The B-model
Abstract.
These are notes taken based on the Bilibili minicourse on the B-model given by Si Li in Spring 2025 at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. The minicourse consisted of 12 lectures.
1 Introduction
The B-model has its origins in mirror symmetry, which is a duality of two dimensional superconformal field theories (SCFTs) in physics. These describe the geometry of a mapping space from a surface to a target space (see Figure 1). The duality gives mathematical predictions which relate symplectic geometry (the A-model) to complex geometry (the B-model).
There is a duality
where both sides involve some kind of infinite-dimensional geometry. However, we can reduce this to a finite-dimensional geometry by a form of supersymmetric localization, which we will not explain. The interested reader can refer to the speaker’s lectures at the Perimeter Institute on supersymmetry and TQFTs, which are also on Bilibili.
There is a string description via a worldsheet theory, where we consider maps as in Figure 2. This theory is called string field theory. This describes string theory using the language of quantum field theory. The correspondence goes as in Table 1.
| String Fock space | String field theory |
|---|---|
| Dynamics | String field action |
We outline some historical developments in both mathematics and physics related to the B-model.
- •
In 1992, Zwiebach described a general structure for closed string field theory and discovered that it is described by a string action which contains infinitely many vertices and satisfies the BV master equation, something we will describe later in the language of the B-model. In particular, if we consider the genus closed string field, we will discover a homotopy Lie algebra or an -algebra.
- •
In 1997, Zwiebach extended this theory to the open string field, which is described by an -algebra. When coupled with the closed string field, it satisfies the open-closed master equation, which is described via the moduli of bordered Riemann surfaces.
We will consider the B-model from the perspective of string field theory. This is usually referred to as the B-twisted topological field theory, and when coupled to gravity, it becomes the topological string theory. It is localized around constant maps, and near each constant map, we see the “local” string field action. The correspondence goes as in Figure 3.
Here are some developments in the history of describing this new action:
- •
Witten described the A-model open string field using Chern-Simons and instanton theories in 1992. As for the B-model open string field, he described it as holomorphic Chern-Simons theory. Finally, he speculated that the theory is actually UV-finite, which we know now is true by the work of M. Wang and J. Yan.
- •
The famous work of Bershadsky-Cecotti-Ooguri-Vafa in 1994 described the B-model closed string field theory on a Calabi-Yau threefold as a gauge theory, which they call Kodaira-Spencer gravity. This has some interesting features:
- –
At the classical level, the equation of motion describes deformation of complex structures on the Calabi-Yau threefold. By Yau’s proof of the Calabi conjecture, this leads to a family of solutions which are Ricci-flat metrics.
- –
The leading cubic vertex of Zwiebach’s string action in the topological B-model admits a full description.
- –
- •
There is a construction by Barannikov-Kontsevich which constructs the Frobenius manifold (which encodes classical genus-zero data) of this theory via the geometry of polyvector fields, which will be discussed in the next few lectures.
- •
In 2012, the speaker and Kevin Costello gave a mathematical definition of the full string action for the topological B-model on a Calabi-Yau manifold of any dimension and proved that it satisfies the full BV master equation. They refer to this as BCOV theory.
- •
In 2015/16, the same authors determined the B-model open-closed quantum coupling in the large limit and from this perspective they worked out a version of twisted supergravity. Most of the lectures will explain the speaker’s work with Costello.
We will now fix some conventions. We will work with the category of -graded vector spaces
For any , we will denote its degree by . We will denote degree shifts by
or namely, shifting to the left. Finally, we will discuss some conventions on tensors. We will denote the symmetric power by
and the exterior powers by
These are sometimes referred to as the graded symmetric product and the graded skew-symmetric product. Finally, we will consider the symmetric algebra (or polynomial algebra)
and its completion (a power series ring)
For a graded algebra , we will always use to refer to the graded commutator, which is defined by
Finally, if is a smooth manifold , we will write
to denote smooth differential forms on and denote the de Rham differential by . If is a complex manifold, we can decompose
and decompose the differential as .
Exercise 1.1.
Show that
2 Calabi-Yau geometry
In this section, we will build some foundations for Calabi-Yau geometry. Let be a complex manifold of dimension . We will denote the holomorphic tangent bundle by .
We will denote polyvector fields by
and the space of all polyvector fields by
Locally, we can write can be written as
where and are multi-indices. Here, the index notation looks like
These look like differential forms, but are in fact subtly different. All are smooth and skew-symmetric for indices in both and in .
There is a natural (wedge) product
which makes a bi-graded algebra. We will define the total degree by for . This makes a graded-commutative algebra, namely that .
We can also extend the -operator to polyvector fields, which has degree and goes as
This is in fact a derivation which satisfies the graded Leibniz rule
There are many definitions for Calabi-Yau manifolds, so we will choose one.
Definition 2.1.
A Calabi-Yau manifold is a pair where is a complex manifold and is a nowhere-vanishing holomorphic volume form on .
