Algebraic topology I
Algebraic Topology
Fall 2020
Notes by Patrick Lei
Lectures by Mohammed Abouzaid
Columbia University
Disclaimer
These notes were taken during lecture using the vimtex package of the editor neovim. Any errors are mine and not the instructor’s. In addition, my notes are picture-free (but will include commutative diagrams) and are a mix of my mathematical style and that of the instructor. If you find any errors, please contact me at plei@math.columbia.edu.
1 Basics of Homotopy Theory
1.1 Categorical Notions
We will use the book Algebraic Topology by Tammo tom Dieck. We will use categorical language, even if we don’t strictly need it. We will denote the category of (Hausdorff) topological spaces and continuous maps by . There are two ways of thinking about algebraic topology:
- 1.
Extracting algebraic invariants from spaces;
- 2.
Doing algebra with spaces.
Homotopy is an equivalence relation on .
Definition 1.1.1.
A homotopy from to is a map such that and . Intuitively, this is a way to interpolate between and . Alternatively, a homotopy is a path in with the compact-open topology.
To show that homotopy is an equivalence relation, it is easy to show that is self-homotopic. To see that homotopy is symmetric, we can simply reverse the interval. Finally, to see that homotopy is transitive, we can just perform each homotopy twice as fast and then concatenate.
Definition 1.1.2.
The homotopy category is the category whose objects are spaces and whose morphisms are homotopy classes of maps. We need to check that composition preserves the notion of homotopy.
Now denote the category of based spaces by , where a based space is a space with a map . The corresponding homotopy category is denoted by . Here, the homotopy is required to fix the basepoint.
Remark 1.1.3.
The transition from spaces to based spaces is like upgrading from semigroups to monoids.
Remark 1.1.4.
There is a functor
Example 1.1.5.
It is easy to see that . Similarly, . Then, we can see that is the set of path components of .
1.2 Fundamental Group and Groupoid
Example 1.2.1.
We will now consider morphisms from the circle. The set is the free loop space . In the based case, we get the based loop space . Then is the path components of , and similarly, , where is the fundamental group.
It should be surprising that is a group. In fact, it is independent on the path component of up to inner automorphism. However, we can distinguish a class of isomorphisms up to conjugation. The identity of this group is the constant path at the basepoint. Next, we need to consider the product in the group. This is simply concatenation, which is given by the (cogroup) operation . Because the two components of the wedge cannot be swapped by a homotopy, this operation is not commutative.
Next, we need to check that this is compatible with homotopy. Then the operation on homotopy classes is the product in . To check associativity, we can check that the total operation of pinching at and pinching at commutes.
Finally, the inverse of a path is simply . To construct an isomorphism between and , choose a path between the two basepoints and then send .
We will now discuss an unbased analogue of the fundamental group. Beginning with the path space , we can consider the evaluations at and . Then over , can consider homotopy classes of maps with fixed endpoints to obtain the set .
Proposition 1.2.2.
are the morphisms of a groupoid with objects .
Remark 1.2.3.
. The fundamental group is much nicer, but is hard to compute because it depends on the basepoint.
Definition 1.2.4.
A homotopy equivalence is a map that induces an isomorphism in the homotopy category.
Proposition 1.2.5.
A homotopy equivalence induces an equivalence of categories . Recall here that an equivalence of categories is a fully faithful and essentially surjective functor. Equivalently, it is a functor has an inverse up to natural isomorphism.
Proof.
The homotopy defines a natural transformation from to . Let be a homotopy inverse, and be a homotopy and let be a homotopy from to . We can evaluate on the path , and this gives a homotopy between and . Therefore, we have equality up to homotopy, so this gives a natural transformation. Because we are working in a groupoid, this is automatically an isomorphism. □
Corollary 1.2.6.
Homotopy equivalences induce isomorphisms of fundamental groups.
Suppose we have a diagram of the form
| (1.1) |
Then a pushout is the colimit of this diagram. This means that there exist maps such that
| (1.2) |
commutes and is universal: For any and commutative diagram, there exists a unique map such that
| (1.3) |
commutes.
Theorem 1.2.7 (Seifert-van Kampen Theorem).
Let be a topological space and subspaes whose interiors cover . Then set . Then
| (1.4) |
is a pushout diagram of groupoids.
Proof.
Consider a groupoid and commutative diagram
| (1.5) |
We will construct . Then we need to write as an object of . If , set , and if , set . Because (1.5) commutes, this is well-defined. Now we define on the level of morphisms. Subdivide paths so that all segments lie in either or . Then on each such segment, the diagram specifies , and define .
Finally, we need to prove that this definition is independent of the choice of representative of homotopy class. We can subdivide the homotopy so each equare lies in either or , and then are well-defined, so is independent of the homotopy class. □
Example 1.2.8.
We can use Seifert-van Kampen to compute the fundamental group of . If we choose to be two arcs, then is homotopy equivalent to two points. Then computing combinatorially, we can recover .
Corollary 1.2.9 (Standard statement of Seivert-van Kampen).
For connected , we obtain a pushout diagram in the category of groups.
1.3 Covering Spaces
Definition 1.3.1.
Let be a topological space. Then is a covering map if it is locally trivial with discrete fiber.
Example 1.3.2.
Consider . Another covering map to with fiber is the projection .
Proposition 1.3.3.
Every covering of is trivial.
Proof.
Let . Then over , we can trivialize the cover. Because is compact, we can choose a finite cover over which is trivial. By indexing the and removing the unnecessary ones, we can assume if and only if . By induction, we want to extend the trivialization on the first elements of the cover to the union with . The trivialization gives us an isomorphism for all , so if , we the local trivialization to obtain an isomorphism for all . Then compose . The procedure terminates by compactness. □
To generalize this result to contractible spaces, we need more tools. The limit of the diagram
| (1.6) |
is called the pullback.
Lemma 1.3.4.
The pullback of a cover is a cover.
Proof.
If is trivial over , then is trivial over . □
Lemma 1.3.5.
A homotopy induces an isomorphism of covers
| (1.7) |
Proof.
Use the idea of the proof in the case of the interval. We can transport the fibers from to , so this gives a homeomorphism. □
Corollary 1.3.6.
If is contractible, all covers are trivial.
Proof.
Then choose and to be constant at . Then we obtain a homeomorphism between and . □
Corollary 1.3.7.
