theorem 4.1.2.
There exists a formal invertible change of variables
denoted by
and an isomorphism
such that intertwines the quantum connections and the pairings.
4.1.2 The master space
Definition 4.1.3.
Define the master space
to be the degeneration to the normal cone of . This is endowed with a -action extending the action
for . See Figure 4.1 for a picture of .
The fixed locus of the -action is given by
We can also see that
Note here that
so a general class in can be written as
The dual notion is the group of -cycles, which is given by
whose Novikov variable is
Note that
The effective curve classes are those which are equivariant, so they either lie in the fixed loci or are -dimensional orbits. There are classes lying entirely inside , classes , which are for , classes , and classes . The corresponding Novikov variables are , and , respectively.
Lemma 4.1.4.
The monoid of effective curve classes is generated by .
Example 4.1.5.
Let and . Then a toric diagram for with is given in Figure 4.2.
The -ample cone of is the dual to the cone of effective curve classes. Then if the set of -stable points under the -action is nonempty. Then there is a decomposition
into pieces where the GIT quotient
respectively. The stable points are
- •
For , the stable points are ;
- •
For , the stable points are .
The dual cones and correspond to embeddings of the effective cones of and , respectively, into the effective cone of as in Figure 4.3.
Recall the Kirwan map
where is either or .
Now consider the equivariant quantum -module
endowed with the quantum connection and the action of the shift operators
which are defined by
where is identified with under the factorization .
We can obtain the quantum -modules for and from the equivariant quantum -module of by taking affine charts and completing. Here, we think of as a global Kähler moduli space.
4.1.3 Fourier transforms
To construct the map in Theorem 4.1.2, Iritani uses both the discrete and continuous Fourier transforms. For , the discrete Fourier transform is given by
The continuous Fourier transform for is given by sending to the element of given by the formal asymptotic expansion of
Remark 4.1.6.
We can think of and either as fixed components (corresponding to the continuous Fourier transform) or as GIT quotients , corresponding to the discrete Fourier transform. These are in fact equal up to a factor.
Note that is not a GIT quotient of , but is a fixed component, so there is a continuous Fourier transform to . In total, we have three morphisms
4.2 Fourier analysis for blowups (Sam, Mar 21)
In this section, denote the Chern roots of by .
4.2.1 Extended Kirwan maps
We will begin by describing the Kirwan maps in coordinates. On , we have
for
for . The dual Kirwan maps on are given by
when and , respectively. It may appear that we don’t see the equivariant parameters in the dual Kirwan map, but we will fix this.
Definition 4.2.1.
The extended Givental space is
which is a base change of .
The shift operators on are now given by
where
4.2.2 Discrete Fourier transform
We are now able to make the following definition.
Definition 4.2.2.
The discrete Fourier transform is
defined by
Because we invert the equivariant parameters, this may not necessarily be well-defined. However, we do have the following result.
Proposition 4.2.3.
The discrete Fourier transform is well-defined on tangent spaces to .
To prove this result, we need various ingredients:
- 1.
Some regularity at , which follows from properness;
- 2.
Not needing arbitrarily high powers of (landing in the target).
As in the case of projective bundles, the shift operators satisfy various nice properties. For example, because
we obtain the formulae
for any .
4.2.3 Continuous Fourier transform
Let be a fixed component in . Denote the Chern roots of by . Now define
More specifically, for each individual fixed component, we have
This actually intertwines all , which are defined for all
Given , we have
which are obtained by section classes on as in Figure 4.5. Now satisfies the equation
which follows from the same argument as in the projective bundle case.
We are now able to describe the continuous Fourier transform formally as an integral which has the same properties as the discrete one. Define
where . Formally, we see that
which suggests that this is the right object to study the asymptotics of. Recall the Stirling approximation
where we have the decomposition
is the first Chern class, , and is the quantum Riemann-Roch operator. We now obtain
We have a critical point
where
Also, for , we have critical points
Definition 4.2.4.
The continuous Fourier transform is given by the asymptotic expansion
where we take the asymptotics as and substitute
and expand in -powers as .
Via taking a formal asymptotic analysis of what we did before, we have
Proposition 4.2.5.
- 1.
The continuous Fourier transform intertwines the shift operators as
- 2.
The continuous Fourier transform intertwines the equivariant parameter via
- 3.
There is a similar property for the Euler vector field.
Now let
Proposition 4.2.6.
There exists
and
such that
In other words, we can recover from after a change of basis and an étale cover of the Kähler moduli space.
Proposition 4.2.7.
The discrete and continuous Fourier transforms agree for . In other words, we have
4.3 Decomposition (Sam, Mar 28)
4.3.1 A general picture
We begin by stating some general conjectures that the blowup result fits into.
Conjecture 4.3.1 (Dubrovin).
Let be smooth and projective. If there exists a semiorthogonal decomposition
then there is a decomposition
More specifically, if admits a full exceptional collection, can be extended to . In addition the Gram matrix of the pairing on is recovered as the Stokes matrix
of flat sections of the irregular connection
On the level of derived categories, we have a decomposition
so we expect a decomposition
In the limit , we obtain at and copies of at roots of unity. The shift away from will correspond to the shift of saddle points in the Fourier transform.