In local holomorphic coordinates on , we can write
where is a nowhere-vanishing holomorphic function. The Calabi-Yau form induces a linear isomorphism
We now consider the divergence operator
with respect to the volume form , which is defined using the commutative diagram
Note that this depends on the choice of volume form. Unfortunately, we will abuse notation and write for and whether we mean the divergence operator or the holomorphic de Rham operator will be clear from context. Unfortunately, the divergence operator is not a derivation. The failure is described by the tensor
This bracket is known in geometry and is related to the Schouten-Nijenhuis bracket by the sign
In mathematics, this is sometimes called the Bogomolov-Tian-Todorov lemma and in physics it is related to the BV algebra. In fact, the difference between the Schouten-Nijenhuis bracket and the BV bracket is related to shifting the degree by . The BV bracket has degree given by
It is in fact intrinsically defined independent of the choice of volume form (or divergence operator).
Remark 2.2.
The lifting of to the volume form or the divergence operator is related to BV quantization.
Exercise 2.3.
Show that the BV bracket satisfies graded symmetry
the Leibniz relation
and the graded Jacobi identity
Remark 2.4.
The algebra is a fundamental example of a differential graded Gerstenhaber BV algebra and exists in a large class of examples.
We can now define a trace map
This trace is only nontrivial for and will be used later to discuss higher residue pairings.
Exercise 2.5.
Show that the trace map is compatible with the the two differentials via the identities
and
We will now let be a compact Kähler manifold. The deformation space of complex structures on is locally given by
Here, the final condition is a gauge-fixing condition and is known as the Maurer-Cartan equation.
Theorem 2.6 (Bogomolov-Tian-Todorov).
Let be a compact Kähler Calabi-Yau manifold. Then the deformation space is smooth and has dimension
In general, we can consider the extended moduli space by solving
modulo gauge for all types of polyvector fields. We can view the original moduli space as a submanifold of the extended one.
Theorem 2.7 (Barannikov-Kontsevich).
The extended moduli space is smooth.
Proof.
Consider the divergence-free polyvector fields . Given , we consider their BV bracket
which is -exact. Therefore,
This fact will be crucial.
The complex is actually a (shifted) dg Lie algbera, and we consider the inclusion
This is actually a morphism of dg Lie algebras and is in fact a quasi-isomorphism. If we allow be the harmonic elements, then extending Hodge theory gives us
by the Kähler condition. Now define the projection
By the -lemma, we see that , so we can consider the map
which is again a morphism of dg Lie algebras. Now we have the zig-zag
where both maps are quasi-isomorphisms. By some abstract nonsense, solving the Maurer-Cartan up to gauge is invariant under quasi-isomorphisms, and solving the Maurer-Cartan equation in is trivial. Therefore we have . □
3 Period map
Before we move to the B-model, we need to discuss the period map, which will allow us to write down action functionals. Let be a compact Kähler Calabi-Yau manifold. Given satisfying the Maurer-Cartan equation
we will use to denote the complex manifold specified by the deformation . Assume that are local holomorphic coordinates on . We can write
Then we can define new holomorphic -forms by
and these form a local basis of -forms on .
Let denote the complex vector bundle over whose fiber at is the de Rham cohomology . This bundle admits a flat connection, called the Gauss-Manin connection, and denoted by , which identifies the nearby fibers to the central one as
There is some global issue with monodromy, but locally the identification is canonical. We now define the holomorphic subbundles (the Hodge filtration) with fibers
In particular, there is the line bundle which picks up the holomorphic volume form on . In physics, this is known as the vacuum line bundle. Later, we will see that invariants of the B-model are actually sections of powers of this line bundle.
The period map is locally given by the map
Here, we need to use the Gauss-Manin connection to identify the cohomology of with that of . The period map is actually a local embedding (the local Torelli theorem). Sometimes it is helpful to remember the actual volume form, and if we consider the -bundle
over , then a point here represents a pair , so we have defined the local moduli of deformations of a pair . This allows us to lift the period map to an embedding
Our goal is to understand the geometry of the period map, which will allow us to understand the action functional of the B-model. We will begin with the case of Calabi-Yau threefolds, which is classical, and then move to a more modern perspective. Let be a Calabi-Yau threefold. Then has a symplectic pairing given by
Considering the Hodge filtration, the subspace
is a Lagrangian subspace. Over the moduli space defines a fiberwise symplectic pairing on which is flat with respect to the Gauss-Manin connection. Then we can lift the Hodge filtration to a subbundle
which gives a holomorphic family of Lagrangian subspaces.
Proposition 3.1.
The embedding defines a Lagrangian submanifold.
Proof.
Let be a holomorphic family of Calabi-Yau forms parameterized by . By Griffiths transversality, we see that
Every fiber is a linear Lagrangian subspace, so we are done. □
From this data, we can cook up B-model invariants as follows. Choose a Lagrangian splitting be a transversal linear Lagrangian subspace such that
is an isotropic splitting. This allows us to identify
where we use to refer to . Then is a Lagrangian submanifold as in Figure 4. Therefore, there is some function such that is the graph of .
Example 3.2.
Choose (the complex conjugate splitting). Physicists would now write down some special geometry and prepotentials. We parametrize by
Because , we see that has homogeneous degree . The local coordinates on are given by . Therefore, we can write
Geometrically, actually defines a local section of , where is the vacuum line bundle. We can now reparaterize the extended moduli space by
The factor inside the parentheses is called the primitive period map. We now obtain a particular choice of holomorphic volume form on the moduli space given by
We are now finally able to calculate the Yukawa coupling for the moduli space by
In the physics literature, is called the prepotential.