If is a cover, then the assignment defines a functor .
Definition 1.3.8.
A cover is a universal cover if there exists to such that is isomorphic to the functor (equivalently if is representable).
Lemma 1.3.9.
If is locally simply connected and path connected, then the universal cover exists.
Proof.
We will build the space by equipping with a topology. We want locally that is homeomorphic to . At every point , we can choose which is path connected and simply connected. In , there is a canonical isomorphism because between any two points, there is a unique homotopy class of paths between them. This determines the topology. □
Note, is a principal bundle over . In particular, the map is equivariant over and is isomorphic to .
Now we will give a classification of coverings. Assume the universal cover exists. Then there exists a bijection between the following data:
- 1.
Coverings up to isomorphism.
- 2.
Functors up to isomorphism.
- 3.
Actions of on a set up to isomorphism.
Proof.
The bijection between 1 and 2 is given by the transport functor. Between 2 and 3, we simply restrict the functor to a single object. Finally, we can consider the associated bundle . □
Definition 1.3.10.
A cover is regular if there exists a norma subgroup of such that .
This implies that is a principal -bundle for a quotient of , and in fact this is an equivalence.
How do we recognize the universal cover? Let be a cover. Fix basepoints and consider the map .
- Homotopy Lifting Property:
-
Consider two paths in with the same endpoints. Then if we consider the diagram
(1.8) there is a unique such that the entire diagram commutes.
To prove this, we can consider the pullback , which is a cover of , which is trivial. This property implies the map on is injective.
- Transport:
-
The transport of defines a map and the “kernel” agrees with . The inclusion of in the kernel comes from the homotopy lifting property, and in the other direction, any loop that lifts to a path taking to itself must have come from a loop.
- Components of the cover:
-
If is path connected, then .
To see this, we will map induced by the inclusion . To check that this is well-defined, note that each lifts to a path between two points of . To check surjectivity, choose and the projection. Choose a path from to and then transport from the fiber at to . To show injectivity, we simply use the homotopy lifting property. If are points in lying in the same component of , we can project the path to .
Corollary 1.3.11.
If is locally simply connected and path connected, then a universal cover of is characterized by being simply connected.
Proof.
The lemma shows that . Thus . □
Now it is easy to check that is a universal cover and that any Riemann surface of genus is for a finite group .
1.3.1 Existence of lifts
Suppose we have a diagram
| (1.9) |
with path connected.
Theorem 1.3.12.
A lift exists if and only if .
Proof.
Define . We want to extend this to all . If is a path from to , is a path in with endpoint at . Then we lift to a path in starting at , and the other endpoint of this path is defined to be .
We need to check that this is well-defined. If we choose a different path , we can form a loop . Because this loop lifts to a loop, is well-defined. Continuity is checked by local trivialization. □
2 Understanding the Homotopy Category
One problem in algebraic topology is that various constructions in are not homotopy invariant. For example, consider the diagram
| (2.1) |
The pushout of this diagram is simply a point. However, if we replace the point by , then the pushout becomes . This is not homotopy equivalent to a point (for example, compute the cohomology), but we have not developed enough tools in the class to see it. We will now discuss homotopy limits and colimits.
2.1 Homotopy Pushouts
Consider a map . To make this map nicer so we can perform various constructions, we will define the mapping cylinder, which is the pushout
| (2.2) |
Note that the inclusion is a homotopy equivalence by pushing the onto . In addition, if we have a commutative diagram
| (2.3) |
Then this induces a map by doing at the top and at the bottom. If the diagram only commutes up to homotopy, then fix a homotopy between and . This induces a map of mapping cylinders by at the top, in the middle, and at the bottom. Thus the construction of the mapping cylinder is functorial in the homotopy category.
Theorem 2.1.1.
If and are homotopy equivalences, then is a homotopy equivalences.
Proof.
Choose homotopy inverses . We need to construct the correct homotopy inverse to . We will set to be the space shown in Figure 2.1.
Here, is a homotopy from to and is defined analogously. Then the three components are first , then , and finally .
Finally, it is easy to check that the piecewise homotopies agree at the boundaries. □
Remark 2.1.2.
This is not a true inverse! However, they are homotopic.
The mapping cylinder generalizes to a double mapping cylinder for spans .
Lemma 2.1.3.
If the diagram
| (2.4) |
homotopy commutes, then we can fit the mapping cylinder into the diagram with an arrow . However, this arrow depends on the choice of homotopy.
Definition 2.1.4.
is a homotopy pushout of the diagram in the previous lemma if is a homotopy equivalence.
Note this is not unique in , but is unique in .
Example 2.1.5.
Consider the projections . Then a homotopy pushout is the join .
Example 2.1.6.
The homotopy pushout of is the unreduced suspension .
Then recall the reduced suspension . Then this is related to another familiar construction. The key fact is
This tells us that the suspension and loop space functors are adjoint. Also note that concatenation makes into an H-space , which is a monoid in .
Concretely, concatenation is homotopy associative and is a (pointed) homotopy unit. Therefore, is a group. To see this from the point of , we see that is a comonoid. The map is simply given by collapsing .
Consider the diagram
| (2.5) |
Then we have a series of maps . Then define . We now have a map . We will use the mapping cone to replace the quotient.
Lemma 2.1.7.
The sequence is exact at for any based space . In other words, the composition sends to the constant map .
Proof.
Given a map and a homotopy , construct by using the construction for the double mapping cylinder. □
Now we can extend to the left by considering the map given by collapsing . This gives us a diagram
Finally, we only need to check that and are coexact. To check this, note that is homotopy equivalent to and the other one is easy.
Corollary 2.1.8.
For each space , we have an exact sequence
If we extend to the left, we obtain abelian groups because the double loop space is a commutative H-space.
2.2 Homotopy Pullbacks
Now we will dualize everything and look for
The cone is a homotopy pushout, so we will define an analogous homotopy pullback for
| (2.6) |
This will be known as the homotopy fiber. In the usual category of , this is the actual fiber. To do this, we will replace the point by . This is contractible by retracting every path to , so we will define to be the pullback of the above diagram.
Lemma 2.2.1.
The sequence is exact.
Proof is given by using the interval direction to construct the map from to . In more words, we interpret a homotopy as a map . In addition, this lemma constructs a fiber sequence
which yields a long exact sequence
2.3 Fibrations and Cofibrations
Assume that is Hausdorff.