In the equivariant setting, we have semiorthogonal decompositions
We then expect
Conjecture 4.3.2.
Setting , then
lies on the Lagrangian cone of .
4.3.2 Decomposition of the quantum -module
First, we would like to give a more precise formulae for the quantities appearing in Proposition 4.2.6. First, is given by
where
Then we have
where
for .
For , the continuous Fourier transform intertwines and with and with . On the other hand, for , the critical points are different, so there is a shift in . For example, we have
because the integral satisfies the formula
A similar argument yields
We next need a space on which to compare , , and via the dual Kirwan maps. Define
and extend trivially on . As in Figure 4.4, we have and , but we also need
The three charts can be compared on the chart
The comparison of the effective cones of curves is given in Figure 4.3.
The comparison also requires a completion and localization of . In order to compare with we need the action of extended shift operators . Define
The completion is given by
Now let
such that
By taking derivatives , the Fourier transform is lifted to a map of quantum -modules.
Theorem 4.3.3.
There is an isomorphism
and a projection
They intertwine the quantum connection and the pairing up to a shift in .
These extend to the completions, but we will not prove this here.
For and any , there are coordinates
such that
Theorem 4.3.4.
There are projections
which intertwine with and with . Here, is defined by the extension
We will now shift our variables in order to make our comparison. Let
Then
intertwines the quantum connections up to a shift in . Combining the Fourier transforms for the different fixed loci, we obtain
Theorem 4.3.5 (Main theorem).
The diagram
induces an isomorphism
over that intertwines the quantum connections and Poincaré pairings.
Bibliography
- [AGV08]. “Gromov-Witten theory of Deligne-Mumford stacks”. In: Amer. J. Math. 130.5 (2008), pp. 1337–1398. issn: 0002-9327,1080-6377. doi: 10.1353/ajm.0.0017.
- [BCS05]. “The orbifold Chow ring of toric Deligne-Mumford stacks”. In: J. Amer. Math. Soc. 18.1 (2005), pp. 193–215. issn: 0894-0347,1088-6834. doi: 10.1090/S0894-0347-04-00471-0.
- [CG07]. “Quantum Riemann-Roch, Lefschetz and Serre”. In: Ann. of Math. (2) 165.1 (2007), pp. 15–53. issn: 0003-486X,1939-8980. doi: 10.4007/annals.2007.165.15.
- [CIJ18]. “The crepant transformation conjecture for toric complete intersections”. In: Adv. Math. 329 (2018), pp. 1002–1087. issn: 0001-8708,1090-2082. doi: 10.1016/j.aim.2017.11.017.
- [Coa03]. “Riemann-Roch theorem in Gromov-Witten theory”. PhD thesis. University of California at Berkeley, 2003.
- [Dub96]. “Geometry of D topological field theories”. In: Integrable systems and quantum groups (Montecatini Terme, 1993). Vol. 1620. Lecture Notes in Math. Springer, Berlin, 1996, pp. 120–348. isbn: 3-540-60542-8. doi: 10.1007/BFb0094793.
- [Giv04]. “Symplectic geometry of Frobenius structures”. In: Frobenius manifolds. Vol. E36. Aspects Math. Friedr. Vieweg, Wiesbaden, 2004, pp. 91–112. isbn: 3-528-03206-5.
- [Giv98]. “A mirror theorem for toric complete intersections”. In: Topological field theory, primitive forms and related topics (Kyoto, 1996). Vol. 160. Progr. Math. Birkhäuser Boston, Boston, MA, 1998, pp. 141–175. isbn: 0-8176-3975-6.
- [IK24]. Quantum cohomology of projective bundles. 2024. arXiv: 2307.03696 [math.AG].
- [Iri17]. “Shift operators and toric mirror theorem”. In: Geom. Topol. 21.1 (2017), pp. 315–343. issn: 1465-3060,1364-0380. doi: 10.2140/gt.2017.21.315.
- [Iri23]. Quantum cohomology of blowups. 2023. arXiv: 2307.13555 [math.AG].
- [Jia08]. “The orbifold cohomology ring of simplicial toric stack bundles”. In: Illinois J. Math. 52.2 (2008), pp. 493–514. issn: 0019-2082,1945-6581.
- [LSW24]. Crepant Transformation Conjecture For the Grassmannian Flop. 2024. arXiv: 2404.12302 [math.AG].
- [PSW24]. Wall crossing and the Fourier-Mukai transform for Grassmann flops. 2024. arXiv: 2404.12303 [math.AG].
- [Tse10]. “Orbifold quantum Riemann-Roch, Lefschetz and Serre”. In: Geom. Topol. 14.1 (2010), pp. 1–81. issn: 1465-3060,1364-0380. doi: 10.2140/gt.2010.14.1.
- [Web23]. “The abelian-nonabelian correspondence for -functions”. In: Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN 3 (2023), pp. 2592–2648. issn: 1073-7928,1687-0247. doi: 10.1093/imrn/rnab305.