Exercise 3.3.
Prove the formula for the Yukawa coupling in the previous example.
Before we proceed, we need to describe the deformation of the pair . We know that deformations of are given by satisfying the Maurer-Cartan equation
In the complex structure specified by , the elements
form a new basis of -forms on .
Lemma 3.4.
We have
for any differential forms .
The lemma now implies that
is of type with respect to . Applying this globally, the form
is of type in . Therefore, there exists a smooth function such that
is a holomorphic volume form on . Because the type is , then the form is holomorphic if and only if it is closed, or in other words that . This gives us the two equations
which govern deformations of the pair . These equations were studied by Barannikov in his work on variations of semi-infinite Hodge structures.
4 Extended period map
Introduce a formal parameter of degree , which will play the role of gravitational descendents and consider the combined differential
We can rewrite our two equations as the single equation
where we have defined
Introduce a new (shifted) dg Lie algebra
Remark 4.1.
The data of can be viewed as a homological replacement of volume-preserving (divergence-free) vector fields . We may now write the complex
which behaves badly, so we replace it with .
Remark 4.2.
The variable plays the role of gravitational descendants (namely -classes on the A-side) in the B-model.
Remark 4.3.
If gives extended moduli for , then gives extended moduli for the Calabi-Yau geometry.
Remark 4.4.
The variable can be viewed as an equivariant parameter for rotation on the worldsheet in the worldsheet B-model.
Question 4.5.
Can we express the above equations as the variational critical locus of some action functional?
One reason we would be interested in this question is because this is the usual approach to classical physics, and then we can quantize these using path integrals. This is unfortunately highly nontrivial, and on a Calabi-Yau threefold, BCOV work with some . They found that the Maurer-Cartan equation
is equivalent to for the Kodaira-Spencer action .
Warning 4.6.
This approach unfortunately violates locality for various reasons:
- •
is not a module over ;
- •
One of the terms in is nonlocal.
Consider the Calabi-Yau geometry and let . We can ask for an action functional whose critical points are solutions of
Unfortunately, the speaker was unable to find this, but there is some magic involved. If we perform an transformation, this equation becomes
and for this equation there is a BCOV action which was found by Costello and the speaker. The transformation is produced directly from the period map.
Definition 4.7.
Define
where the shift makes have degree . Then define
This makes , and once we define a symplectic structure it will be a splitting by isotropic subspaces. However, does not preserve the splitting, but this will lead to the classical master equation.
We define a -sesquilinear pairing on (inspired by the higher residue pairing of Kyoji Saito)
by the formula
Observe that
If we calculate the degrees, then is only nontrivial when
so if we take the original shift by into account, we have proved the following result.
Proposition 4.8.
The space has a -shifted symplectic structure.
Remark 4.9.
For a Calabi-Yau threefold , we have the splitting
and the we will be able to identify this with
via contraction with , which we will call . The higher residue pairing will be identified with the usual pairing on differential forms. We should note however that this only works for threefolds.
Proposition 4.10.
The operator is (graded) skew-symmetric with respect to .
Proof.
The proof is left as an exercise. The key point is to study the operators and . □
We now consider the (cochain) period map
Remark 4.11.
This is understood as a map on formal schemes. For any Artinian ring , we send
This truncates at finite order, so the map is well-defined.
We compute the tangent map at , and we see
so we see that
is simply the inclusion with a sign of . See Figure 5 for a visualization. This implies that is a formal embedding.
This map is actually an -morphism
One way to see this is to check that the Maurer-Cartan equation is preserved. We can check that
and therefore we see that satisfies the Maurer-Cartan equation if and only if does. Therefore, if we view as a vector field on , then is tangent to and is thus the pushforward of a vector field on which defines the structure.
The image of the period map is a formal Lagrangian submanifold. If we calculate the variation of the period map, we see that
Proposition 4.12.
For all , we have
Proof.
The proof is left as an exercise. □
5 Classical BCOV action
Some references for this include the surveys Some classical/quantum aspects of Calabi-Yau moduli and Renormalization method and mirror symmetry by the lecturer in addition to his work with Costello.
We will begin with a toy model to describe the geometry of gravitational descendants. Suppose the case when is a point. In this case, , , and . The symplectic pairing is given by
The period map now looks like Figure 6. The image of the period map is a formal Lagrangian submanifold.
Under the identification , we write the image of the period map as the graph of for some . We will parameterize as
Then we can write , and our goal is to compute this. We see that
Denoting this by , we will try to find its geometry. This actually becomes a combinatorial problem, but this actually becomes too complicated. Instead, it can be charcterized by various properties, which correspond to properties of the Lagrangian cone in Gromov-Witten theory.
The first property is the string equation. Let be the operator which sends . Now define
which is essentially multiplying by . We can view as a vector field on , which is actually symplectic, namely satisfying the equation
Writing the symplectic form as
we see that
This implies that
Therefore, we will write the Hamiltonian as
The following result is one of the basic results in the Givental formalism.
Lemma 5.1.
The vector field is tangent to the object , which is known as the dilaton shift.