Definition 2.3.1.
A map is a cofibration if any diagram
| (2.7) |
admits a lift. This is called the homotopy extension property.
In other words, we can extend diagrams of the form
| (2.8) |
Proposition 2.3.2.
Pushouts preserve cofibrations. In other words, for a pushout
| (2.9) |
if is a cofibration, then so is .
Proof.
We will diagram chase. We construct the full diagram
| (2.10) |
Then the map exists by cofibrations, and then the arrow exists because is a pushout. □
This proof is completely formal, and we had no idea what is going on.
Example 2.3.3.
is a cofibration. To see this, note that we can identify with two sides of the square, and the retract the square onto the two sides of the interval. Note that two sides of the square form the mapping cylinder of .
Proposition 2.3.4.
is a cofibration if and only if it satisfies the homotopy extension property for .
Proof.
Suppose the lift exists. Then this induces a map . Then we can map and compose. □
Proposition 2.3.5.
is a cofibration if and only if it is a neighborhood deformation retract. This is defined by and wuch that
- 1.
.
- 2.
for all .
- 3.
If , then .
- 4.
.
The proof uses the previous criterion. The point is to deformation retract onto .
We want to be able to compute things, and we will start with cofibrant replacements. Because is a cofibration, so is for any . Then inclusion is a homotopy equivalence, so we can factor into a homotopy equivalence and a cofibration. Functoriality of the mapping cylinder was discussed previously.
Question 2.3.6.
Let be a homotopy equivalence such that are equipped with extra structure. Can the homotopy equivalence be made compatible with this extra structure?
Example 2.3.7.
Suppose live under a space . Then we can define a homotopy equivalence under .
Proposition 2.3.8.
If are cofibrations, then is a homotopy equivalence in if and only if it is a homotopy equivalence in .
Proof.
Let denote the homotopy inverse of . Then consider the space under . If we fix a homotopy , this induces an isomorphism . This is done by extending to by the homotopy extension property.
Note that is a transport map. If is a cofibration and is a homotopy. □
Proposition 2.3.9.
Let and be cofibrations. Then if and make the diagram commute, then is a homotopy equivalence of pairs if and only if and are both homotopy equivalences.
If we dualize everything, we replace by . Now we consider a map .
Definition 2.3.10.
A map is a Hurewicz fibration if all diagrams of the form
| (2.11) |
admit a lift. This is called the homotopy lifting property.
Definition 2.3.11.
A map is a Serre fibration if it satisfies the homotopy lifting property for all cubes.
Lemma 2.3.12.
Pullbacks preserve fibrations.
The test object we will use to study fibrations is the pullback .
Proposition 2.3.13.
is a hommotopy equivalence. In addition, is a fibration if and only if it has the homotopy lifting property for .
Now, let be an arbitrary map. Then we can factor as a fibration and a homotopy equivalence.
Example 2.3.14.
All covering maps are fibrations. Also, if is a cofibration, the dual is a fibration. Similarly, if is a fibration, then so is .
Now suppose is a homotopy equivalence of spaces over . Then if and are fibrations, is a homotopy equivalence in if and only if it is a homotopy equivalence in .
2.4 Homotopy Groups
Let be a based space.
Definition 2.4.1.
The -th homotopy group of is
Definition 2.4.2.
Given a pair of based spaces, the -th relative homotopy group is
where . Here, the source triple is homotopy equivalent to .
We will attempt to develop some tools to compute homotopy groups. Let
By splitting and using the suspension-loop adjunction, we obtain
Therefore the relative homotopy group is the set of components of the -th loop space of . The loop space appears in the fiber exact sequence, and is simply the homotopy fiber of , so if we set , we obtain from the long exact sequence
the exact sequence of homotopy groups
which becomes
Warning 2.4.3.
The relative homotopy group is not the same as the homotopy group of the quotient.
Here, we were very sloppy with basepoints and all of our homotopy groups should have carried basepoints. Last time, we showed that a homotopy induces a transport map
if is a cofibration. Applying this to , we obtain a transport .
Proposition 2.4.4.
The assignment defines a functor . If , the target of the functor can be replaced with .
Corollary 2.4.5.
- 1.
Up to some isomorphism, the -th homotopy group is invariant of the choice of basepoint. The choice is not canonical unless acts trivially.
- 2.
If is a homotopy equivalence, then the induced map on homotopy groups is an isomorphism.
- 3.
acts naturally on .
Now suppose is a fibration. Then the homotopy fiber is homotopy equivalent to the actual fiber , so the relative homotopy groups of in are isomorphic to the homotopy groups of the base. To construct an explicit map , we begin with a sphere in . Then we use the homotopy lifting property to obtain a disc in with boundary in .
It is easy to see the following:
- 1.
If is contractible, then for all .
- 2.
The argument we gave for for also shows that for . To see this, consider . First, we can find a homotopic map which is smooth and transverse to . This implies the image lies in if , so is nullhomotopic because is contractible.
- 3.
If is a covering map, then is an isomorphism for . To see this, we use the lifting property for maps
because .
As an example, this allows us to compute , and for because the universal cover is contractible.
- 4.
Consider the Hopf fibration . Applying the long exact sequence, we have
and observe that .
We would naively expect that for , but this is incorrect. However, it is true that . For higher homotopy groups, it is easy to see that an analog of the Seifert-van Kampen theorem does not hold. If we write , then and both have trivial , but does not.
What does hold is Blakers-Massey. Assume that , where the are open. Suppose that is nonempty. Then we have a map
called the excision.
Theorem 2.4.6 (Blakers-Massey).
Assume that is -connected and is -connected. Then excision is an isomorphism in degree and surjective in degree . This means that excision is -connected as a map of pairs.
Note that a pair is -connected if for . This is equivalent to for and .
Now we can prove that . First consider . Then we have a long exact sequence
and we see that . We now apply excision for . To see that excision is an isomorphism, use the Hopf fibration.
In the next dimension, we use the same computation to see that and the pairs are -connected. Then the map is -connected, so .
Theorem 2.4.7.
If and are and -connected, then is connected. Here, are paths such that , .
This implies Blakers-Massey by taking the fiber over . Note that the homotopy fiber of is
Then using the long exact sequence of homotopy groups, we obtain the desired result.