Proof.
Let . We calculate the tangent space
We conclude by calculating . □
We can now write down a Hamilton-Jacobi equation, which says that is constant. In this example, the constant will be zero, we see that
This is equivalent to the PDE
which is exactly the string equation from Gromov-Witten theory.
The second property we will consider is the dilaton equation. Consider the operator
This is also a symplectic operator satisfying
The Hamiltonian function is now given by
Note that all of our operators are linear, so the Hamiltonians are quadratic.
Lemma 5.2.
The vector field is tangent to .
Proof.
The proof is similar to the string equation, so it is left as an exercise. □
We can once again write the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, which says that
This implies that
which is exactly the dilaton equation from Gromov-Witten theory. We may continue this and write down the classical Virasoro constraints, but we will stop here.
There is a third equation, called the grading equation. Consider the degree operator
Here, we are remembering that there is actually a shift by that we have been suppressing and that has degree .
Lemma 5.3.
is tangent to the Lagrangian (with no dilaton shift).
Unfortunately, this is not a Hamiltonian vector field (in particular the symplectic form has a nonzero degree). The lemma is equivalent to the statement that is preserved by the -action taking . In particular, we see that is homogeneous of degree if we assign . Combining this with the string and dilaton equations, it is easy to show the following.
Proposition 5.4.
For each , we have
The general case follows easily from the point case, and in particular we can determine the classical BCOV action. Denote the image of the cochain period map (see Figure 5) by , which is a formal Lagrangian submanifold of . Writing as the graph of , we can determine as a function on . Denote
This extends -linearly to a map
Theorem 5.5 (Costello-Li).
We have the formula
This is known as the classical BCOV action.
If we write for , we see that
In the Kodaira-Spencer gravity of BCOV, the fields are , and their action is given by
This looks a bit unusual, because we can find the Maurer-Cartan equation, but the original theory is nonlocal, which poses problems for quantization (which is why we replace with the complex ).
6 Hodge structure and primitive forms
We can pass our picture from the cochan level to cohomology (or really the Maurer-Cartan functor). We will let
The extended period map
Because is compatible with , there is an induced symplectic form (shifted by ) on , which we also call . If we consider the subcomplex
then we see an isotropic subspace
However, is not preserved by , so we do not have a preferred choice of splitting at this level.
Definition 6.1.
An opposite filtration of is a choice of linear isotropic subspace such that
- (1)
There is an isotropic splitting ;
- (2)
is preserved by .
A choice of opposite filtration splits the map
by the natural isomorphism
If we write and , then and , where we choose . This allows us to write
Using this, the period map looks like Figure 7. We then see that is the graph of , where is a function on , which is called the B-model state space (and is the genus-zero B-model potential).
We now consider the geometry of the opposite filtration. Define the map
for . This intertwines the operator with the standard de Rham differential . Observe that
where is the Hodge filtration. Here, we can see that
where we identify . In particular, we see that
gives us a sum of graded pieces of the Hodge filtration. In particular, we see that is equivalent to a splitting of the Hodge filtration. Some examples include the following:
- (1)
If we let is the complex conjugate splitting (the harmonic splitting), we obtain the usual Hodge decomposition
However, this splitting does not give the correct B-model invariants.
- (2)
We can let be the monodromy splitting, which arises near the large complex structure limit. This is in fact the correct splitting in the B-model and gives the mirror to Gromov-Witten theory. If we move to a different point (maybe the Gepner point), we get a different monodromy splitting, which is mirror to FJRW theory.
Remark 6.2.
For a Calabi-Yau threefold, we have a symplectic subspace
and identifies this with the space
We will now introduce primitive forms (due to Kyoji Saito), or equivalently, J-functions (due to Givental). Fix a splitting and a subspace
with basis .
Definition 6.3 (Higher residue pairing).
Define the pairing
When we come to the Landau-Ginzburg B-model, this is literally Saito’s higher residue pairing. In addition, note that
If we reduce modulo , this simply becomes the trace pairing on .
There are some peculiar properties here. First, the isotropic splitting
implies that
Together, these tell us that
sends to constants. In our basis, we will write
Saito calls this choice a good basis. With our choice of splitting, write
for the corresponding projection. Under the choice of good basis , we see that
simply eliminates the terms of negative degree in .
Now consider the fiber product
Let’s write coordinates for and coordinates for . This identifies a family
solving the Maurer-Cartan equation
This will play the role of the primitive form in Saito’s theory. The solution also satisfies
Here, the notation means taking the cohomology class with respect to . This can be rewritten as the equation
using the fact that the period map has image the graph of . We can see that the right-hand side of this equation is the J-function , which is the analogue of the J-function defined by Givental in Gromov-Witten theory. We can again rewrite this as
and the left-hand side here is the primitive form defined by Saito.
Proposition 6.4.
The quantity
is independent of .
Proof.
By the expression of , we see that
On the other hand, we can calculate
where we use the fact that this last expression lies in the tangent space to the Lagrangian cone. The conclusion follows by comparing our two calculations. □
We see now that defines a family of good bases parameterized by . Geometrically, we see that
At , we see that is our original choice of good basis. Because we have the splitting
we see that the splitting
holds for nearby . The idea (due to Givental) is that the set forms a basis of .