The key idea is that if is a family of paths, then generically, the subfamily of paths which intersect the origin in has dimension . To see this, appeal to the fact that locally is a manifold and then use Sard’s theorem. If a path is not in , then we can retract it to “radially” in . Such a path lies in .
If our path lies in , then we have a dimension locus passing through . If , then the dimension is negative, so it is empty. Thus generically, every path misses either or . Then we can retract to . But then we can move the basepoint along back to , so we retract to
We will ignore the details needed to make this precise. To handle the general case, we simply need to consider the case where an arbitrary number of cells are attached and then use CW approximation.
Here are some applications of Blakers-Massey:
Corollary 2.4.8.
Say is a cofibration. Then suppose is -connected and is connected. Then is connected.
Proof.
Take the mapping cylinder . Cover this by . Then is -connected if and only if is -connected. Using the fact that is connected, we use Blakers-Massey to obtain the desired result. □
Corollary 2.4.9 (Freudenthal).
Assume is well-pointed and connected. Then is an isomorphism for and is surjective for .
Proof.
Note that . The only thing we need to check is that the map from Blakers-Massey is the same as the suspension map. □
Corollary 2.4.10.
If is -connected and is -connected, then is connected.
Proof.
Note that . We need to understand . But then , so
Then using excision to compute in the range, we obtained the desired result. □
In the text, there is more discussion of the homotopy groups of , which has as its universal cover. Then if we take the colimit of
and obtain , this has trivial homotopy. We can prove this by noting that is contractible.
We can also consider the action of on . We then obtain a fiber sequence . Then we can use induction to compute the difference between and . For , the groups are isomorphic. Then we consider the colimit
to obtain the group with periodic homotopy groups by Bott periodicity. We can do the same computation for the unitary group.
3 CW Complexes and Homology
3.1 -Spaces
Recall that whenever are locally compact, then we have the adjunction
We want this to always hold, so we will need to study infinite complexes. For example, an infinite wedge of circles is not locally compact. Our solution will be to change the topology on and on .
Definition 3.1.1.
is a -space if, for all , if is closed for all with compact Hausdorff, then is closed.
Now we define a functor . Here, is as a set with closed sets those such that closed for all continuous in the original topology. Because has more closed sets than , then we have a natural transformation between and the identity.
Proposition 3.1.2.
is a -space if and only if the following hold: Any map is continuous if and only if is continuous for all with compact Hausdorff.
Let be the full subcategory of -spaces.
Theorem 3.1.3.
Products exists in .
Theorem 3.1.4.
We have the adjunction
We did all of this because non locally compact spaces show up relative naturally.
3.2 Simplicial Complexes
A simplicial complex is a set with a collection of finite subsets such that for all .
Letting , then we have natural maps .
Definition 3.2.1.
The geometric realization of a simplicial compex is the space
where is the equivalence defined by the maps above.
If we have a homeomorphism , then this is said to be a trianglation of . All smooth manifolds can be triangulated.
This is very rigid, which is bad for homotopy theory, so we give an alternative viewpoint. Let , where is the subsets of size at most . This is called the -skeleton, so the geometric realization induces the simplices of dimension at most . Then we have a pushout
Lemma 3.2.2.
.
To prove this, we check that the topology agrees. Unfortunately, the maps from simplices are too rigid, so to derigidify, we will relax the notion of the attaching maps.
3.3 CW complexes
Definition 3.3.1.
A CW decomposition of a space is a filtration such that we have pushouts
Remark 3.3.2.
Let . We obtain a decomposition as a set
where is the image of in .
A key property is that if is compact, then intersects only finitely many cells. To see this, note that for some . Then lies in an infinite union of disks, so it must intersect finitely many of them.
Remark 3.3.3.
The abbreviation CW stands for closure-finite (C) and weak topology (W).
Definition 3.3.4.
A CW decomposition of a pair is a filtration where and is given as a pushout
Here, the cell attachment happens in dimension .
If , we have a CW decomposition of . Then we say that if all cells have at most that dimension. Now there are two ideas for working with CW-complexes.
- 1.
Suppose is a map. If is a relative CW complex, we want to extend to . The obstruction is as follows. Say we only have one cell. Then defines an element of , and this vanishes if and only if an extension exists. If has more cells, then proceed by induction (we have a sequence of obstructions, and we need them all to vanish).
- 2.
(Cellularity) Say that is -connected. If is a CW complex and is a map with , then is homotopic to some with .
To prove this, use induction. We know that have the same components, so we may deform so that maps to (use the transport with a cofibration). Then each -cell of determines an element of , so we can make map to .
Here are some consequences:
- 1.
If for all and is a relative CW complex which is -connected, then . Note all obstructions to the extension vanish.
- 2.
Say is an -connected map. If is a CW complex, then is an isomorphism if and a surjection if . Here, use the mapping cylinder to reduce to the case of an inclusion and then note that obstructions vanish.
Remark 3.3.5.
Conditions on of the target are in some sense dual to the source having no cell in a given dimension (replace this by vanishing cohomology).
We can now let (i.e. a weak homotopy equivaence).
Proposition 3.3.6.
A map of CW complexes is a homotopy equivalence if and only if is an isomorphism for all .
Proof.
For any -connected , we have an isomorphism . Then if we let , note that and choose an inverse fo . Alternatively, this is just the Yoneda Lemma. □
Remark 3.3.7.
If , then we only need to check for .
Remark 3.3.8.
If it not true that CW complexes are determined up to homotopy equivalence by their homotopy groups. The counterexample is and , but to prove this, we need to use cohomology.
Proposition 3.3.9.
For any space there exists a CW complex and a map which is a weak homotopy equivalence. This is not a homotopy equivalence in general (see the pseudocircle from the homework), but for a manifold, it is a homotopy equivalence.
Proof.
By induction on , we want which is -connected. Using the mapping cylinder, we can assume that . Consider . Define as the result of attaching discs to indexed by a basis of this group. Extend the map to and use the long exact sequence to see that is connected. To see that we can extend, note that we have the diagram
Then we can extend from the disk by using the associated element of . Now we have a diagram
Then we can show that the left middle arrow is surjective, and then by surjectivity of the whole diagram, we see that the desired arrow is surjective. □
Now we give a useful computation. Suppose that for all and that is a -connected CW complex. Then .