We can now compute the second derivatives in two ways as we did with the higher residue pairing. On one hand, the expression of tells us that
On the other hand, we calculate
In particular, the two calculations imply that
This now implies that there exists such that
Passing to the primitive form, this is now equivalent to the statement that
Remark 6.5.
There is a perturbative algorithm for the Landau-Ginzburg B-model due to Li-Li-Saito, which allows us to compute the primitive form order by order using a method similar to Birkhoff factorization.
7 Classical master equation
Recall the period map as in Figure 5. Using the string and dilaton equations, we determined that was the graph of , where
Our goal now will be to study some structure relating to , which will allow us to pass to a finite-dimensional model. is odd (whereas the Virasoro constraints are even), so we will write down an odd version of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, which will be the classical master equation.
Because preserves , we will write down the quadratic Hamiltonian , which will satisfy . The differential satisfies , and is therefore a cohomological vector field. Here are some properties of the operator :
- •
It preserves ;
- •
It does not preserve .
To give an idea of the general picture and how to quantize the theory, we will consider a finite-dimensional toy model. Let
be a dg (even) symplectic vector space (and for simplicity, we will assume the degree is ), so in particular we can consider one of
By definition, the differential is skew-symmetric with respect to . Assume that we have a splitting
where both and are Lagrangian subspaces. We will require that preserves but not necessarily . The splitting will allow us to make the identification and consider the projection
We know that . To write down the Hamiltonian function, consider
Denote the component in by
which plays the role of the BV kernel and measures the failure of to preserve .
Proposition 7.1.
defines a degree element of and is -compatible, namely that
Proof.
Using the fact that is skew-symmetric with respect to , we see that
This implies that
is symmetric, and projecting to concludes the proof. □
This is actually a dual description of the Hamiltonian function . Geometrically, we can consider
which exactly gives the quadratic Hamiltonian associated to . Using the fact that
we see that
We see that the Hamilton-Jacobi equation will have a linear term coming from the first two components and a quadratic term coming from the last component.
Definition 7.2.
Denote the differential operator
by contracting with . More explicitly, we define
Also define the BV bracket
Proposition 7.3.
The data defines a dg Gerstenhaber-Batalin-Vilkovisky (dGBV) algebra.
Proof.
Because , we see that . The rest of the properties are straightforward to check. □
Now assume that we have a Lagrangian submanifold
which is the graph of for some function .
Proposition 7.4.
is tangent to if and only if
This is called the classical master equation.
Proof.
The odd Hamilton-Jacobi equation says that . The mixed part of corresponds to and the purely momentum part corresponds to the BV bracket. □
Now denote by
the corresponding cohomological vector field. The classical master equation can now be rewritten as . In fact, with the picture as in Figure 8, we see that
Because , we see that as well.
We will now return to our original infinite-dimensional setting of the B-model on a Calabi-Yau manifold . The structure is a bit more complicated but is still similar. Recall that
Also recall that
The problem comes from the trace pairing, which causes the Poisson tensor to involve distributions as
where is a distributional element of and is the integral kernel for the identity operator
Note that this is fine classically but will presernt problems for quantizing the theory. We can still write down the BV kernel
because only fails to preserve on via the term. Given a local functional on of the form its variation can be computed as
We define the BV bracket for two local functionals and by
which produces another local functional. Copying the finite-dimensional case, we have the following theorem.
Theorem 7.5 (Costello-Li).
The BCOV action satisfies the classical master equation
Remark 7.6.
The theorem is proved directly in the lecturer’s PhD thesis, where he finds that the classical master equation is equivalent to the genus-zero topological recursion relations.
8 Quantum master equation
Note that the map is a diffeomorphism. However, we gain the classical interaction and the Maurer-Cartan equation with respect to becomes
where emerge from the term.
We will now return to our toy model of a dg symplectic vector space. We also continue to assume the Poisson kernel and the isotropic splitting . preserves but not , and we wrote down the tensor
This produced a dGBV algebra
Definition 8.1.
We define the (formal) Weyl algebra
where is the formal (quantum) parameter and the relation is generated by
Note that the classical limit
is the formal functions on . We denote the annihilator to be
Because the differential preserves , the induced differential preserves as well.
Proposition 8.2.
The annihilator is a subcomplex.
Definition 8.3.
The (formal) Fock space is defined by
Remark 8.4.
We treat as annihilation operators.
Because is compatible with , we see that defines a cochain complex with subcomplex . This induces a differential
The splitting induces a natural embedding given by extension by zero on . Let
be the formal functions on . This induces
and realizes as creation operators (which for physicists look like expressions of the form ). Under this isomorphism, there is a differential on , namely the unique one making the diagram
commute. However, this is not the same as the one induced from (which extends to ).
Proposition 8.5.
The difference between and is precisely the failure of to preserve the splitting, namely
Proof.
This is standard quantization of quadratic Hamiltonians and is left as an exercise. □
Definition 8.6.