Surjectivity is easy (use lemma about ). To prove injectivity, we sill reduce to being the cone of , by assumption, , so is a suspension. Then we have a sequence of groups
Then we use Blakers-Massey to prove exactness and then obtain the desired result.
3.4 Eilenberg-Maclane Spaces
Now recall that the universal cover satisfies
- 1.
- 2.
if .
We want to generalize this to a general procedure (-connected cover), which will be a fibration, but not a covering space.
Given a space and integer , let be the result of attaching cells to kill for . This means that for and otherwise.
Example 3.4.1.
There exists a space with .
Let be a group and .
Definition 3.4.2.
A CW complex is a if
The key fact is that is unique up to homotopy equivalence by a previous lemma. To show existence, we will present as a quotient of (free if , free abelian if ). Then consider the cone of . The is correct by Blakers-Massey, so we simply kill the higher homotopy groups.
Now there is an additive structure on the . If is abelian, then addition is a homomorphism . This gives a natural map , but , so we see that is a commutative -space. We have a diagram
Then because the two rightmost arrows come from the same map , we see that this diagram homotopy commutes.
Remark 3.4.3.
In fact, we can make into a commutative group. It is also possible to show that these are the only abelian groups in .
Now we will consider multiplicative structure. By excision, note that is connected. To compute , look at the and skeleta. We get that
where the wedge of smashes comes from the relations of and comes from the generators. This gives us a map to .
If is a ring, then we obtain a map , which makes a graded ring.
3.5 Eilenberg-Steenrod Axioms
Definition 3.5.1.
A homology theory is a functor
and natural transformation such that
- 1.
is homotopy invariant.
- 2.
There is a long exact sequence
- 3.
(Excision) If , then is an isomorphism.
To produce such , we can let be a based space. Then set . Then both of the first two axioms are clear, and the long exact sequence comes from the cofiber sequence. Unfortunately, excision is false because Blakers-Masset does not hold in general. However, it does hold in some range, and so we can extend this range by suspending everything. Thus the groups stabilize, and are stably isomorphic to .
Definition 3.5.2.
For any space , the homology theory is
Remark 3.5.3.
The connecting map is just the boundary map for the pair . Alternatively, we can produce a boundary map that commutes with the arrows to . However, we have a sequence . If , then we obtain stable homotopy. This is easier to compute than ordinary homotopy, but is still mysterious.
Unfortunately, ordinary homology is not an for some . Instead, we have spaces and map4 , which form a prespectrum. In this setting, define
Then we have , so we only need to do this for spaces. Unfortunately, these homotopy groups do not stabilize in general, and thus we need additional assumptions to get excision.
Example 3.5.4.
Let be an abelian group. Recall we have . Thus we have . This is now adjoint to a map .
For example, if , we have , , and . Next, for , we have and is obtained from by attaching a -cell that is twice the generator of and then attaching -cells to kill higher homotopy, and thus we have .
Thus for every abelian group we have a homology theory
where is a cofibration.
To construct the boundary map, we use the map , where and thus we have the boundary map
and maps . To see the middle isomorphism is really an isomorphism, we know that is -connected and thus the homotopy groups stabilize. To establish excision, we simply use Blakers-Massey. Then the homology theories associated to prespectra satisfy additional properties:
- 5.
(Additivity) Homology preserves coproducts, that is,
This follows from additivity of stable homotopy groups.
- 6.
Weak homotopy equivalences induce isomorphisms on homology. This follows from the homework problem we were unable to solve (smash of weak equivalences is a weak equivalence).
- 7.
(Dimension) if and vanishes otherwise.
Remark 3.5.5.
Cohomology satisfies the additivity axiom with the direct sum replaced by a direct product. If we take the “dual” to cohomology, then we should obtain the dual to the product, and this is clearly not a direct sum. To see failure of weak homotopy equivalence, this fails because spaces can be nasty (like the topologist’s sine curve circle).
Our long term goal is to show that any homology theory satisfying all six axioms is represented by . Our first computation is that
Now from the axioms, we consider . Because this is contractible, we see that and that we have a long exact sequence
Then we have and then the map on the left is given by and the map on the right is the sum of the two projections. Thus we have proceeding by induction.
Next, we will define the reduced homology groups by . Then looking at the diagram
we get that the bottom row is exact. Then if is a cofibration, then we can write . This follows from the long exact sequence on for
Corollary 3.5.6.
Suppose is a triple. Then the sequence
is exact.
Proof.
If we take the quotient by and then use reduced homology. If the inclusion of is not a cofibration, then replace everything with the mapping cone. □
This is a key ingredient in the proof of Mayer-Vietoris. In fact, we can go further with homology. We have a natural map that sends to the map induced by . This is clearly a homomorphism, so first we recall that addition in is induced by . But then we have and so the map is addition. Now, er know that maps to , so by linearity, goes to multiplication by .
Corollary 3.5.7.
If , then the map is an isomorphism.
We should caution that is not an isomorphism.
Now assume that . We want to compute given . We do this if and are open. Here, by excision on , and so we have a long exact sequence
Theorem 3.5.8 (Mayer-Vietoris).
The sequence is exact.
Proof.
Let . Then we have using excision. Now we have homotopy equivalences , so , and thus the long-exact sequence
for relative groups gives us the desired result. □
Now note that for unbased spaces, additivity tells us that
for arbitrary indexing sets. If the indexing set is finite, then this is a consequence of excision, because in the long exact sequence
we have and the sequence splits because we have the map . Thus Mayer-Vietoris does not depend on additivity.
Remark 3.5.9.
There is a relative version of this. For , we have a long exact sequence
To prove this, we can collapse when it is a cofibration and then replace it by a cofibration when it is not.
Example 3.5.10.
Now we will compute the homology of lens spaces. Recall that
is the quotient of the sphere by the action of with weights . Note that if , then this action is not free and has fixed points for . Freeness is needed to ensure the quotient is a manifold.
Now we decompose as a neighborhood of and , where our neighborhoods look like . We can choose this to be invariant under by taking invariant tubular neighborhoods. Then the intersection is a copy of , which is explicitly the set of points with equal norm.
This gives us a decomposition of the quotient as and . Now the factor of is a curve in and the factor of is a curve in . Here, a curve is simply a line of slope in the square. The asymmetry comes from the choice of identification of with .