A formal function
satisfies the quantum BV master equation (QME) if
Equivalently, we can rewrite this as
Note that in the classical limit , we recover the classical master equation
We now discuss what is going on in a physical sense. Consider the state
Then the quantum master equation is equivalent to the statement that , which in physics is called the quantum gauge consistency. Passing to -cohomology (what physicists call physical states), we pass to
which usually an element of a finite-dimensional space. If we let and , then we have a symplectic vector space with as an isotropic subspace. If we choose a polarization , the surjection reduces to a surjection
and the target is once again isomorphic to because the polarization gives an embedding . Because , we obtain a state
The choice of splitting gives us a formal function
Unfortunately, this is extremely hard to compute.
Warning 8.7.
If we try to redo everything in the actual B-model, the “quantum master equation”
is ill-defined because is singular. This will require choosing a Kähler metric, doing renormalization, and defining everything in a homotopical way.
9 Homotopic renormalization
In quantum theory, we will replace by , where is the space of fields. Usually, we will take
to be the global (smooth) sections of some graded vector bundle and
to be an elliptic operator (for example or ). This data will be called an elliptic complex. The (shifted) symplectic space will be replaced by a (shifted) Poisson kernel , which is a distributional section of which is usually supported on the diagonal of (here, note that comes from the inverse of integration, which involves delta functions).
We will now follow the toy model until we reach an obstruction. The first modification we need to make is to force to be the continuous dual (these are essentially distributions on ). The next modification we need is to consider that is a nuclear space, so when we write , we mean the completed tensor product, which we think of as distributions on . This allows us to define
We may now discuss functions on as
Our next goal is to define the BV operator, which in the toy model was
We would like to define
but this is not well-defined because we cannot pair two distributions, which in QFT is known as the ultraviolet problem and arises in any infinite-dimensional model.
We will resolve this problem by using Costello’s homotopic renormalization theory. We will change notation and replace by , which is the (shifted) Poisson kernel. This is -closed, namely that
The key observations are
- (1)
is a -closed distribution;
- (2)
Elliptic regularity means that
and therefore we can write
where is a smooth kernel and is a distribution known as the parametrix.
We will call the renormalized BV kernel with respect to the parametrix . Now, we can define
by contracting with the smooth kernel . This is now well-defined and gives us a renormalized BV operator
(Note that working with formal power series means we are working perturbatively, and the non-perturbative theory is much more complicated). Because is -closed, we see that
Definition 9.1.
The data defines a dGBV algebra called the renormalized dGBV with respect to the parametrix .
Question 9.2.
How do we resolve the possible dependence on the choice of parametrix ?
Let and be two parametrices such that
Then we see that is smooth inside .
Definition 9.3.
Define the operator
by contracting with the smooth kernel .
Proposition 9.4.
The following diagram commutes:
Proof.
Note that . This implies that
This implies that
Definition 9.5.
Define
Note that in physics this is called interaction theory. We define the homotopic renormalization group flow
by the formula
The real content is that
This tells us that
is a sum over connected Feynman diagrams, where contributions are as in Figure 9. The physicists would call the vertex and the propagator.
Definition 9.6.
A solution of the effective quantum master equation is an assignment for each parametrix satisfying
- (1)
The renormalized quantum master equation (RQME)
- (2)
For any two parametrices and , we have
Because of the chain homotopy
we see that the two conditions are compatible. The picture is as in Figure 10, where the two points and represent two different choices of parametrix and the arrow represents the homotopic renormalization group flow. The central dot represents the original singular kernel , which is homotopic to both and via the parametrices and .
10 Quantum BCOV theory
We are finally ready to discuss the quantum B-model. Recall that our space of fields is
with , which had the (shifted) Poisson kernel
Because this kernel is singular, we will need to run the homotopic renormalization group flow. First, choose a Kähler metric on . This gives us
which is the adjoint of . We can then write down the Laplacian and then the heat kernel
for any , which represents
for any . Now let
(this limit holds because the heat kernel converges to the delta function). Also, note that because of the grading,
is the usual Laplacian. Now the parametrix is given by
Proposition 10.1.
We have .
Proof.
This is the integral kernel representation of the operator equation
Because and the Kähler condition implies that
we see that
Definition 10.2.
Given , define the effective propagator
This is the homotopy from to .
Definition 10.3 (Costello-Li).
A perturbative quantization of BCOV theory on is a family of functionals (or distributions)
for each such that
- (1)
They respect the homotopic renormalization group flow, namely
- (2)
The renormalized quantum master equation
where , holds;
- (3)
The locality axiom that has a small asymptotic expansion by local functionals as ;
- (4)
The classical limit
recovers the classical BCOV action;
- (5)
The degree axiom and Hodge weight axiom hold (this is analogous to Gromov-Witten theory) such that has Hodge weight , where has Hodge weight .
Remark 10.4.
This quantization is not necessarily unique.
Given a quantization , we consider the IR limit . In this limit, we have
and therefore the quantum master equation becomes
This implies that , so it represents some cohomology class
A choice of Kähler metric gives a splitting of the Hodge filtration, which gives an isomorphism
This now gives quantum B-model invariants , which by the mirror conjecture should be related to the Gromov-Witten invariants on the mirror .
Calculations are very hard, but we can do them using UV finiteness and locality. In practice, constructing a quantization is very complicated, but the program usually goes as follows.
- (1)
Start with a local functional (the classical interaction).
- (2)
Find an -dependent local functional
such that the limit
exists. If we can find the counterterms, the family automatically satisfies the homotopic RG flow. However, it does not necessarily satisfy the quantum master equation.
- (3)
Find further corrections to solve the quantum master equation. This step may be obstructed, and the obstruction is known in physics as the gauge anomaly.
Definition 10.5.
We say the theory is UV finite if the limit
exists for the class of local functionals in question without the need for counterterms.
Now assume that the theory is UV finite (all chiral theories like BCOV theory, holomorphic Chern-Simons, etc are in fact UV finite). Unfortunately, the equation
is ill-defined at , so we regularize to an equation of the form
If the theory is UV finite, we can take the limit to obtain something like
where the can be viewed as higher brackets for local functionals and come from resolving the ill-defined term . We will refer to this as the renormalized local quantum master equation. Unfortunately, what the are is not known in general.
Exercise 10.6.
Do this for holomorphic Chern-Simons theory.
There is one case where the higher brackets are known explicitly.
Theorem 10.7 (Li).
2D chiral theories are UV finite and the renormalized local quantum master equation is equivalent to the Maurer-Cartan equation in chiral vertex operator algebras.
The renormalization behaves as in Figure 11, and a reference is the paper Vertex algebras and quantum master equation by the lecturer. From this, we can obtain an explicit canonical solution for the quantum B-model on elliptic curves and establish the quantum mirror conjecture.
Theorem 10.8 (Wang-Yan).
Chiral theories of any dimension are UV finite (which implies that BCOV theory and holomorphic Chern-Simons theory are UV finite).
The result of Wang-Yan implies that quantum BCOV theory has a local expression.
Remark 10.9.
Gui calculated the higher chiral operator product expansions.
11 Landau-Ginzburg B-model
There are many ways to describe the Landau-Ginzburg B-model (for example via the category of matrix factorizations), but we will take the approach of string field theory. We will consider the Landau-Ginzburg B-model associated to the data , where
- (1)
is a non-compact complex manifold;
- (2)
is a holomorphic volume form on ;
- (3)
is a holomorphic function1 (called the superpotential) on with compact critical locus (which we call ).
We will consider polyvector fields and the compactly supported polyvector fields . We will twist the Dolbeault operator and write
We will still refer to the divergence operator with respect to as . Then we can consider the dGBV algebras
Lemma 11.1.
The inclusion is a quasi-isomorphism.
Proof.
The operation becomes the Koszul complex, which is exact outside of (a small neighborhood of) the critical locus . □
To apply the Barannikov-Kontsevich construction to obtain a Frobenius manifold on the cohomology , a number of things are required:
- (1)
Hodge-to-de Rham degeneration at the page for the -adic filtration on (or the compactly supported version), where unfortunately both are bad. If this exists, then this is smooth formal in the sense of Barannikov-Kontsevich and therefore has a univeral period map (which would give us a -function allow us to write down the Frobenius structure);
- (2)
A trace pairing on polyvector fields which is compatible with and , which is required to write down a formula like
which of course works better for compactly supported polyvector fields;
- (3)
A compatible splitting
which is compatible with the trace pairing (and the higher residue pairing). This is usually referred to as a good basis.
Remark 11.2.
When has isolated critical points, the cohomology
and the Hodge-to-de Rham degeneration holds automatically.
To define the trace pairing, it is of course better to use .
Definition 11.3.
Define the trace pairing
Proposition 11.4.
We have the formulae
Corollary 11.5.
The trace pairing defines a pairing on cohomology given by
and the higher residue pairing
given by the formula
Remark 11.6.
Assume that has only an isolated critical point at the origin. Let be the standard volume form. Then we have
Then the trace pairing
is precisely the residue pairing, where we see that
A reference is the paper by Changzheng Li, the lecturer, and Kyoji Saito. In particular, if we write
then is the residue as just described, and all of the are called higher residues. Here, we should consider holomorphic functions as elements of .
Regarding the Hodge-to-de Rham degeneration issue, we can look at the various models:
- •
behaves well here, but is bad for the trace pairing;
- •
behaves well for the trace pairing, but is too small for the Hodge decomposition (for example harmonic functions are outside of this);
- •
If we consider polyvector fields, this works well for both the trace pairing and the Hodge decomposition, but is “bad” for non-linear structures (like products).
To solve these problems, we will introduce yet another model, which was introduced by the lecturer and Wen and are called adapted polyvector fields. It will sit as
and will have integration, the Hodge decomposition, and non-linear structures (products) all be well-behaved. It is given by
Definition 11.7.
The data (here is a complete Kähler metric) is called a bounded Calabi-Yau geometry if is a bounded geometry (namely a complete Riemannian manifold, all derivatives of curvature are bounded, and positive injectivity radius), and all covariant derivatives of and are bounded.
Definition 11.8.
Let be a bounded geometry. A holomorphic function is strongly elliptic if for all and , then as approaches the boundary.
Example 11.9.
Here are some examples which fall into this setup:
- (1)
Let and be the standard flat metric. Next, let be a non-degenerate quasi-homogeneous polynomial. This is mirror to FJRW theory and the full mirror theorem holds by the work of Li-Li-Saito-Shen and He-Li-Shen-Webb.