Finally, we compute and by covering the torus with two halves, and now we can use Mayer-Vietoris to compute
and then this becomes
This tells us that , so we now have the exact sequence
We simply need to compute the middle map, coming from . This is injective, so and .
This leads us to the following question: All of these spaces for a fixed have the same homology. Are they homeomorphic? In fact, they are homotopy equivalent, but they are not homeomorphic (although proving they are not diffeomorphic is easier).
Now we want to compute homology for colimits. Consider a sequence of space . We now have a map . If we assume is a cofibration, we can consider the mapping cylinder. The inclusion of the mapping cylinder in is a homotopy equivalence relative to . Iterating this, we can simply stack all of the mapping cylinders on top of each other to form the mapping telescope . The key fact is that this is a homotopy equivalence. More generally, if we consider any sequence of maps
we can similarly define the mapping telescope . Then we have a map , where we send .
Theorem 3.5.11.
The map is an isomorphism.
The idea is that the diagram
commutes up to homotopy.
Remark 3.5.12.
We should think of as the “homotopy colimit” of the diagram , and thus we obtain the slogan that homology commutes with (homotopy) colimits.
If additivity fails, then this is false for the sequence
where . In fact, additivity is equivalent to commuting with homotopy colimits.
Proof.
Consider the decomposition given by
Then additivity tells us that
but analyzing the pieces tells us that this becomes
Finally, we obtain . Now by Mayer-Vietoris, we have an exact sequence
and then we obtain that is the cokernel of . □
Going back to the case of cofibrations, we obtain
Corollary 3.5.13.
If and is a cofibration, then .
This can be used to compute the homology of .
3.6 Cellular Homology
Let be a homology and a CW complex. We will consider the relative homology groups . We have a diagram
of degree and thus we can attempt to form a chain complex.
Proposition 3.6.1.
.
Proof.
If we paste two such diagrams together to obtain
then the sequence is the long exact sequence of the pair and thus we obtain a chain complex. This is a bounded complex if and only if has cells in only finitely many dimensions. □
This gives us a chain complex
As for how this is related to , this is simply the “first page of the spectral sequence” which computes such homology. Also, this makes sense for any filtered space because we have not used any information about CW complexes. Now consider the case when satisfies the dimension axiom, which says that is supported in degree .
Theorem 3.6.2.
If satisfies the dimension axiom, then the complex defined in the previous proposition computes . This means .
Proof.
We prove this by inducting on the dimension of . Note this requires additivity, which is the same thing as homology commuting with homotopy colimits. The base case is simple:
Now assume that the complex
computes . Now recall that we have the long exact sequence
and so now we need to understand the connecting map . In the cell complex, this only interacts with . Thus we need to know that the long exact sequence only changes in two degrees. We use the isomorphism
unless , where is the set of -cells. Here, the final isomorphism comes from the dimension axiom. Thus if and .
For , we simply see that
because by the inductive hypothesis. For , we have the diagram
Then we have . This is clearly isomorphic to . □
In order to compute this, we need to understand the map . Denote the set of -cells by and the set of -cells by . Then we have
Here, if is an abelian group, is the chain complex shifted in degree by . In addition, we have
The attaching map gives rise to of degree . Note this choice relies on orienting all of the cells. Then the matrix computes the map , which is really
This formula also arises from the study of the compatibility of homology with suspension. Now we define the chain complex to be the free -module given by the -cells of . The differential is simply the degrees of all attaching maps.
Exercise 3.6.3.
Directly prove that by analyzing .
In fact, the differential is always given by the matrix defined above, and this implies uniqueness of homology theories on spaces which are homotopy equivalent to CW complexes.
Now if is a cellular map, then we obtain maps and these are maps of complexes. These are again given by the degree. (Note that all maps are homotopic to cellular maps). Now the problem is to compute the maps from the cellular point of view. If we consider the commutative diagram
then we see that the map is given by the degrees of the maps of cells and thus all maps are axiomatically determined. Thus is determined axiomatically as a functor, not just as a group.
Example 3.6.4.
Consider . Then all differentials vanish because the attaching map to is the element and thus the map is . In degree , the loop in the fundamental square is still and thus we have the same map. Thus, we have
The same analysis works for both and for higher genus surfaces .
3.7 Simplicial Homology
Simplicial homology is one of the original versions of homology. Let be a partially ordered set and be a subset of such that for all and , then and all are totally ordered. Thus we can write as an -simplex. Then let be its geometric realization. Now define to be the free -module generated by -simplices. Note that attaching maps in this case all have degree because they are linear, and this is why we choose orientations using a partial order. The differential is given by
This is a very old and famous formula. The is simply here to keep track of orientations. Also, we can consider as a CW complex and then the CW and simplicial chain complexes are the same. Then we can collapse the skeleton to obtain a wedge of spheres, and then we have maps of degree . The sign is determined by the orientation, where we will consider clockwise to be the standard orientation. For example, consider a single -simplex as in Figure 3.1.
Now if is a map of “simplicial sets,” then we get maps . We can try to compute , and this is determined by the cell complex, which is the same as the simplicial complex. Suppose . Then if , either all are distinct, in which , or we have and then we set .
(Here, commutes with or the map from factors through and hence the quotient factors through a point.)
Now if is a simplicial complex, we can consider the groups . The first is small, the second is medium, and the last is large. Then there is no differential for and the cellular differentials are hard to compute, but the simplicial differentials are very easy to compute.1
Now we can define a very weak invariant from homology: the Euler characteristic
If is defined, it is in fact independent of . It is very easy to compute this for Riemann surfaces. For finite CW complexes, is given by the alternating sum of the number of -cells.
3.8 Singular Homology
We will define the complex of singular chains for any space . We will see that this is functorial and that is a homology theory. If has the homotopy type of a CW complex, we get the same result as for cellular homology. This satisfies the dimension axiom and is ordinary homology.
Let be the free abelian group generated by maps . First, we identify
We can now think of this as a convex polytope in Euclidean space, and it is thus the convex hull of the vertices . Next, we define given by induced by skipping the -th component. Now we define
Like in the simplicial case, the sign comes from the transposition. We can avoid explicit signs by assigning to its orientation line . Now from an orientation on , we induce an orientation on the boundary, so we can set
and define the map by simply restricting orientation to the boundary. The advantage of this secondary approach is that we can see that topologically instead of combinatorially. On a manifold with corners, when we consider the intersection of two facets, the two restrictions are clearly opposite to each other, as in Figure 3.2.