- (2)
Let , be the standard metric, and be a convenient non-degenerate Laurent polynomial (here the origin lies in the interior of the Newton polytope). This is mirror to toric varieties;
- (3)
Let be a crepant resolution for is a finite subgroup and be an ALE metric. The superpotential is given by which is -invariant. This is the orbifold Landau-Ginzburg B-model. Note here, that the superpotential lifts as
Theorem 11.10 (Li-Wen).
Let be a bounded Calabi-Yau geometry and be holomorphic and strongly elliptic with compact critical locus.
- (1)
The data forms a dGBV algebra with the trace pairing and Hodge-to-de Rham degeneration holds;
- (2)
The inclusions are all quasi-isomorphisms. In particular, Hodge-to-de Rham degeneration holds for as well.
- (3)
(Poincaré duality) The trace map induces
this is non-degenerate, and generalizes Saito’s higher residue pairing.
The upshot is that a Frobenius manifold structure can be constructed on the cohomology .
Remark 11.11.
There is an algebraic approach based on positive characteristic methods, including the work of Sabbah, Ogus-Vologodsky, Esnault-Sabbah-Yu, and Katzarkov-Kontsevich-Pantev.
12 Open-closed B-model
So far, we have discussed the B-model closed string field. This leads to a generalized version of BCOV theory, which was developed by Costello and the lecturer. We will now discuss the open-closed B-model. As a reminder, Witten in 1992 gave two models of the open string field theory.
- •
The A-model open string field is Chern-Simons theory with instanton corrections;
- •
The B-model open string field is holomorphic Chern-Simons theory.
Let be a Calabi-Yau threefold and be a holomorphic vector bundle on . The space of fields will be
and the action (in the BV formalism) is given by
If we decompose
where , then is the ghost, is the gauge (physical) field, is the anti-field, and is the anti-ghost. For the physical field , the equation of motion is
which says that if we set , then , meaning defines a new holomorphic vector bundle structure on . This is what is meant when it is said that holomorphic Chern-Simons theory describes the moduli of holomorphic vector bundles.
The space is -shifted symplectic with the symplectic form
The shifted Poisson kernel is given by
and defines a BV bracket for local functionals . Holomorphic Chern-Simons theory satisfies the classical master equation
If we write (the BRST transformation), then we obtain
and this implies that . Equivalently, this says that is a dg Lie algebra.
A bit more universally, embed as a subbundle for some sufficiently ample line bundle . This allows us to represent by some idempotent matrix
by choosing a smooth splitting. Using this, we write , and then we can embed
Here, must be very large, so we will consider the behavior as . We will focus on
and look for functionals on which have a stable expression when . We will call these admissible functionals.
Example 12.1.
The functional
is admissible.
We will now study the large limit from the perspective of large duality. For , we can write
Unlike ordinary Chern-Simons theory (which only allows us to tune the coupling constant), holomorphic Chern-Simons has many degrees of freedom to deform. One deformation is to deform the Calabi-Yau structure, and in fact this gives all deformations. Consider a first order deformation
where is an admissible local functional. The first-order classical master equation says that
is the local dual of Lie algebra homology
where the differential is and the Lie bracket is given by . This looks hard to compute, but in fact there is a way to compute it.
Theorem 12.2 (Loday-Quillen-Tsygan).
The large limit of the Lie algebra homology is given by
Here, is called cyclic homology.
Applying this to our model, we obtain
by the Hochschild-Kostant-Rosenberg theorem (use ). By the trace pairing, this is local dual to
Therefore, the BCOV field (topological gravity) is the single trace operator at (this is also related to the AdS/CFT correspondence) in the gauge/gravity duality.
Example 12.3.
Suppose . This gives a first-order deformation
which is in fact another way to express the HKR theorem.
Example 12.4.
If we include descendents to make , then (see Figure 12)
A general formula for higher order deformations at the disk level is given by Calaque-Willwacher’s cyclic extension of Kontsevich formality (see Figure 13). This is called a Poisson -model with formulae given by
We will now discuss the open-closed master equation. We are interested in distributions
where is the genus and is the number of boundary components.
Zwiebach’s open-closed master equation requires to satisfy equations based on , which are various degenerations.
Example 12.5.
At the disk level with and , the boundary is in Figure 15 and the corresponding equation is
This is in fact Kontsevich formality.
Example 12.6.
Now suppose and . Then the boundary is given in Figure 16 and the corresponding equation is
Example 12.7.
In the case of an annulus with and , the boundary is given in Figure 17 and the corresponding equation is
The term is the one-loop gauge anomaly, and is cancelled out by the tree-level closed string sector via the Green-Schwarz mechanism.
Theorem 12.8 (Costello-Li).
On , start with:
- •
Holomorphic Chern-Simons theory on . This is necessary because , but .
- •
A first order deformation.
There exists a canonical quantization for all which satisfies the open-closed master equation.
Remark 12.9.
These quantizations glue to any local Calabi-Yau with a non-trivial -action.
Remark 12.10.
The open-closed B-model which is BCOV coupled to holomorphic Chern-Simons theory is UV finite on any Calabi-Yau manifold (assumed to be Kähler).