Now for , we clearly have an inclusion . Then define to be the quotient . Note that this is different from . If two maps agree away from but are different in , then they correspond to different elements of .
Corollary 3.8.1.
There exists a long exact sequence
This comes from the definition of the singular chain complex as a quotient complex.
Functoriality is clear at the chain level. For , the map of chains is simply , and checking that everything is well-defined is easy.
Now we check the dimension axiom. First, note that and otherwise. Then in the chain complex
we see that
and thus when we pass to homology, we see that everything vanishes except in degree .
To check additivity, we simply see that
because is connected. Then we pass to homology.
This leaves homotopy invariance, excision, and weak homotopy. Homotopy invariance will be proved by using the acyclic model theorem or by using prisms. Excision follows from barycentric subdivision, and weak homotopy is proved using cellular approximation.
First we will prove that the homology of a contractible space is trivial. If is contractible to , then there exists such that and . We want to associate to this a homotopy between and
Here a homotopy between is a map such that . This is given by the diagram
Here, the map is simply given by collapsing one of the interval segments. Now we note that , where the last is the constant -simplex at . Now we obtain that and thus they are homotopic. As a corollary, this gives an isomorphism in homology.
Corollary 3.8.2.
If is contractible, then is isomorphic to .
Now consider the two inclusions .
Lemma 3.8.3.
The two maps are homotopic.
Proof.
This is easy to see on by sending every to the component of its image. Then the isomorphism on homology is clear. Now consider the functors . We see that is free and is acyclic, so by the acyclic model theorem, any natural transformations are chain homotopic. □
Note that a direct proof of this uses the subdivision of the prism into simplices. The idea is that the map has domain not a simplex, but there are maps . Then we send
Next, we use the fact that to give the fact that .
To prove excision, let and suppose their interiors cover . We will show that . Then consider the subcomplex given by such that or . We have the diagram
By definition, we see that . Now we need to prove that is a quasi-isomorphism, and we will do this using barycentric subdivision. This defines a chain map , and so we obtain a map given by iterating until all are excisive.
We will now fill in some details about the acyclic model theorem. This generalizes the idea that if is a free module over a ring with basis , then any map is specified by the values . For chain complexes, we need additionally .
Definition 3.8.4.
A functor is free if there exist models such that is free (as a graded -module) with basis indexed over all models and maps .
Example 3.8.5.
The singular chain functor is free with models .
Definition 3.8.6.
A functor is acyclic if for all . This means the homology of the models is supported in degree .
Here, for the singular chain functor, we know that all are contractible, and thus is acyclic. However, we need to prove this explicitly without appealing to homotopy invariance.
Theorem 3.8.7.
If is free and is acyclic, then every natural transformation lifts uniquely up to chain homotopy. In other words, we can find a natural transformation and any two such choices are chain homotopic.
This arises in our proof of homotopy invariance, where if we consider the map , we can see that this is the same on homology as the identity.
Now we will prove that if is a weak homotopy equivalence, then the induced map on is an isomorphism. By the use of the mapping cylinder, it suffices to consider an inclusion, so if is -connected, then is an isomorphism for .
For each , choose a homotopy from the identity to a simplex in . In fact, if is surjective, we can always take a homotopy to make lie in .
Inductively, we will get . Starting with -simlices, the union of with defines an element of . Now we can proceed by induction, and therefore we have is an isomorphism for . Letting , the we see that depends only on the weak homotopy type.
3.9 Comparison of Homology and Homotopy
Now going back to cellular homology, we know that if is -connected, then . To prove this, use the fact that the Moore space is an -connected approximation of .
For example, if , then we get and for . For , the homology is actually nonzero! This is related to Steenrod operations.
To fix this, we will show that if are simply connected, then is a weak homotopy equivalence if and only if it induces an isomorphism on homology. Combining this with the Whitehead theorem, we obtain
Corollary 3.9.1.
If are simply connected CW-complexes, then is a homotopy equivalence if and only if it induces an isomorphism on homology.
Note that the simple connectivity assumption is essential because there exist groups with but is nontrivial. This can be resolved by generalizing homology to homology with local coefficients, where the input is a local system. Also note that this result does not say that if then . We can find with isomorphic homology, but this is not induced by any map. An example of such spaces is .
3.10 Homology with Coefficients
Consider . Then the homology of this is . One reason to consider this is to obtain better structure than when we use -coefficients. For example, is much nicer than . The same is true for the lens space with -coefficients.
A natural problem is to compute given . The answer is purely algebraic. If we consider the chain complex , the homologies are . However, if we tensor with , we obtain . The first comes from and the other one comes from the derived functor. In fact, there is only one derived functor because all abelian groups have a two-step free resolution. Now we define
where is a projective resolution of . The key facts are and if .
Now all of this is the same for graded abelian groups, but instead of resolving each component, we can instead pick a free chain complex with as its homology. If is a chain complex of free abelian groups, then
Now if is a topological space, we have
and in fact this exact sequence splits. Note that this splitting is not natural in . This means that we can compute all torsion in from . The idea is that every two copies of in consecutive degrees give rise to one copy in the higher degree if they don’t come from the homology for arbitrary . Now we can consider . The free part of contributes a copy of on the left and on the right, and so these will stabilize for arbitrary . (Here we assume is a finite CW complex).
Remark 3.10.1.
This reconstruction is not canonical.
4 Cohomology
A cohomology theory is a functor together with natural transformations such that
- 1.
The sequence
is exact.
- 2.
If , then the map is an isomorphism.
Just like with homology, we can add two axioms:
- 3.
(Additivity) .
- 4.
(Dimension) vanishes when .
If all of these hold, then is determined by its value on CW complexes and agrees with ordinary cohomology. A key difference with is that the map
is not always an isomorphism when are cofibrations. The error term is , which is the derived functor. Here, the sequence
is exact.
Now we will discuss constructions of cohomology theories. Recall that we have prespectra, which are sequences of spaces with maps . Now the prespectrum is an -spectrum if the induced map is a homotopy equivalence. For example, . Now let be an -spectrum. Then we can define . Because we assumed is an -spectrum, we have
Another approach is to use singular homology with coefficients in an abelian group . Define with differential . Then the cohomology of this complex is denoted by and is called singular cohomology. This agrees with for spaces homotopy equivalent to CW complexes by the same argument as for CW complexes.
Now for a CW complex, we can take and take the cohomology. This is called cellular homology, so in some sense is the “derived dual” of .
4.1 Multiplicativity
For singular chains, define
This defines a product on the set of singular chains. The meaning is that given a choice of an approximation of the diagonal, should be . Intuitively, we want to make the diagram
work in a simplicial manner. Now we can check that the cup product makes a differential graded algebra. To do this, we check the graded Leibniz rule
Passing to cohomology, we see that is a graded algebra. In fact, we have graded-commutativity, which says
Warning: this equality is not true at the chain level. In fact, there is no way to construct the cup product that makes the chain a commutative dg-algebra, which leads to the theory of Steenrod operations. We can actually derive all of this from the homotopical point of view by noting that if is a ring, then
induces a map
If we want an algebraic structure on homology, recall that we have a natural map . Now we consider the diagonal map , which gives a map . Unfortunately, there is no way to obtain a coproduct because the Kunneth formula has an extra term. However, if the homology of is free, then there is a coproduct. The other problem here is that coproducts are unintuitive (even if they are probably the same for a computer).
Next, we will show that is a module over . In the setting of spectra, a homology class is a map and a cohomology class is a map . The only way to do this is
In fact, there are other products, like the slant product. In the singular theory, the formula for is given by
This defines a chain map, so it descende to homology, and we obtain a map satisfying
Now we can axiomatize this setting as a (co)-homology theory equipped with cap products. If are such that are ordinary, then this is determined by . Now we are ready to state Poincaré duality.
Theorem 4.1.1.
If is a closed manifold of dimension , then there exists a class , then the map
is an isomorphism.
Remark 4.1.2.
We can remove the compactness assumption using compactly supported homology (or the one-point compactification) and we can allow boundaries by using relative homology.
To state the result for general homology theories, we need the local system of orientations. Recall that . Then we have suspension isomorphisms . Suppose has a distinguished element .
Definition 4.1.3.
An -orientation of is a class (called the fundamental class) whose restriction to is for all points in .
Proposition 4.1.4 (Poincaré Duality).
If is an -orientation of a closed manifold , then the cap product is an isomorphism.
Now, we can use Mayer-Vietoris to analyze the problem of the existence of orientations. Orientations restrict along open inclusions. First, if , then we can define a notion of an orientation of along to be a class such that the image of in is for all points in .
Next, this is functorial for inclusions, as in if , then an orientation along induces one along . Every point has an open neighborhood along which has an -orientation, which is just a coordinate chart.
We will now use Mayer-Vietoris to produce
and so we need and to agree.
Lemma 4.1.5.
Every has a orientation. Moreover, for .
Proof of this is by taking a cover and running the above argument noting that in characteristic . However, there is not always a -orientation, where the classic example is the Möbius strip.
4.2 Proof of Poincaré duality
Let be a compact manifold with fundamental class . First, if we have an open neighborhood, we can cap with the image of in to get . Now we will consider compact subsets of . Define
If we take a represented cohomology theory, then this is isomorphic to . Unfortunately, this is false for singular cohomology, where the counterexample is the pseudocircle.
Now capping with the image of gives . Here, we use the diagram
Theorem 4.2.1 (Alexander Duality).
If is compact, the above map is an isomorphism.
Proof.
First, we will establish that if Alexander duality holds for , then it holds for . To see this, we use the Mayer-Vietoris sequences
note that two of the vertical arrows are isomorphisms, and then use the five lemma.
The next step is to prove continuity. If Alexander duality holds for compact sets , we will prove that it holds for . To see this, we note that commutes with colimits, so that . Also, we use the definition of Cech cohomology.
Finally, we have reduced to subsets of , and the result clearly holds for convex subsets of , so to complete the argument, we use the fact that any compact set can be written
Thus we write , and this can be handled by compactness (reduce to a finite cover), so now we have a reduction to . But then we have . □
Corollary 4.2.2.
For compact , we have .
Proof.
Set and use Alexander duality. □
Here are some consequences of Poincare duality:
- 1.
If is an odd-dimensional manifold, then . If we use field coefficients, we know that , and when is odd then have different parity, so they cancel in the alternating sum.
- 2.
Assume is an orientable manifold. If we consider the diagram
For ordinary cohomology, commutativity follows from either the actual cup and cap product formulas or from Eilenberg-Maclane spaces. This tells us that the cup product gives us a perfect pairing . This tells us that cohomology is a graded algebra with a map such that is a perfect pairing. This is sometimes called a Frobenius algebra or a Calabi-Yau algebra.
It is better to do this at the chain level for singular cohomology. Here, we consider the map
- 3.
Consider the case when has dimension . Then we get a map . For odd, we see that , and thus we have an even antisymmetric pairing, which is a symplectic form. This can be decomposed into pieces that look like . This implies that the Euler characteristic is even.
If , then can be arbitrary. For example, and . We can also produce -manifolds of arbitrary Euler characteristic from this process by taking linear combinations of and .
Now consider manifolds with boundary . The statement of Poincaré duality for manifolds with boundary is that the fundamental class lives in and capping gives us an isomorphism . Also, is orientable and is the image of under the boundary homomorphism. Now capping with gives a commutative diagram
If we consider the middle dimension cohomology where , we have a commutative diagram
Note that . Also, , so . Moreover, the map
is zero by exactness. Dualizing, we see that the pairing
vanishes, so the intersection pairing vanishes on and thus the pairing is isotropic. If we do the same thing for , we obtain a Lagrangian subspace.
Now consider a Riemann surface embedded in . This bounds some manifold . There are some curves bounding discs and some curves bounding “holes” of the surface, and these are the symplectic basis for the intersection pairing. In summary, the map has half-dimensional image. Unfortunately, we can make the homology of more complicated by adding stuff, so we cannot say anything about the entire homology of .
Finally, suppose that . Over , a nondegenerate form splits into positive and negative-definite parts .
Definition 4.2.3.
Define the sign of a manifold as .
Theorem 4.2.4.
If , then .
Proof.
The image of is half-dimensional, but the pairing vanishes on it (because lives in degree ), and then by linear algebra the only way this can happen is when . □
This means there are manifolds which cannot be boundaries (all -manifolds are boundaries of -manifolds), such as . Here, the form is and is positive definite.